JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, April 4, 2025

Trinis stranded in US sue ministry over COVID-19 exemption secrecy

by

Derek Achong
1711 days ago
20200727
 Justice Betsy-Ann Lambert Peterson

Justice Betsy-Ann Lambert Peterson

Wesley Gibbings

A group of cit­i­zens cur­rent­ly strand­ed in the Unit­ed States has sued the Min­istry of Na­tion­al Se­cu­ri­ty, over its re­fusal to dis­close the cri­te­ria be­ing used to grant trav­el ex­emp­tions un­der on­go­ing COVID-19 reg­u­la­tions. 

In the law­suit, which was filed last week, lawyers rep­re­sent­ing the group, which com­pris­es a cou­ple and their two chil­dren who are strand­ed in Hous­ton, Texas and an el­der­ly woman strand­ed in Mi­a­mi, Flori­da, claimed the min­istry's re­fusal to dis­close the in­for­ma­tion was il­le­gal, ir­ra­tional, un­rea­son­able and ar­bi­trary. 

The ju­di­cial re­view law­suit was deemed ur­gent when it came up for hear­ing be­fore Jus­tice Bet­sy-Ann Lam­bert-Pe­ter­son last week and the par­ties were giv­en dead­lines for the fil­ing ev­i­dence on whether the group should be grant­ed leave to pur­sue the claim.

The law­suit is ex­pect­ed to come up for hear­ing on Thurs­day. 

In the court fil­ings ob­tained by Guardian Me­dia, the group's le­gal team is con­tend­ing their clients and hun­dreds of cit­i­zens strand­ed abroad de­serve to know the cri­te­ria to de­ter­mine whether or not they qual­i­fy and whether they had been dis­crim­i­nat­ed against. 

"Strand­ed per­sons who are be­ing de­nied en­try have no way of know­ing whether they meet the cri­te­ria, what as­pect of it they do not meet, how to make ef­fec­tive rep­re­sen­ta­tions to se­cure en­try, whether they have been ar­bi­trar­i­ly by­passed in favour of oth­ers in breach of their con­sti­tu­tion­al right to equal­i­ty of treat­ment un­der Sec­tion 4(d) of the Con­sti­tu­tion," they said. 

Minister of National Security, Stuart Young.

Minister of National Security, Stuart Young.

They claimed that by fail­ing to dis­close the in­for­ma­tion, the min­istry ef­fec­tive­ly in­su­lat­ed ex­emp­tions grant­ed by Na­tion­al Se­cu­ri­ty Min­is­ter Stu­art Young from ju­di­cial re­view. 

"The ex­er­cise of such an im­por­tant pow­er and se­ri­ous dis­cre­tion in se­cret by the in­tend­ed de­fen­dant is anath­e­ma to the con­cept of the rule of law, equal­i­ty, and jus­tice," they said. 

Through the law­suit, the group is seek­ing a se­ries of de­c­la­ra­tions and an or­der com­pelling the dis­clo­sure. 

In the court fil­ings, the group's le­gal team sought to high­light the per­son­al cir­cum­stances of its mem­bers. 

In late Feb­ru­ary, a sev­en-month preg­nant Rae­hana Lorick and her first child left Trinidad for Cana­da so she could un­der­go an op­er­a­tion. How­ev­er, the Cana­di­an hos­pi­tal in­formed Lorick it could not per­form the pro­ce­dure due to its COVID-19 re­sponse fo­cus. 

Lorick made arrange­ments with a hos­pi­tal in Texas and flew there with her child and her hus­band joined them be­fore T&T closed its bor­ders in late March. Lorick un­der­went the pro­ce­dure and al­so had her sec­ond child dur­ing the pe­ri­od. How­ev­er, sev­er­al re­quests for ex­emp­tions to re­turn home re­ceived gener­ic re­spons­es. While abroad, Lorick was laid off from her job and her hus­band was placed on no-pay leave. 

The oth­er mem­ber of the group iden­ti­fied is 61-year-old Joanne Pan­tin, who left the coun­try in March to go to Mi­a­mi to help her daugh­ter take care of her grand­chil­dren while her son-in-law was re­cov­er­ing from an op­er­a­tion. The group claimed Pan­tin is un­der fi­nan­cial strain. 

The group's law­suit comes af­ter po­lit­i­cal ac­tivist De­vant Ma­haraj brought a law­suit claim­ing the min­istry breached the Free­dom of In­for­ma­tion Act (FOIA) by re­ject­ing his call for dis­clo­sure of the ex­emp­tion pol­i­cy. 

The group is be­ing rep­re­sent­ed by Anand Ram­lo­gan, SC while Regi­nald Ar­mour, SC, is lead­ing the State's team. 

COVID-19


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored