‘Illiterate’ man jailed for ganja

Published: 21 Nov 2009

Being a school drop-out and illiterate are no excuses for breaking the law, says Justice Anthony Carmona.

The judge expressed this view as he sentenced 30-year-old Garrison Adams, of Moruga, to five years’ imprisonment for possession of 20.5 kilogrammes of marijuana for the purpose of trafficking. Adams’ attorney Mewahlal Chatoor, in a stirring mitigation plea, said his client had left school in Form Two, lived in poverty and was illiterate. Chatoor also noted that there was a 30 per cent drop-out rate in the school system. Alluding to this, Carmona said although progressive strides continued to be made in the education system, the issue of school drop-out was a serious one.

Carmona, in the San Fernando Second Criminal Court, said: “No child in T&T must be allowed to drop out of school...Parents must be held accountable.” The judge also noted that there was an endemic problem of marijuana cultivation and drug addiction in Moruga. Very often, he said, drug addiction and trafficking result in the spiralling crime rate in the country. In determining sentence, the judge said he considered that Adams spent eight prison years awaiting trial because he was unable to secure bail. But, he said the sentence must reflect the court’s abhorrence to such offences and as a deterrence to would-be offenders. The judge commended PC Byron Lee and acting Cpl Leon Haynes for doing excellent police work.

The State’s case, led by state attorney Maureceia Joseph, was that Lee, then assigned to the Princes Town Police Station, and other officers received information in November 2003. They went to Herrera Street, Penal Rock Road, Moruga, where they hid in some bushes. Lee said he saw the accused and another man under an abandoned house throwing marijuana in large plastic bags. He said he knew the accused three years before that date. When the police ran out, he said, the men ran into a canefield and escaped. The police found five large plastic bags containing the illicit herb.

Article Tools
 

Kudos to the Judge on this

Kudos to the Judge on this case!

This ganga wielding criminal is clearly sensible enough to know what fetches a dollar (or a few hundred) these days and so a plea of 'illiteracy' was desperate and inapproriate.

If he was schooled up to form 2 then he ought to be able to read and write and by definition isn't illerate!

Failure of academic success is no excuse for resorting to crime period! Our yard-boy never went to school a day in his life, but is hard working and honest - which is why we've continued to hire him weekly, sometimes twice weekly for the past 10 years.

On a separate but related issue some parents and beaurocrats need to realize that some children plateau at a very basic, simple level educationally (mostly related to factors created by said parents or 'parents') and this is not an excuse for condoning criminality.

In fact if you know child isn't going to qualify for 'an office job' the onus is on you to push them even harder into finding an approriate skill with which they can contribute productively to society.

The shameful thing is, this message is probably not going to be read by those folks who need to hear it most.

Interesting defense. I guess

Interesting defense. I guess lawyers make plenty money if they can come up with these creative arguments and if the court buys it then that is lagniappe.

The definition of literacy used by T&T is one that many but not all countries use .... 'age 15 and over and can read and write'.... so if he made it to Form 2 that suggests he finished Primary school and took his exams to make it to Secondary school. As for other definitions of literacy, my information says that Barbados uses .... 'age 15 and over has ever attended school' .... ; Guyana and Jamaica use .... 'age 15 and over has ever attended school' ....; the US uses the same definition as T&T and the UK uses .... 'age 15 and over has completed five or more years of schooling' .....

So next time one of them rankings on literacy comes out remember to look at it and steups.

 
 

Feedback