Intolerance, arrogance, insensitivity and ignorance constitute a really bad cluster of personal attributes. In the case of an aspiring or sitting leader, it is just not acceptable. Each culture has its own manifestations of cultural practices, gestures and facial expressions. In western culture, sitting on chairs or couches is the norm. Asians generally, even now, still feel more comfortable sitting on the floor, in one or more of the yoga-based crossed-legs poses; whether they still live in the land of their ancestors or in the Diaspora. Is the act of sitting on a chair superior to that of sitting on a mat or a peerha?
The Japanese greet each other by bowing from the waist. In fact, in the dojo, before the start of the training session, from a kneeling position, the karateka or judoka would bow very deeply with the head touching the back of the open palms which rest on the floor. So when the Japanese martial arts masters come to Trinidad to grade the locals and the proper protocol is followed, would it be sensible to say that we are kissing the dust of the feet of the Japanese? The pope and indeed priests of the Catholic Church, on a yearly basis, would kneel before 12 people and wash their feet. The touching, washing and drying of the feet are considered to be a great act of humility. Curtseying to royalty, which is in effect bowing by bending the knees, is standard practice and is reflective of tradition, protocol and just plain good manners. Would the gentleman rant and rave about kowtowing to the queen?
The practice of touching the feet of parents, elders and gurus constitutes a many-thousand-year-old practice in Hindu and Indian culture. It is reflective and indicative of respect and humility on the part of the doer. Humility and respect are essential attributes and core values of any civilised society. While the external manifestations of these values may take various forms, they do exist in all civilisations. It is thus particularly regrettable that the Leader of the Opposition chose to describe the touching the feet of the elderly President of India by the Prime Minister of T&T as "kissing the feet." This description is loaded with insinuations and innuendoes, none pleasant. No doubt he was playing to the gallery but in so doing did he expose how he felt about Hindu cultural practices?
It would behove the Leader of the Opposition to tell the Hindus of this country if he thinks that touching the feet of an elder is not an acceptable practice. He should also indicate which other Hindu practices he finds unacceptable. Further, he should articulate for the national and international communities whether he would expect people of the Hindu persuasion holding office under his regime, should his party win a future election, to dispense with their religious duties and cultural norms. All governments must be held responsible and accountable for public monies spent. So there can be no argument about the right to question the size of the delegation and the value of the outcomes. The criticising of what was clearly a spontaneous act of traditional cultural expression and the tone of the criticism make one rather uncomfortable; made more so by the fact that we are a plural society, one in which the Constitution which he is sworn to uphold boldly declares that all creeds and races find an equal place.
Leaders must demonstrate a higher level of humanity, humility and cultural sensitivity. The present episode is exceedingly distasteful and has served to add fuel to the fires that threaten the cohesion of our diverse society. One expects leaders to seek to strengthen, not weaken, the bonds of inter-social harmonious relations. The Leader of the Opposition should take the lead from his former political leader and apologise to the nation for this unacceptable remark. He should seriously consider a programme of meditative and reflective practice as he comes across as a particularly angry individual. Hindus feel offended by the remarks made by the Leader of the Opposition He should withdraw them and apologise to the nation.
• Prakash Persad is the director of Swaha Inc