JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Monday, March 17, 2025

Tar sands in T&T?

by

20130814

Both lo­cal and in­ter­na­tion­al en­vi­ron­men­tal­ists have been warn­ing against the dan­gers of lo­cal tar sands min­ing for years. Tar sands or oil sands are clay, bi­tu­men and dirt de­posits which can be mined and re­fined to pro­duce syn­thet­ic oil.

The re­port Tar Sands in T&T? A look at the dirt­i­est oil from Cana­da to T&T, writ­ten by Cana­di­an en­vi­ron­men­tal­ist Mac­don­ald Stains­by, out­lines what he be­lieves is ev­i­dence that con­sec­u­tive T&T gov­ern­ments have planned and are plan­ning to be­gin min­ing tar sands lo­cal­ly. The re­port al­so out­lines the en­vi­ron­men­tal dan­gers as­so­ci­at­ed with tar sands.

Stains­by has vis­it­ed Trinidad four times since 2009.

How­ev­er, Min­is­ter of En­er­gy and En­er­gy Af­fairs, Kevin Ram­nar­ine, in a tele­phone in­ter­view, said the Gov­ern­ment has "no plans to de­vel­op the coun­try's oil sands."

Kyle de Li­ma, of Tri­ni Eco War­riors, who as­sist­ed with com­pil­ing the re­port, stands by its claims.

He said tar sand min­ing could lead to mas­sive de­for­esta­tion and pos­si­ble re­lo­ca­tion of com­mu­ni­ties.

Among the ev­i­dence cit­ed in the re­port are pub­lic state­ments from for­mer en­er­gy min­is­ters Con­rad Enill and Car­olyn Seep­er­sad Bachan and Prime Min­is­ter Kam­la Per­sad Bisses­sar.

The re­port al­so cites the rein­tro­duc­tion of the Roy­al Bank of Cana­da in­to T&T, a mem­o­ran­dum of un­der­stand­ing with an In­di­an en­er­gy com­pa­ny, Re­liance En­er­gy, for bi­tu­men up­grad­ing, the re­fur­bish­ment of the Petrotrin re­fin­ery, the con­struc­tion of the San Fer­nan­do to Point Fortin high­way and the open­ing of a de­sali­na­tion plant in Point Fortin.

Ac­cord­ing to de Li­ma, RBC is the largest fi­nancier of tar sands in Cana­da. At­tempts to ob­tain a com­ment from RBC on any prospec­tive fi­nanc­ing of tar sands op­er­a­tions in this coun­try were un­suc­cess­ful.

De Li­ma said the main fo­cus of his or­gan­i­sa­tion was to ed­u­cate the pop­u­la­tion and al­low peo­ple to make their own de­ci­sions.

There were 2,000 copies of the re­port print­ed and dis­trib­uted through­out Trinidad, in­clud­ing to the ar­eas in South­west Trinidad where there are high lev­els of bi­tu­men de­posits.

These ar­eas in­clude Ves­signy, La Brea, Guapo and Par­ry­lands.

Yet, whether or not this ev­i­dence leads to ac­tu­al tar sand min­ing is still up for de­bate.

Ac­cord­ing to the re­port: "This is not to say all or even any of the pro­posed in­dus­tri­al projects in the south­west are specif­i­cal­ly or even pri­mar­i­ly for tar sands de­vel­op­ment.

"How­ev­er, every sin­gle one of these in­fra­struc­ture projects make tar sands cheap­er, more prac­ti­cal and more vi­able than with­out them."

Ram­nar­ine did not com­ment on state­ments made by Seep­er­sad-Bachan or Prime Min­is­ter Per­sad-Bisses­sar.

How­ev­er, he said the agree­ment be­tween Re­liance En­er­gy and the T&T gov­ern­ment is no in­di­ca­tion that there are plans to mine tar sands.

He said: "In the oil in­dus­try, bi­tu­men is not on­ly found in tar sands. Bi­tu­men is al­so a by-prod­uct of the re­fin­ing of crude oil. In fact, we cur­rent­ly pro­duce bi­tu­men at Pointe-a-Pierre and we are not min­ing tar sands are we?"

The ar­gu­men­ta­gainst tar sands

Stains­by's re­port used Cana­da as an ex­am­ple of some of the dev­as­tat­ing ef­fects tar sand min­ing has on com­mu­ni­ties.

The Athabas­ca tar sands in Al­ber­ta, Cana­da, are wide­ly re­gard­ed as the largest de­posits of bi­tu­men in the world. In the re­port, he points to the Fort MacK­ay and Fort Chip­weyan in­dige­nous com­mu­ni­ties which are sur­round­ed by min­ing op­er­a­tions.

Ac­cord­ing to the re­port, in Fort MacK­ay "a large num­ber of chil­dren in the com­mu­ni­ty are suf­fer­ing from breath­ing prob­lems such as em­phy­se­ma and asth­ma."

In Fort Chipewyan, which has a pop­u­la­tion of 1200, the re­port says a min­i­mum of two and pos­si­bly more than six cas­es of a rare can­cer­ous dis­ease, cholan­gio­car­ci­no­ma, have oc­curred.

Ac­cord­ing to Stains­by, this can­cer should ap­pear on­ly once in 100,000 peo­ple. Oth­er can­cers have al­so af­fect­ed res­i­dents and a study by the provin­cial gov­ern­ment con­clud­ed that can­cer rates were 30 per cent high­er than ex­pect­ed in 2009.

Can­cers are caused by the in­ges­tion or in­hala­tion of tox­ic ma­te­ri­als used in the process of tar sand min­ing, the re­port says. These ma­te­ri­als in­clude ar­senic, cad­mi­um, lead, nick­el, mer­cury and poly­cyclic aro­mat­ic hy­dro­car­bons.

These ma­te­ri­als con­t­a­m­i­nate wa­ter sup­plies, seep in­to soil and are re­leased in­to the air. Fort Chipewyan is 200 kilo­me­tres from tar sands op­er­a­tions but re­mains neg­a­tive­ly af­fect­ed.

In the area of South­west Trinidad, where fam­i­ly homes and small busi­ness­es are sit­u­at­ed on top of and sur­round­ing bi­tu­men de­posits, the health is­sues could be much more detri­men­tal.

La Brea MP Fitzger­ald Jef­fery be­lieves tar sand min­ing is a "bad idea" due to the neg­a­tive ef­fects on the en­vi­ron­ment.

But Jef­fery said in an in­ter­view that he's "weary of all these grandiose projects" which nev­er come to fruition in south­west Trinidad, par­tic­u­lar­ly La Brea.

In 2006, there were plans to build an alu­mini­um smelter plant in La Brea, which en­vi­ron­men­tal­ists al­so protest­ed against.

The plant, Jef­frey said, was one of 16 pro­posed projects that have failed to come through in re­cent years.

He be­lieves some ma­jor in­fra­struc­tur­al project is nec­es­sary to al­le­vi­ate un­em­ploy­ment in the area, how­ev­er.

A res­i­dent of the La Brea, Travis Joseph, said there should be a bal­ance be­tween de­vel­op­men­tal needs and en­vi­ron­men­tal sus­tain­abil­i­ty. Al­though Joseph said he still need­ed more in­for­ma­tion about tar sands be­fore mak­ing a de­ci­sion on its vi­a­bil­i­ty, he com­pared this to the pro­posed smelter plant.

"My ini­tial thought about the smelter was that smelters in oth­er parts of the world are away from hu­man oc­cu­pan­cy so that they pose lit­tle stress to hu­man life," he said in an in­ter­view.

"Based on the in­fo that I re­ceived when there were plans to build a smelter here though, once it was prop­er­ly main­tained there was a buffer sys­tem that would min­imise the ef­fects on hu­man life. I guess once it's prop­er­ly main­tained it would be al­right."

De Li­ma, how­ev­er, dis­agrees.

"We can't con­tain a tar sand mine in Trinidad and we need to un­der­stand the process. The sol­vent that they add to the tar sand brew when they're mak­ing it is ex­treme­ly tox­ic and we don't have the aquifers in the area to off­set it and pro­vide clean wa­ter. It (tar sands) can present a very se­ri­ous threat to the area," he said.

What is tar sands?

Tar sands or oil sands are bi­tu­men de­posits mixed with clay and sand.

Bi­tu­men is a black vis­cous ob­tained nat­u­ral­ly or as a residue from pe­tro­le­um dis­til­la­tion.

How is it mined?

Tar sands can be mined in two ways. The first is a low im­pact sur­face min­ing. The sec­ond is called in-situ. In-situ is pri­mar­i­ly a process called Steam As­sist­ed Grav­i­ty Drainage. In this process, ar­eas are cleared of for­est cov­er­age then suc­tions off wa­ter from the sur­face area. Af­ter all wa­ter is re­moved, "over­bur­den" or soil, roots etc, are re­moved and col­lect­ed. The bi­tu­men is ex­tract­ed (dig­ging can get as deep as 600 feet) and tak­en to a slur­ry. The slur­ry us­es nat­ur­al gas to heat fresh wa­ter and mix tar sands un­til the clay and dirt are sep­a­rat­ed from the bi­tu­men. It is es­ti­mat­ed that three to five bar­rels of fresh wa­ter are con­t­a­m­i­nat­ed dur­ing the pro­duc­tion of one bar­rel of syn­thet­ic oil.

Tar Sands Talk in T&T:

In Feb­ru­ary 2009, then en­er­gy min­is­ter Con­rad Enill an­nounced that Cab­i­net had agreed to give Petrotrin li­cense to ex­plore tar-sands in south Trinidad. Es­ti­mates sug­gest­ed that al­most two bil­lion bar­rels of crude oil could be ex­tract­ed from the ex­ist­ing bi­tu­men de­posits.

In a Feb­ru­ary 2011 ad­dress at the open­ing of the Na­tion­al En­er­gy Pol­i­cy con­sul­ta­tions in San­gre Grande, then en­er­gy min­is­ter Car­olyn Seep­er­sad-Bachan men­tioned tar sands as a vi­able so­lu­tion to in­creas­ing crude oil pro­duc­tion in T&T. In the ad­dress, she ac­knowl­edged the en­vi­ron­men­tal chal­lenges to tar sands, but not­ed that there were in­ter­na­tion­al ex­am­ples of safe min­ing.

In Ju­ly 2011, the Na­tion­al Gas Com­pa­ny and the Na­tion­al En­er­gy Cor­po­ra­tion signed a mem­o­ran­dum of un­der­stand­ing with Re­liance Group, of In­dia, for a bi­tu­men up­grad­ing plant to pro­duce syn­thet­ic crude oil. The pro­posed site for the plant was the La Brea In­dus­tri­al Es­tate.

At the Sum­mit of the Amer­i­c­as in Co­lum­bia in April 2012, Prime Min­is­ter Kam­la Per­sad-Bisses­sar par­tic­i­pat­ed in Cari­com-Cana­da talks with Cana­di­an Prime Min­is­ter Stephen Harp­er. On her re­turn from the sum­mit, Per­sad-Bisses­sar said the gov­ern­ment was look­ing in­to a tar sands ven­ture in which Cana­di­an ex­per­tise would be ap­plied.

Three weeks af­ter Per­sad-Bisses­sar's an­nounce­ment, en­vi­ron­men­tal­ists warned against the dan­gers of tar sands. Tri­ni Eco War­riors host­ed the first of four sem­i­nars on the is­sue in Ch­agua­nas. Mac­Don­ald Stains­by pre­sent­ed at the sem­i­nar. En­vi­ron­men­tal­ist Dr Wayne Kum­baloi al­so spoke out against Gov­ern­ment plans for tar sands.

In Ju­ly 2013 a de­sali­na­tion plant opened in Point Fortin. En­vi­ron­men­tal­ists such as Kyle de Li­ma be­lieved this was a sign that tar sands projects were in the works. De­sali­na­tion plants could pro­vide the heavy wa­ter sup­ply need­ed to re­fine bi­tu­men found in tar sands.

Protests Around The World

Protests against tar sands have grown in var­i­ous parts of the world, but main­ly in Cana­da and the US.

Most re­cent­ly, four mem­bers of the Michi­gan Coali­tion Against Tar Sands were ar­rest­ed and are fac­ing felony charges for their protest ac­tion.

The pro­tes­tors go to court next month.

In June, the UK Tar Sands Net­work host­ed a demon­stra­tion dur­ing the vis­it of Cana­di­an Prime Min­is­ter Stephen Harp­er to Eng­land. Ear­li­er this month, pro­tes­tors demon­strat­ed at Se­ba­go Lake State Park in Que­bec, af­ter a train car­ry­ing crude oil from the north­ern US ex­plod­ed.

The pro­tes­tors want to put an end to tran­spi­ra­tion of crude oil and drew at­ten­tion to the threat posed to the Se­ba­go Lake and park.

To find out more about the glob­al move­ment against tar sands, you can vis­it Stains­by's Web site: www.oil­sand­struth.org. You can al­so fol­low "Tri­ni Eco War­riors" on Face­book.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored