The hope for an extended ceasefire in the war by the Israel Defense Force (IDF) against Hamas, more correctly the assault on Gaza and the West Bank, and the murders of an estimated 30,000 Palestinians, are caught in a trap of contradictions.
At the same time that the negotiators from the USA, Qatar and Egypt are meeting in Paris, and with US President Joseph Biden expressing the expectation that an agreement on the extended cessation of the killings of Palestinians will be arrived at by the weekend, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is warning that a ground offensive by the IDF is about to be launched. Further, he has repeated his position taken at the start of the Hamas October bombing and counter offensive from Israel, that the war will not end until Hamas is wiped out, never again to launch raids on Israel. To allow for the return of the approximately 110 hostages still held by Hamas, PM Netanyahu is said to be seeking a two-month ceasefire and the bodies of Israelis who are reported to have died during the bombing of the IDF.
Hamas is reported to have rejected the temporary ceasefire offer, requiring instead a permanent end to the hostilities, and the release of thousands of Palestinians, many of whom have been held in Israeli prisons for years. Hamas also wants its leaders in Gaza to be able to remain in the area, and control of Gaza.
The question remains whether US President Biden has suasion over PM Netanyahu, who is driven by his desire to hold on to power, by seeking revenge on Hamas/Palestinians, and to retrieve the hostages to please Israeli families demanding a return of friends and family from Hamas.
PM Netanyahu has clearly rebuffed the overtures of US Secretary of State Antony Blinken during his several trips to the area, while holding fast to his mission to wipe-out Hamas fighters, caring little about the murders and crippling of tens of thousands of civilians, an estimated 70 per cent of whom are said to be women and children.
How does a country enter into an agreement to stop the bombing, killing and displacement of Palestinians, at the same time that its government says it intends to move its troops on the ground to wage relentless war, which inevitably will result in further and increased killings of innocent civilians?
There surely is a major contradiction between the readiness to seek peace, whatever the length of it, and what Prime Minister Netanyahu is hell bent on doing. Further to the objectives of the Israeli government, is the reality of starvation said by three United Nations (UN) officials to be imminent as a minimum number of food deliveries are allowed.
“Unfortunately, as grim as the picture we see today is, there is every possibility for further deterioration,” observed Ramesh Rajasingham, director of Co-ordination at the Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs, United Nations. He said at least 576,000 people in Gaza – one-quarter of the population – are “one step away from famine”.
At the level of diplomacy, the United States' continued efforts to block every move at the UN Security Council to end the war also do not help.
Whatever the immediate horrors of the Palestinian peoples, the long-term consequences of the effective destruction of Gaza are far greater.