Reporter faces ban from Parliament

Published: 14 Nov 2009

A local journalist created history in T&T yesterday after becoming the first reporter recommended to be banned from Parliament’s media gallery following a report from the Privileges Committee of the House of Representatives.

According to the third report of the 2009 Privileges Committee, it was concluded that a contempt had been committed by the Newsday reporter Andre Bagoo, through the premature publication of the proceedings of the committee. It followed a motion in the Lower House on July 3 by Information Minister Neil Parsanlal, who said the reported information appeared to touch on the proceedings of the Committee of Privileges, including interactions that might have taken place between the Committee and the Urban Development Corporation of Trinidad and Tobago (Udecott). The committee concluded that Bagoo and the newspaper’s publisher breached the rules of the House of Representatives and in particular Standing Order 81. The committee made four recommendations, which included that Bagoo be banned from the media gallery for the rest of the session. It also recommended Newsday publish an apology to the House of Representatives that carried equal prominence to his article and appear within pages one to three.

Committee’s members included House Speaker Barry Sinanan (chairman), Government MPs Colm Imbert, Pennelope Beckles, Christine Kangaloo, Stanford Callender and Opposition MPs Dr Roodal Moonilal, Dr Tim Gopeesingh and Kamla Persad-Bissessar. In the minority report of the three Opposition MPs, calls were made for members of the Lower House to reject the committee’s report in its entirety and amend the report by deleting the recommendation for the ban against Bagoo. Calls to Bagoo went unanswered yesterday and the T&T Guardian was informed that Newsday’s chief executive officer and Editor-in-Chief Therese Mills was not in the country.

Article Tools
 

Virgogyul Dont let this

Virgogyul
Dont let this break your spirits Andre.

I know a lot of folks who

I know a lot of folks who commented below (and elsewhere online) think this is a threat to press freedom, but is it really so? Can the media do no wrong? Is penalising a reporter for breach of the Standing Orders, which has been acknowledged by the Newsday's editor, really an example of fascism? Or are we over-reacting?

See alternative views on http://www.knowtnt.com/node/45 - and respond if you wish.

It's early days yet on this issue - maybe we should wait to get the full picture before accusing the government of heavy-handedness.

The PNM will

The PNM will prevails...

Jumbie's Watch

WISE UP T&T

WISE UP T&T -

We laugh when they do it to UNC, we don't realize that it would be out turn next. It was Mark, Goopesing and Kamla now Seethalal. It was Panday singled out from hundreds who did not comply with the Integrity Laws, now it is One Voice being singled out when many PNM marches, Cudjoe marches have been allowed to take place unimpeded.

They came for the UNC, I did not STAND UP.
They came for the media, I did not STAND UP.
They came for the Judiciary, I did not STAND UP.
They came for the Unions, I did not STAND UP.
They came for NGO's, I did not STAND UP
They came for Sat Sharma, I did not STAND UP.
They came for Rowley, I did not STAND UP.
They came for Civil Servants, Coudrey e.c.t, I did not STAND UP.
They came for Bagoo, I did not STAND UP.
When they came for me, there was no one to stand up for me.

He who laughs last laughs best. When you laugh everyone laughs with you, when you cry you cry alone.

A few years ago we were

A few years ago we were urged to boycot was it the express for a day and people did just that. The media comes under siege by all and sundry this is no different.
The express is still here and so will Mr Ragoo umpteen years from now. Each one of the parties that are in power harass the media when things are not going their way.
How different is that from coercing the nation to put an entire news paper out of action even for a day.

WHO KNOWS

WHO KNOWS -

Just like COP, The Medical Association and the Hindu Credit Union Panday and the much vilified UNC might have to accommodate the Press so that they could defend themselves in Parliament. At least they attempted to defend them in their report. I am happy to see it acknowledged, who knows who next it could be Fraser, Ali, Alexander or even Raphael.

The members of the Privilege

The members of the Privilege Committee of the House of Representatives of T&T should research why the press was called the Forth Estate . More than 25 years ago , a Speaker of the House of Assembly in Barbados , banned a reporter , Albert Brandford , of the Daily Nation , from entering the House of Assembly , for life - the ban was later rescinded .
These former colonies believe that they have inherited the Westminister System of Parliament but what they actually practice is what was handed to them from the Colonial office at Whitehall . In the 19th century , british politician Edmund Burke ,referred to the reporters in the press gallery of the House of Commons as the Fourth Estate . He said : "Yonder sits the Fourth Estate , and they are more important than them all" .
The role of the press , in Parliament (the press gallery) is to inform the masses as to what is taking place there and if the actions of the Committee appears to muzzle the press , them , the reporters should stay away as a form of peaceful protest . The members of the Privilege Committee smile from ear to ear , when the reporters communicate their speeches to the masses - yet , they are recommending that the reporter , Andre Bagoo should be banned from the media gallery for the remainder of the session . The minority report which was submitted by the 3 UNC of the committee should be supported by the members of the H-of-R .
The PNM members of the Privilege Committee do not know that the reporters in the media gallery are the eyes and ears of the MASSES - also referred to as the electorate .
"Power corrupts , absolute power corrupts ; absolutely" . Lord Acton .
ATW-Barbados .

WIGGS YOU REALLY BELIEVE

WIGGS YOU REALLY BELIEVE -

That,

The PNM members of the Privilege Committee do not know that the reporters in the media gallery are the eyes and ears of the MASSES - also referred to as the electorate.

They bloody well know that is why they do it. This is the art of political warfare, intimidation of the opposition then the press.

ATW-Barbados Please tell us

ATW-Barbados
Please tell us about police crime in Barbados. The commissioner is calling for a tribunal to deal with it. Must be serious!

http://www.nationnews.com/news/local/DOTTIN-talks-of-delays-in-disciplin...

The PNM is really trying to

The PNM is really trying to dictate history by banning Adndre Bagoo. It has a tendency to do so from time to time. Once before the PM who was at his barber having his hair cut when he heard some disturbing news that motivated him to run directly to the radio station and confront the the announcers. If the press is not allowd then the parliament perhaps is discussing classified items, in other words some sort of secret or covert items which in intended for the masses. Doesn't this smells as a tendency of dictatorship. This is typical in leftist governments.

I believe all other Media should join forces to show their solidarity for one of collegues. After all, an apology was made by the chief of Newsday as mentioned in the press,and that should be seen as sufficient for breaching the standing orders of parliament.If parliament agrees to disbar the press then closed the doors on them but don't allow them in and then say to them don't report anything in the press about this particular session. Insanity and absurdity of the highest degree.

It really smells as very authoritative or more a taste of dictatorship. In that same context Hugo Chavez revoked the license of RCN and in Ecuador Leftist Correa bannned Teleamazon from broadcasting because they were exposing the corruption of the government. Therefor, the writing is on the wall.

PM Manning and the PNM bunch

PM Manning and the PNM bunch stand in solidarity again to show that dictatorship rule. Many PNM ministers have grown use to their outlandish lifestyle, even when they know that some of the decisions made are wrong they will support it out of fear. Way to go T&T. We still have some freedom left, use it to vote wisely. Manning knows the tool to use, when the people shout give them something 'free'. For the minority that accept to eat the bread the devil need, the populace will pay the ultimate sacrifice. Manning probaby secured a home in Panama already as the table will turn, how long is this piece of string.

Just another attack on

Just another attack on freedom of the press in a developing police state. The Press must take a stand and speak out and speak up. Our democracy is at stake as this out of control regime continues to trample on our rights and freedoms. Let us hear what MATT has to say. Today it's Newsday, tomorrow the Guardian and the following day the Express.

When Panday ill advisedly attacked the Guardian's Madeira there was widespread outrage. Let there be consistency.

Virgogyul MATT has already

Virgogyul

MATT has already commented on this (see today's Express). In brief, they have described the ban as harsh, which I agree with because the Newsday has since apologised for the breach, yet the Priviledges Committee still saw it fit to ban Mr. Bagoo, who coincidentally has been exposing a lot of UDECOTT's business.

We next I guess. Go on Neil,

We next I guess. Go on Neil, play yourself. At least, for now.

I was sent an interesting

I was sent an interesting link by a friend. Entitled “Fourteen Defining Characteristics Of Fascism”, Dr. Lawrence Britt identified some of the characteristics by examining several fascist regimes.

It is interesting that I identified the following points I consider to be applicable to the PNM and Pa-trick's governance. Keep in mind that these are only what I consider, and to get the rest of the list you need to click the link above.

  1. * Powerful and Continuing Nationalism - Fascist regimes tend to make constant use of patriotic mottos, slogans, symbols, songs, and other paraphernalia. Flags are seen everywhere, as are flag symbols on clothing and in public displays. (I wonder if the cost of the flag, example $2 million, has anything to do with it? Gary Hunt did speak of nationalism, did he not?)
  2. * Disdain for the Recognition of Human Rights - Because of fear of enemies and the need for security, the people in fascist regimes are persuaded that human rights can be ignored in certain cases because of "need." The people tend to look the other way or even approve of torture, summary executions, assassinations, long incarcerations of prisoners, etc. (I know, you are saying that there is not so much of this at the moment but there are certain clues that point to this coming).
  3. * Identification of Enemies/Scapegoats as a Unifying Cause - The people are rallied into a unifying patriotic frenzy over the need to eliminate a perceived common threat or foe: racial , ethnic or religious minorities; liberals; communists; socialists, terrorists, etc. (Again, a sort of grey area?).
  4. * Rampant Sexism - The governments of fascist nations tend to be almost exclusively male-dominated. Under fascist regimes, traditional gender roles are made more rigid. Divorce, abortion and homosexuality are suppressed and the state is represented as the ultimate guardian of the family institution. (Uh huh, we are seeing definite signs of this).
  5. * Religion and Government are Intertwined - Governments in fascist nations tend to use the most common religion in the nation as a tool to manipulate public opinion. Religious rhetoric and terminology is common from government leaders, even when the major tenets of the religion are diametrically opposed to the government's policies or actions. (We can see the increasing religiosity in our great great leader).
  6. * Corporate Power is Protected - The industrial and business aristocracy of a fascist nation often are the ones who put the government leaders into power, creating a mutually beneficial business/government relationship and power elite. (Anyone see Andre Montiel, Salybia & Boynes, etc).
  7. * Disdain for Intellectuals and the Arts - Fascist nations tend to promote and tolerate open hostility to higher education, and academia. It is not uncommon for professors and other academics to be censored or even arrested. Free expression in the arts and letters is openly attacked. (One word – Imbert-cile).
  8. * Rampant Cronyism and Corruption - Fascist regimes almost always are governed by groups of friends and associates who appoint each other to government positions and use governmental power and authority to protect their friends from accountability. It is not uncommon in fascist regimes for national resources and even treasures to be appropriated or even outright stolen by government leaders. (Do I really need to comment here?).
  9. * Fraudulent Elections - Sometimes elections in fascist nations are a complete sham. Other times elections are manipulated by smear campaigns against or even assassination of opposition candidates, use of legislation to control voting numbers or political district boundaries, and manipulation of the media. Fascist nations also typically use their judiciaries to manipulate or control elections. (Don't forget, using strong-arm tactics by community leaders, promising land to community leaders, giving lucrative contracts to community leaders...).

So out of 14 identifiable characteristics of Fascism, I have identified 9.

Until this morning... when we see a 10th:

* Controlled Mass Media - Sometimes the media is directly controlled by the government, but in other cases, the media is indirectly controlled by government regulation, or sympathetic media spokespeople and executives. Censorship, especially in war time, is very common.

Jumbie's Watch

When the Government is the

When the Government is the largest client of the media in their advertising budget, they actually own the media. Even the independent ones. Money talks.

EXCELLENT POINT

EXCELLENT POINT -

Point is worth noting. We therefore have to view media reports with scepticism. Some papers could be seen to be clearly supportive of a particular party. Their news amounts to no more than PR for that party.

Virgogyul You could not be

Virgogyul
You could not be more accurate SadTrini and Fairplay

Jumbies_Watch - Thanks

Jumbies_Watch - Thanks You.
The information you have provided to us is very timely. I hope that our readers would take the time to not only read your submission but also to look around and question every aspect of our government's operation. Never accept anything at face value.

Sorry to say, but I have seen many of our bloggers giving their unquestionable support to this regime to do as they wish; and this scares the daylights out of me.

I do look forward to your unbiased commentaries on important issues. Its very valuable. Thanks again.
Gardenia

SCARED INAPPROPRIATE

SCARED INAPPROPRIATE RESPONSE -

The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. This not an attempt to dictate to you what your responses should be we all have to swim upstream ourselves in this journey of life. In all societies freedoms are infringed and will continue to be. Fear immobilises action and activism liberates. Emancipate yourself from mental slavery for none can ah rule our mind. Take courage speaking out takes courage and does make a difference and will not always be popular. One just has to do what one has to do, sometimes you are right sometimes you are wrong but the learning is in the doing not only in doing the right things. We can also learn from our mistakes as can others. Stay up stay strong. Your intentions are noble.

Jumbies thanks for the info,

Jumbies thanks for the info, very interesting, careful Parsie send you to the PC next...lol

I am waiting to see the

I am waiting to see the solidarity of the members of the press on this issue.Would They fold under this tinpot dictator or refuse to attend the various propaganda events like Cabinet press conferences or even boycott parliament.But then there is the power of the dollar for Government ads.This repression wouldn't stop because the PNM is under intense scrutiny for the UDECOTT SCAM which has the potential for bringing down this Government

....we're not too surprised

....we're not too surprised by this turn of events since it's a normal step on the pathway to where our Country is heading....one could say that we're being burhammed or even mugabied.....

The 'Chavez-like mentality'

The 'Chavez-like mentality' is slowly, but surely creeping into the political structure of T&T. First, it was intimidation of the Radio Station and the newswaves. Now, whether or not you like the reporting in Newsday, it's suppression of the Free Press.

It's a clear indication of where things are heading in this country - Government continuing to 'do it's own thing' without accountability to the Nation. If that isn't an indication of a budding Dictatorship, I don't know what other clues we need.

However, it's encouraging to see that the Opposition menbers stood against the motion.

This whole scenario would make for interesting front page press (in Newsday) when the C-HOG Meeting convenes. Imagine " Freedom of the Press At Risk" & "Prison Guards Protest", when Her Majesty lands in Paradise !!

All these Gov't efforts, to ensure that Government isn't 'embarassed' at the upcoming meeting..... What's Next ?

Just look at the Trinidad

Just look at the Trinidad Express during the course of this week digging 6 feet deep to put away the outcries of Justice Volney. Shouldn't we instead pay heed to such outcries especially when members of our judicial system (from Chief Justice in his opening remarks of law term; Law association and now individual judges) begin to voice strong concerns over the political direction of the country and the independence and the need for strengthening judicial system??? It is sad to see The Express treating the remarks of Justice Volney in isolation of all the growing tendencies towards stifling expression of opinions, killing of opposing ideas no matter how idependent and subtle erosion of right to civil and peaceful protests.

The actions of the State towards Bagoo should therefore be placed within context. Moreover, the local press like the judiciary needs to start strongly defending its rights in these uncertain times and seek strength from other international media bodies. Can we expect this from MATT?????

THE STENCH OF HYPOCRICY

THE STENCH OF HYPOCRICY -
You people fail to surprise anymore. If I had a dollar for everytime you complain about how biased the press is, how inaccurate their reporting is, how sensationalist their headlines are, how curryfavouring the reporters are, I could afford to live in One Woodbrook Place.
One thing is certain, when it comes to inconsistency, you folks are the most consistent.

Its better to have an

Its better to have an inaccurate and sensational FREE PRESS than no press at all.
We all know the problems with the press in TnT, and you are right it is at times inacurate and sensational. And we hold them accountable for that. But when the govt. starts dictating who can cover the news and how it should be covered then there is a major problem.
When the govt. runs the press then we will only read about is how great our leaders are doing. You will never hear about crime, dengue, H1N1, $2,000,000 flags, UDECOTT or anything else that would put the govt. in a bad light.

Then we have nothing to

Then we have nothing to complain about.

IT IS DESIRABLE TO HAVE

IT IS DESIRABLE TO HAVE -

A free accurate press is desired. In other countries if a paper supports a party it comes out and says so. Neither the government nor the press are perfect and when they err they should be criticised. If not it will not be a free country and a free press.

They have all forgotten when

They have all forgotten when we were asked, that is the entire nation was loudly coerced into boycotting the "EXPRESS" for a day some of these complied with that directive not long ago. Not one person on this page probably said a word for the media why is it so much more important today, when the last time it was an entire news paper, the threat was worse.

I AM NOT SURE ABOUT THE

I AM NOT SURE ABOUT THE EXPRESS -

But I remember there was a also call to boycott the Newsday by Anil Roberts, when a reporter linked to the plagarisim of Fr Charles issue was fired.

In calling for a free press

In calling for a free press and strong media we are in fact supporting the media; In asking for transparency we are supporting the media; In providing constructive criticism we are supporting the media.

'Kill one, frighten a

'Kill one, frighten a thousand' is an old strategy. People, the Fourth Estate is under attack! And the media seems to be taking all the licks in virtual silence. Is it because of the 'manna'? or their political affiliation?

What is sickening is that it seems like 'they own whip cutting they tail' Check who are the 'Communications Specialists'(aka spinbowlers) in each gov. agency? One would think that these former media men and women would stand up for their former profession. But the almighty dollar seems to have morphed them into the 'field slave' being promoted into the whip weilding overseer?

My stomach turns every time one lawmaker or the other talks in codes about burning one newspaper or the other in the 'Square', or of of boycotting. Reminds me of Venezuela and Guyana, where, in the latter, journalists have been murdered by 'unknown' gunmen from time immemorial? Remember the massacre there some 2 or so years ago? We haven't reached there yet, but I remember reading an article by the great express writer, Owen Baptiste, in which he claimed that after the publication of an article 'Grab for power'(in which an allegation was made against a faction opposed to then PM Robinson),he (OB) received a phone call one night instructing him to 'go to the post box'! Needless to say, he hid in his house and that probably saved his life.

I would not even try to have you recall anti-media political events like: burning of the Guardian; calling it the 'Jamette of St Vincent Street'; one sitting TT Prime Minister causing supporters to attack an NBS crew covering an Arima political meeting in the 1980s; another one declaring to a frenzied and some intoxicated 'lynch mob' at Mid Centre Mall 'do them first before they do you'. And now the media's own 'Mr-We-Made-Mistakes-Big-Brother' appearing to be the smiling 'media assassin' cussing and cuddling the media?

Hell, they sometimes appear to have invaded the blogs spots here too, flagging contributions, telling people what to say and how to say it, ferret out the undotted i and the uncrossed t,who to support and who not to support. Man, these control aliens seem to be everywhere!!!(Don't get me wrong, they have the same right to write just like me and you)

The Fourth Estate, the free conscience of civilization, the civilized and the uncivilized, appears to be under sustained attack. Man, you don't even know if the press is getting kill by 'friendly fire' or 'unfriendly fire' or if it's 'collateral damage'!!

No one, especially the 'bosses', ever likes to hear that their 'bam-see' is showing, but the role of a free press seems to be, for me, to tell whoever's 'bam-see' is exposed, that his 'bam-see' is glaringly receiving natural sunlight. Like it or not. Otherwise, we'll all end up a society of 'bam-sees' if we didn't stand up for freedom and liberty.

(PS. If you have to flag me, It'll take nothing less that a 2 or even an 800 million dollar (in USdollars) flag please!)

ajfyzabadbutlertown

ONE WORD

ONE WORD -

amirjairam

BRILLIANT

AJFYZABADBUTLERTOWN:- It was

AJFYZABADBUTLERTOWN:-

It was refreshing reading your expose this morning. One 'plus' has come my way today. Thanks. I have been following the goings-on carefully, and to be honest, I find it quite a bit unsettling. But like many, I attempt at every turn to question and critique where and when necessary. Every voice raised is one more echo. Good governance is desired.
Remember, that I always enjoy reading your 'words of wisdom'.
Enjoy your day, my friend.
(PS: I don't think that anyone will dare "flag" your blogs: So I guess that the $??M-US has just flown the coop.) Nice Try!
Gardenia

“Since truth and reason

“Since truth and reason have maintained their ground against false opinions in league with false facts, the press, confined to truth, needs no other legal restraint”. Thoman Jefferson's Second Inaugural Address 1805.

 
 

Feedback