JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Wednesday, February 26, 2025

NCBA under fire as All Stars win

by

20140307

A de­ci­sion by the Na­tion­al Car­ni­val Bands As­so­ci­a­tion's (NC­BA) judges to deduct points from a re­port­ed 25 large bands for fail­ing to start at their first judg­ing point in Wood­brook, is threat­en­ing to cast a shad­ow over Neal and Massy Trinidad All Stars' Band of the Year vic­to­ry.In fact, the de­ci­sion may have to be re­scind­ed, as sev­er­al af­fect­ed bands yes­ter­day sig­nalled their in­ten­tion to take the mat­ter to court if the NC­BA does not pro­vide them with their score­sheets, nul­li­fy the de­ci­sion and re­count the scores.Trinidad All Stars was yes­ter­day named the NC­BA's Band of the Year win­ner for its pre­sen­ta­tion of Sailors on Shore Leave at a Trop­i­cal Fi­es­ta. The band, which lost this year's Na­tion­al Panora­ma fi­nal by one point to Phase II Pan Groove, scored 2,365 points, beat­ing Pa­parrazi Car­ni­val's Cen­ter­stage (2,048) and Lega­cy's Na­ture's Touch (1,976) in­to sec­ond and third re­spec­tive­ly. The re­sult al­so marked the first time in decades a tra­di­tion­al steel­band had won the large band mas cat­e­go­ry.

How­ev­er, Tri­ni Rev­ellers band­leader Dave Cameron was among the first to query the re­sults af­ter learn­ing their por­tray­al of The Sul­tan's Palace (1,585) had placed fourth. While con­grat­u­lat­ing Trinidad All Stars on the win, Cameron said he sent a let­ter to the chief judge ask­ing for his score­sheet, as he be­lieved there were dis­crep­an­cies in the judg­ing, and would de­cid­ed his next move there­after."I can't un­der­stand how the con­ven­tion­al bands could be so far back, es­pe­cial­ly when Trinidad All Stars Steel Or­ches­tra have been com­ing out with the same thing every year. But I can't do any­thing but con­grat­u­late All Stars be­cause they won," Cameron said."I in this busi­ness long time. I be­lieved I may have lost some marks, but the NC­BA don't come out and tell you any­thing. They just say, 'Take that,' and I am not tak­ing that."How­ev­er, the T&T Guardian sub­se­quent­ly learned that sev­er­al bands had been de­duct­ed as much as 50 points for not start­ing at Adam Smith Square, Wood­brook, which the NC­BA des­ig­nat­ed as the first judg­ing point along a new route this year.

25 bands af­fect­ed

Con­tact­ed yes­ter­day, band­leader Ros­alind Gabriel con­firmed her band was among 25 which start­ed in down­town PoS. She said Dune Ali's Car­ni­val Play­ers Stephen De­r­ick's D' Mi­das T&T and Vanes­sa Forde's Clas­six Pro­duc­tions were al­so de­duct­ed points for start­ing down­town. She said she would have a clear­er idea to­day of the ex­act num­ber of bands af­fect­ed.Gabriel ad­mit­ted she did not fol­low the NC­BA's des­ig­nat­ed route, which start­ed in Wood­brook and end­ed at the Queen's Park Sa­van­nah. In­stead, she opt­ed to use the route pre­scribed by Port-of-Spain may­or Ray­mond Tim Kee, which start­ed down­town and end­ed at the Sa­van­nah."If you dis­obey the route you lose 50 points. I am not in the re­sults any­where from one to five or even one to six. Every year I win a ti­tle, so for me not plac­ing at all is im­pos­si­ble. I am not the on­ly one who suf­fered this fate," Gabriel said.She said her de­ci­sion to start down­town was based on a num­ber of is­sues, in­clud­ing mas­quer­aders hav­ing to trav­el to Wood­brook up­on reach­ing Port-of-Spain.

"We have bands com­ing from as far as Ma­yaro and it is un­fair for them when they reach City Gate to leave down­town to trav­el with their cos­tumes and what have you to Wood­brook."The wind fac­tor was an­oth­er is­sue, traf­fic con­ges­tion and Wood­brook res­i­dents hav­ing to un­der­go an­oth­er day of Car­ni­val," Gabriel added.She said she re­tained at­tor­ney Michael Quam­i­na and in­tends to ob­tain a copy of her score­sheet be­fore con­sid­er­ing her op­tions.Al­so con­tact­ed last evening, pres­i­dent of the T&T Car­ni­val Bands As­so­ci­a­tion Ger­ard Weekes con­firmed sev­er­al of his mem­bers were af­fect­ed by the de­ci­sion. He said while his band was not af­fect­ed, as he fol­lowed the pre­scribed route, it should not mat­ter how bands like Gabriel's got to the Sa­van­nah once they passed all the judg­ing points.

"It doesn't mat­ter whether she (Gabriel) start­ed in down­town or at Wood­brook. Once she got to the sa­van­nah she should have been equal­ly judged and she has a right to re­quest her score­sheet," Weekes said."For Tri­ni Rev­ellers it's a dif­fer­ent case. They are re­quest­ing their score­sheet to de­ter­mine where they lost points and why."He added, "Some­one needs to say who are the judges and what cri­te­ria they used. ...The NC­BA must be held ac­count­able." He said while he had noth­ing against All Stars win­ning, he won­dered how they could emerge on top in the cre­ativ­i­ty cat­e­go­ry."What they did cer­tain­ly was by no means cre­ative. Buy­ing a sailor hat and putting two ap­ples in it is not cre­ative. That says a lot, es­pe­cial­ly to us who have spent many tire­less hours pro­duc­ing," Weekes said.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored