“Whoever wins Tunapuna wins the election”.
This is a statement you may have heard being bandied about before.
But how true is it?
Well, according to data from the Elections and Boundaries Commission (EBC) looking back at all national elections held since the start of the 21st century, this is indeed so.
There were six General Elections and four Local Government Elections held in this country since the year 2000, and the political party that won the Tunapuna constituency eventually went on to win the General Election, while the party that won the Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation (TPRC) came out victors in the Local Government Election.
And so with a Local Government Election constitutionally due before the end of this year, and a General Election due next year the stakes for Tunapuna are now extremely high.
As it stands right now the People’s National Movement (PNM) represents Tunapuna in the Parliament and is also in charge of the Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation (TPRC).
The United National Congress (UNC), however, believes it can wrest control of the area from out of the hands of the PNM.
Guardian Media went into the Tunapuna area last week to look at the situation, as the country anticipates going to the polls in some form or fashion within the next year and a half.
Esmond Forde, who is the current Member of Parliament for Tunapuna and Deputy Speaker, first entered the House of Representatives following the 2015 General Election.
Before his entry into the Parliament, Forde also spent five years as the councillor for the Auzonville/Tunapuna electoral district.
He was also the Vice-Chairman of the TPRC.
Forde, who says he was “born and bred” in Tunapuna, believes the constituency is a “critical one”.
“It is considered the most marginal of marginal seats. In past general elections the (Tunapuna) seat was won by under 500 votes, however, in 2015 I won the seat by around 3,700 votes. But all that can evaporate overnight so I am not taking anything for granted,” Forde said.
As a result of this Forde said he has always been working in the area as he tries to provide proper representation for its constituents.
“My door was always open as a local government councillor, and it continues to be opened now as the member of parliament,” he said.
PNM and UNC focusing on people-centred service
Forde said he has logged close to 9,000 visits to his office since becoming an MP.
He said while the financial difficulties facing the country has hampered some infrastructural work in the area, he believes that once the situation is turned around Tunapuna will get what it rightfully deserves.
“I took my oath very seriously, even though I may not be able to provide the main infrastructure, paved roadways or bridges constructed because of the tightness of the economy, Esmond Forde the MP for Tunapuna forges relationships with his constituents,” he said.
Forde believes he has a good relationship with the majority of constituents no matter their creed, race, or political affiliations.
“I am doing my part, God and the people will decide whether or not Esmond Forde did enough, but I think I did enough to ensure that Tunapuna got its share of the pie,” he said.
“I just want the constituents to continue to have faith and once the country gets back on a good financial footing, Tunapuna is going to get everything it needs,” Forde said.
Despite the financial constraints, however, Forde said some serious infrastructural work was undertaken in the community including the construction of bridges and the fixing of a sinkhole.
The UNC, however, does not believe that enough is being done for the constituency.
Last Saturday the party opened its “People-centred service centre” to address those perceived deficiencies, UNC chairman Peter Kanhai told Guardian Media.
Kanhai, who is also the coordinator for the UNC’s Tunapuna constituency, had previously served as the president of the Greater Tunapuna Chamber of Industry and Commerce for five years.
Kanhai said the UNC intends to win the Tunapuna seat.
“There are several marginal constituencies now and Tunapuna is a critical marginal seat for either party. There is a saying that whoever wins Tunapuna wins the election so from that standpoint both sides recognise the significance of Tunapuna. Now that is not to say that a party who loses Tunapuna cannot win the election or vice versa, a party who wins Tunapuna cannot lose the election, but we the United National Congress, we are focused on winning the election and we have placed Tunapuna among those constituencies that we must win,” Kanhai said.
Kanhai said the UNC has picked up “a lot of disenchantment” from Tunapuna constituents.
“What we’ve picked up is a lot of disenchantment from the people in this community as in other areas. There’s a lack of representation. Tunapuna is a constituency represented entirely and at both levels, the local government and at the Parliamentary level by representatives of the PNM, yet a lot of the people we have met are disenchanted for one reason or the other,” he said.
As a result of this Kanhai said the UNC intends to provide various services, including free legal aid, as well as create an employment database.
Forde, however, believes that the UNC coming into the constituency now is simply a mamaguy.
The voice of the voters
So what do the voters in Tunapuna think?
Well, for Ardon Breton both the UNC and the PNM are simply the same thing.
“I don’t like politics but I don’t like to see people suffering and boy right now the cry of the people is that they are suffering,” Breton said.
Breton said no matter who wins the election whether be PNM, or UNC, or any other party he just wants them to be “more empathetic”.
Breton said all politicians should take a page from former prime minister George Chambers when it came to dealing with people.
“None of them today could match Chambers. He used to listen, he would let you talk and listen to what you have to say,” he said.
Camille John, however, believes that Forde embodies those very attributes.
“I see him walking the area. I see him in the market, he’s always at a function for people in the community whether it’s a birthday party or funeral. So to me, he is trying,” John said.
Meanwhile, Breton’s friend Mark Francois took issue with his analysis of the situation.
“How can you say people suffering, and the bar always full? They still have money to go to the bar, so I don’t like the statement that people are suffering,” Francois said.
Francois highlighted the recent Carnival celebrations to support his point.
He said whoever wins the election in Tunapuna needs to consult more with the constituents.
“They need to consult before they make any major decisions that’s what they need to do. We know that there are hard decisions to be made but talk to us first,” he said.
Dale Bacchus said he feels the traffic congestion and drainage are two of the major problems affecting the constituency.
“We just need to sort those two things out and I feel we will be good,” Bacchus said.
For N. Mulkhraj the most pressing issue is the crime.
“Crime is what killing this place. We need them to address that and have the police doing more night patrols,” Mulkhraj said.
Christian Persad said he believes the cry all across the country is for better representation.
“I don’t think anybody is ever really satisfied with representation on a whole in the constituencies, nationwide, not just here,” Persad said.
Voting patterns
2016: PNM won the Local Government Election on November 28.
PNM captured the Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation (PNM 12, UNC 4)
2015: PNM won the General Election on September 7.
Esmond Forde won the Tunapuna constituency for the PNM with 11,228 votes.
2013: PNM won the Local Government Election on October 21.
PNM captured the Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation (PNM 12, COP 2 , ILP 1)
2010: People’s Partnership won the Local Government Election on July 26.
PP won the Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation (PP 11, PNM 4)
2010: People’s Partnership won the General Election on May 24.
Winston Dookeran won the Tunapuna constituency for the PP with 10,446 votes.
2007: PNM won the General Election on November 5.
Esther Le Gendre won the Tunapuna constituency for the PNM with 8,494 votes.
2003: PNM won the Local Government Election on July 14.
PNM captured the Tunapuna/Piarco Regional Corporation (PNM 9, UNC 4)
2002: PNM won the General Election on October 7.
Eddie Hart won the Tunapuna constituency for the PNM with 10,154 votes.
2001: PNM and the UNC tied the General Election on December 10 winning 18 seats each. President Arthur NR Robinson eventually chose Patrick Manning as Prime Minister.
Eddie Hart won the Tunapuna constituency for the PNM with 8,792 votes.
He beat Mervyn Assam of the UNC by 254 votes.
2000: UNC won the General Election on December 11.
Mervyn Assam won the Tunapuna constituency for the UNC with 9,062 votes.
He beat Eddie Hart by 336 votes.