JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Thursday, April 17, 2025

How a birthday cruise turned tragic for T&T's 1st COVID victim

by

Joshua Seemungal
1823 days ago
20200419

Vernise There­sa By­er-Lodge was Vic­tim Num­ber 4.

The day af­ter she died from the coro­n­avirus, her chil­dren, Tri­cia and Car­lyle, col­lect­ed the death cer­tifi­cate of their 65-year-old moth­er and the cre­ma­tion li­cense from po­lice.

They rushed home, got a few min­utes rest, then went to the cre­ma­tion. On­ly two fam­i­ly mem­bers could be present. They were not al­lowed to see their moth­er’s body. They were not even al­lowed to touch the cof­fin. Flow­ers they brought to put next to her were placed there by peo­ple in haz­mat suits.

COVID-19 has claimed eight live so far in Trinidad and To­ba­go. In all, 114 cit­i­zens have been in­fect­ed from the virus, which has roiled so­ci­eties across the globe.

Lo­cal au­thor­i­ties have of­fered a few de­tails about vic­tims. Guardian Me­dia got an in­side look in­to the Lodge’s case from her four chil­dren who shared their trag­ic sto­ry

Her loved ones said she was a self­less, car­ing and God-fear­ing woman with un­wa­ver­ing faith.

“Mom­my had three things: God, love, and for­give­ness. She nev­er said it was her mot­to, but she lived it,” her son, Car­lyle, re­called.

To him and his three sib­lings, Tri­cia, Col­in, and Kalisha, their moth­er was al­so a friend.

Many were the times spent to­geth­er in the pa­tio of their fam­i­ly home, just talk­ing. From pi­cong to pol­i­tics to church, the sub­jects were wide-reach­ing, last­ing well in­to the night.

On oc­ca­sion, they even talked about life and death. Lit­tle did they know that one con­ver­sa­tion, one de­ci­sion, would end up be­ing, quite like­ly, the dif­fer­ence be­tween the two.

For her 65th birth­day on March 14, Lodge went on a cruise across the Caribbean Sea.

“She has al­ways want­ed to go on a cruise. She talked about it. She dreamt about it,” said her daugh­ter Tri­cia.

As part of a re­tiree group, Vernise trav­elled every oth­er year, but this trip was par­tic­u­lar­ly spe­cial to her.

Aware of the po­ten­tial risks the fam­i­ly dis­cussed whether she should still go, or not.

“It wasn’t some­thing easy for us. The thing is, re­mem­ber, that it didn’t hit Trinidad as hard as yet. Even­tu­al­ly, we were like, you know what? Go ahead. It so hap­pened, of course, that this whole COVID-19 came, but re­al­i­ty is, it was a tough de­ci­sion telling her go,” Tri­cia said.

Dri­ving that de­ci­sion was an in­sis­tence by Car­ni­val Cruise Line, own­ers of the Cos­ta Favolosa ship, that it would not pro­vide a re­fund to pas­sen­gers who can­celled their trip.

Seek­ing to take as many pre­cau­tions as pos­si­ble, the re­tiree group’s mem­bers did med­ical check­ups be­fore de­part­ing. They al­so took ex­tra med­ica­tion in an ef­fort to boost up their im­mune sys­tems.

On March 6, Lodge left T&T for Mar­tinique. Be­fore leav­ing her home, as she al­ways did, she told her chil­dren she loved them and kissed her grand­chil­dren good­bye while they slept.

Her son, Car­lyle, dropped her to the air­port. On the way there, they struck up a con­ver­sa­tion.

“She asked me, she said, ‘Be hon­est with me. You don’t think I should go on the cruise?’ Now, at that point, I was re­al­ly feel­ing I tell her no, but I knew she was ex­cit­ed and she had nev­er been on a cruise, so I say, ‘You should go.’ But deep down in­side, I didn’t want her to, “ he re­called.

He thought to him­self, if it’s fate, it’s fate.

Costa Favolosa

Costa Favolosa

The Cos­ta Favolosa

Launched in 2010, and with a ca­pac­i­ty of 3,780 pas­sen­gers, the Cos­ta Favolosa is part of the fleet of Cos­ta Crociere, a sub­sidiary of Car­ni­val Cruise Lines.

Of­fer­ing fine din­ing, bars, shops, and just about any­thing some­one on board could need, it is es­sen­tial­ly a city at sea. At the be­gin­ning of Lodge’s trip, it was every­thing she dreamt of.

She lept her chil­dren up to date via What­sApp and sent them pic­tures of her ad­ven­tures.

Things did not re­main pic­ture-per­fect for long, how­ev­er.

On March 13, the day be­fore Lodge’s birth­day, pas­sen­gers found out there were at least two pos­i­tive cas­es of COVID-19 aboard the cruise. The two con­firmed cas­es were es­cort­ed off and all oth­er pas­sen­gers were told to iso­late them­selves in their rooms.

Med­ical pro­fes­sion­als test­ed all the pas­sen­gers and the T&T na­tions in Lodge’s group all test­ed neg­a­tive.

How­ev­er, there was a prob­lem--- no coun­try was will­ing to al­low the Cos­ta Favolosa to dock.

“Stuff start­ed to get worse. They were un­able to dock in Mar­tinique. Then they weren’t al­lowed to dock in Sint Mar­tin. Ba­si­cal­ly, they were just cir­cling the sea, “ Tri­cia said.

Miles away, Lodge’s chil­dren could do noth­ing but pray and hope.

“It was the most tor­ment­ing thing we went through as a fam­i­ly. Just know­ing you can­not get to her. You felt help­less. Be­cause, at this point in time, no­body could have helped, “ Tri­cia said as tears filled her eyes.

Lodge’s childen didn’t sleep for days. The pa­tio of their Care­nage house where they used to con­verse with their moth­er be­came a chapel. There, they prayed to­geth­er for their moth­er’s safe re­turn.

Tri­cia said: “You know they talk­ing to you, and you are hear­ing the dra­ma so you could hear the de­pres­sion in their voice be­cause they want to come home

“Every­body would have their mo­ments of feel­ing like this is just crazy. This is not hap­pen­ing.”

Their prayers were an­swered when the Guade­loupe gov­ern­ment per­mit­ted the Cos­ta Favolosa to dock, al­low­ing pas­sen­gers with con­firmed flights to leave. How­ev­er, the T&T na­tion­als had flights booked out of Mar­tinique which had de­nied the ship en­try the day be­fore.

While arrange­ments were be­ing made be­tween the gov­ern­ments of both coun­tries, the 75 T&T na­tion­als re­mained on board the ship. For one day, they were the on­ly peo­ple on the Cos­ta Favolosa.

Even­tu­al­ly, ac­cord­ing to the Lodge fam­i­ly, the Favolosa’s own­ers in­ter­vened amd char­tered a flight back to Trinidad.

“The own­ers of the Cos­ta Favolosa paid for ever­body to come back home, so they han­dled them for the flight back. The gov­ern­ment gave them the clear­ance to come back home, “ Tri­cia said.

The fam­i­ly got con­fir­ma­tion that their moth­er would re­turn on a March 18 flight. The flight touched down at Pi­ar­co, short­ly be­fore noon. Lodge was one of 68 na­tion­als on­board.

Des­per­ate­ly hop­ing to see his moth­er, Car­lyle drove up to the air­port but was un­able to see her. Straight off the plane, the na­tion­als were es­cort­ed in­to ve­hi­cles and tak­en to a quar­an­tine site, Camp Ba­lan­dra.

“It was a sense of re­lief. We knew that she would have to go through that quar­an­tine process, and we were hop­ing it would have just been that, and she would come back home, “ Car­lyle said.

Ba­lan­dra to Cou­va

Ba­lan­dra of­fered a much-need­ed sense of com­fort for Lodge, ac­cord­ing to her chil­dren.

“I re­mem­ber Mom say­ing the fresh breeze was ther­a­peu­tic. But, she did say the so­cial dis­tanc­ing prac­tices were not al­ways fol­lowed,” Tri­cia re­called.

On Thurs­day, the day af­ter their ar­rival, every­one was test­ed for COVID-19 and told they would have re­sults by the Sun­day.

Just af­ter 11 pm, on Sat­ur­day, 40 of the pa­tients were wok­en up from their beds, then washed with wa­ter out­side of the build­ing.

Lodge and the 39 oth­ers had been hear­ing ru­mours they had all test­ed pos­i­tive for the virus but had not been of­fi­cial­ly in­formed.

Even­tu­al­ly, they were placed in­to bus­es and tak­en to the Cou­va Hos­pi­tal.

“It was heart­break­ing. It was a lot of mixed emo­tions be­cause it was all over the place. One mo­ment you are feel­ing an­gry. The next mo­ment you are feel­ing sad, “ said Kalisha.

Lodge’s health soon took a turn for the worse. She had no pre-ex­ist­ing con­di­tions, apart from mild hy­per­ten­sion.

On Mon­day, she was placed on a ven­ti­la­tor. That night, her chil­dren heard her voice for the last time.

“While she was on oxy­gen she want­ed to call us and her room­mate was re­peat­ing every­thing she was say­ing to us and then she came off the oxy­gen quick­ly and said she loved us, that she loved every­one,” Tri­cia said.

The fol­low­ing day, Lodge col­lapsed and was tak­en to the In­ten­sive Care Unit.

That af­ter­noon, Lodge’s body start­ed shut­ting down and just af­ter 8 pm, the call her chil­dren had all feared the most came.

She didn’t feel a thing. She did not suf­fer, the doc­tor told them.

Just like they had done every night since they first heard their moth­er was strand­ed on the Cos­ta Favolosa, the fam­i­ly was on the pa­tio pray­ing for a mir­a­cle. Every­one stopped pray­ing when Tri­cia got the call, Car­lyle re­mem­bered.

He knew what had hap­pened based on the ex­pres­sion on his broth­er’s face. It’s an ex­pres­sion he had seen 22 years ear­li­er when their fa­ther drowned on a fam­i­ly trip. His body was not found un­til days lat­er.

When­ev­er the fam­i­ly had spo­ken about death, Lodge, a staunch Catholic, had made it clear she want­ed to be buried. It was not pos­si­ble for her to have that wish, how­ev­er.

The day af­ter she died, Vernise There­sa By­er-Lodge was laid to rest.

A life of pur­pose

When she lost her hus­band, Car­lyle Lodge Sr, Lodge strug­gled im­mense­ly with the loss. Then one day she had an awak­en­ing and ded­i­cat­ed her life to God.

“A lot, a lot of peo­ple that I didn’t even know my moth­er im­pact­ed so much, called me in a state of shock. When they told me about their sto­ry of how mom­my told them to come to church and changed their lives, I didn’t know she played such a big role in peo­ple’s lives. I think that is a big part of us be­ing com­fort­ed, “ Tri­cia said.

Lodge was a mem­ber of the So­ci­ety of St.Vin­cent de Paul, a re­li­gious in­struc­tor at Point Cumana Gov­ern­ment Pri­ma­ry School, a eu­charis­tic min­is­ter, and First­Com­mu­nion teacher.

Not a sin­gle day has gone by with­out vis­i­tors shar­ing their mem­o­ries of Lodge with her fam­i­ly.

For­give­ness

While the Lodge fam­i­ly was go­ing through their be­reave­ment, there were peo­ple, on so­cial me­dia, fierce­ly crit­i­ciz­ing the na­tion­als who went on the Cos­ta Favolosa cruise.

“It felt in­hu­mane. In­hu­mane. It was so de­mor­al­iz­ing. They were just de­grad­ing. I mean it’s like, you don’t know how our fam­i­ly is feel­ing,” Tri­cia said.

“Yes, peo­ple went on the cruise and the de­ci­sion was wrong, but you have to re­mem­ber that these peo­ple be­longed to fam­i­lies. With COVID-19, no­body is in­vin­ci­ble.”

While the fam­i­ly has some is­sues with the treat­ment their moth­er re­ceived at the hos­pi­tal, they ac­knowl­edge that many of the doc­tors and nurs­es, as well as the Chief Med­ical Of­fi­cer and Health Min­is­ter are do­ing their best.

Af­ter all the Lodge Fam­i­ly has been through in the last six weeks, they want the coun­try to un­der­stand one thing--- that the key to de­feat­ing this dead­ly virus rests in our hearts.

“Just bring some hu­man­i­ty back. It’s not about pol­i­tics. It’s not about pow­er or sta­tus. Just bring hu­man­i­ty back.

“COVID-19 is not judg­ing any­one. It is not pick­ing or choos­ing. Who would have thought our moth­er would have gone like this?”


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored