Speaker allows debate on Chinese labour...

Dumas: Living conditions okay

Published: 20 Oct 2009

Dr Roodal Moonilal.
PHOTO: MARCUS GONZALES

Labour Minister Rennie Dumas says the living conditions at a commune in Cunupia in Central Trinidad for Chinese migrant employees of Liujing Beijing Construction Company is not an issue. House Speaker Barry Sinanan granted leave to Opposition MP Dr Roodal Moonilal to present the matter for debate as a definite matter of urgent public importance. And Dumas said the matter centred around three issues—the duration of the contract, the retention of earned wages as a bond for performance and wages retained. He said the problems related to only one company employing Chinese migrant workers and not the other 18 companies employing Chinese workers in T&T.

Dumas insisted that the labour laws and conventions were being adhered to in this country. He said his ministry was “quite capable of managing the issues that arise in labour in T&T.” In response to claims from Dr Moonilal that the country’s international reputation was not at risk because of the situation, Dumas said: “I want to assure the country that we have nothing to be ashamed of.“ He accused Dr Moonilal of maligning the Occupational Safety and Health Agency. Dumas said the OSH Agency and labour inspectors, in their recent visits to the construction sites of the Chinese company, have reported that there were no dramatic issues.

He said claims being made that the working conditions could be described as slavery were a total falsehood.” He said there are people in this country who are “very discriminatory and racist in our minds.” He added that Chinese had almost become a bad word in T&T. “We want to make it abundantly clear that the Government of T&T does not subscribe to that racism (and) that discrimination,” he said. Moonilal demanded that a tripartite committee be set up to monitor the issue of contract work and migrant workers on a regular basis.

Article Tools
 

If Dumas is so happy with

If Dumas is so happy with the living and working conditions of the Chinese workers, why doesn't he put his money where his mouth is and go and live for a week in each one of the camps and work a few shifts with the workers and then come back and say how great things are.

I don't know about you, but I have not seen any racism displayed against these poor Chinese workers. While many have queried the need to import cheap Chinese labour from far off China at the expense of local and regional workers, there was never any issue of racism.

On the contrary, Trinis were appalled at the sub-human treatment meted out to these people and reached out to them and condemned their atrocious treatment and came to their defence and rescue.

Dumas owes the country an apology for his ignorant charges and accusations.

Mr Lord, the name of the

Mr Lord, the name of the company is the Beijing Liujian Construction Company.

Minister Dumas is being creative when he omits the fourth issue - the below-standard living conditions at the camp used to house the Chinese workers, and the apparent misrepresentation of purpose made during Town and Country Planning application (warehouse vs residential area).

This 4th issue is what's giving our country a bad name on the Internet. His ignoring it in Parliament is not helping.

Mr. Dumas, Listen Here You

Mr. Dumas, Listen Here You Pompous Man:-
You say "I want to assure the country that we have nothing to be ashamed of." Sorry to disappoint you mister, but even your Minister Gopee-Scoon said she was disgusted with the despicable conditions she saw in the living quarters of these workers. Even one of their Managers said "we are Chinese' giving the impression that they accept lower standards than that which T&T ascribes to.

Well Mr. Dumas, if you feel there is nothing to be ashamed of, them you must be prepared to allow these workers to live like your forefathers did under slavery. You have not progressed from your 'slave' mentality. You lack credibility and should not be sitting in our House of Power; as you ae not worthy to enter through it's doors.

To add insult to injury you ranted and raved about racism and discrimination from the Opposition. Can we assume that your protest was simply an effort to cover up the shame you have allowed to take place on T&T soil. No one is casting aspersions on the Chinese, we are taking you and this government to task for the disgraceful behaviour you are involved in; allowing the Chinese to be taken advantaged of.

You were caught with 'your pants down' for all the world to see when the living and working conditions of these workers came to light. You disrespected local firms and workers for foreign attempting ro justify cheaper labour. Do you think that we did not see through your smoke screen. You and your gov't indulged in unconscientionable practices.

If you believe that these living accommodations are so excellent do as suggested by another blogger and - go and live in these for a week at a time, eat the meals they are served, and do the job they do for one week at a time, and then come back and report to us, and then you can jump up like Jack in the Box.

Mr. Dumas you have a portfolio to manage, and are being paid handsomely for it, so how about earning your pay cheque?

Mr Dumas, like Ms Dick-Ford

Mr Dumas, like Ms Dick-Ford and most of the cabinet, cannot go against his master on this or any other wrongdoing.

He doesn't want to be in the same boat as Dr Rowley.

For such a big man, I thought he might have had a spine at least.

http://www.dsaltsman.blogspot.com/

He has a noodle for a spine,

He has a noodle for a spine, Mr Salts.

WHO DOES MR DUMAS CARE

WHO DOES MR DUMAS CARE ABOUT? -

Who does Mr Dumas Care about?

1) Does he care about the people of Tobago? Inadequate health care they still have to be airlifted to T&T. No Scarborough hospital.
2) Does he care about the Chinese Labourers; they are working under Slavery conditions.
3) Does he care about T&T workers; he works with the ECA to destabilize the unions.
4) Does he care about the Ethnic Cleansing, little black boys wiping out each other.

But he is bold face enough to try to deflect his inadequacies by getting up in Parliament and saying that UNC do not care about the people of Tobago. That statement immediately absolves him of any of his responsibilities. Does PNM care about the people of Tobago? Check the history of Robinson and Rowley. If Robinson did not team up with Panday we would not have been the only PM/President today.
Soon as a Tobagonian look powerful in PNM they get set up, watch out you are next in line. My great-grandmother is from Tobago and PNM cannot fool me again. Getting into power makes it expedient to present a caring face. Ask the people of Beetham, ask the Jamat, ask the people of Laventille, ask the Community Leaders.

Dumas you foolish man, who

Dumas you foolish man, who said anything bout race or prejudice, cant you read we are worried about our Chinese visitors, Have you been to China Mr Dumas? They are lovely people? I have many Chinese friends real Chinese not Singaporean Chinese. Have you been Mr Dumas on an oilfield platform in China's Bohai Bay, I have. I have seen how these Chinese workers are treated. Have you been to Dubai, Mr Dumas? to see how the Indians are treated and the conditions they live in. So dont bring that on 'bout racism, cant you see the TT public are worried about these Chinese workers, You trying to alienate the public and trying to say we are prejudiced, no way, take THAT back, right away, now!!!

Children use this tactic a

Children use this tactic a lot when they are arguing. The issue may be apples, and they argue vociferously about bananas, hoping they could twist the thing around and deflect to something else, because they think you born yesterday. What racism? The Trade Unions, the Catholic commission for social justice, the media, Manohar Ransarran and his group, the employees at the Immigration department,the ordinary citizens, the contributors to the newspapers'commentaries, even Emile Elias who had called for them to go home because of the threat to his pocket, all were in sympathy with these frightened victims. I found it quite disturbing on the other hand that their own people at the Chinese Embassy who spoke the language, did not dip into their petty cash and purchase food or water for them, knowing that they would have been out since 6am on the said day. So it is not an issue of racism but of oppression and very brutal when comes from your own and aided and abetted by a government in power.

Yes Prince I just read your

Yes Prince I just read your leading input on this, Dumas needs apologize, Knowing where TT came from, maybe NOT Dumas, his family, but we TT citizens care about slavery and the way we treat our fellow men, so apologize Dumas or resign and go back to where your family came from as surely you are not real TT.

Mr Dumas is just another one

Mr Dumas is just another one of the Prime Minister's hand picked Ministers drawing taxpayers money under false pretence.His only interest is how to stay looking loyal to the BOSS so he can continue to draw good money for doing little.He has no concern for anything else.

 
 

Feedback