JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Wednesday, January 22, 2025

Two brothers file lawsuits over State blocking postgraduate study options

by

986 days ago
20220511

A pair of sib­lings from San Fer­nan­do, who both re­ceived na­tion­al open schol­ar­ships, have ini­ti­at­ed sep­a­rate law­suits over be­ing de­nied ap­proval to de­fer their oblig­a­tory ser­vice to com­plete their post­grad­u­ate stud­ies. 

Last Fri­day, High Court Judge Ricky Rahim grant­ed med­ical doc­tor, Dr Ryan Laloo, leave to pur­sue his ju­di­cial re­view case against the Min­istry of Ed­u­ca­tion’s per­ma­nent sec­re­tary and the Cab­i­net. 

On Tues­day, his old­er broth­er Mark, a vet­eri­nar­i­an, was grant­ed leave to pur­sue a sep­a­rate law­suit against the min­istry’s per­ma­nent sec­re­tary on­ly by High Court Judge Kevin Ram­cha­ran. 

In his law­suit, Laloo, who won the Pres­i­dent’s Medal for his per­for­mance in Caribbean Sec­ondary Ed­u­ca­tion Cer­tifi­cate (CSEC) ex­am­i­na­tions and Pres­i­dent’s Gold Medal for his sub­se­quent per­for­mance in the Caribbean Ad­vanced Pro­fi­cien­cy Ex­am­i­na­tion (CAPE) in 2009 and 2011, is chal­leng­ing the pol­i­cy on de­fer­ral of oblig­a­tory ser­vice for re­cip­i­ents of gov­ern­ment schol­ar­ships, which was ap­proved by the Cab­i­net in Feb­ru­ary 2014. 

The pol­i­cy states that the de­fer­ral of oblig­a­tory ser­vice will be guid­ed by the coun­try’s need to har­ness ar­eas of study which are con­sid­ered to be of high pri­or­i­ty and by op­por­tu­ni­ties to in­crease the val­ue of the schol­ar’s con­tri­bu­tion to na­tion­al im­por­tance. 

It adds that in or­der to qual­i­fy, schol­ars must pur­sue post­grad­u­ate stud­ies in an area aligned to the coun­try’s hu­man re­source needs, an in­tern­ship, a res­i­den­cy pro­gramme, or short-term em­ploy­ment for a max­i­mum of two years to max­imise their com­pe­ten­cies in their field.

The pol­i­cy states schol­ars will be on­ly al­lowed a six-year de­fer­ral to pur­sue post­grad­u­ate stud­ies. 

In the law­suit, Laloo’s lawyer Ganesh Sa­roop claims the pol­i­cy was ir­ra­tional, un­fair and un­rea­son­able, as it pre­clud­ed his client from pur­su­ing spe­cial­ist train­ing in vas­cu­lar surgery, gen­er­al surgery and trau­ma and or­thopaedic surgery, which is not avail­able in T&T and takes eight years to com­plete. 

“Such an in­flex­i­ble con­struc­tion is ir­ra­tional, be­cause it is im­prac­ti­cal and would lead to a man­i­fest ab­sur­di­ty where­by the pol­i­cy ef­fec­tive­ly ex­cludes high­ly spe­cialised fields of train­ing in med­i­cine re­gard­less of how crit­i­cal­ly de­fi­cient the coun­try is in that area, or how bad­ly the coun­try needs such ex­per­tise,” Sa­roop said. 

At­tached to Laloo’s law­suit is an af­fi­davit from in­ter­na­tion­al­ly renowned vas­cu­lar sur­geon Pro­fes­sor Vi­jay Narayans­ingh, who gave ex­pert ev­i­dence over the length of time re­quired to com­plete the train­ing sought by Laloo and the lo­cal need for doc­tors spe­cialised in the field. 

Narayans­ingh not­ed that vas­cu­lar sur­geons play an im­por­tant role in min­imis­ing limb loss in cas­es of am­pu­ta­tions for di­a­bet­ics and claimed there was a dire short­age of doc­tors with this spe­cial­i­ty train­ing. 

“In ad­di­tion, al­though stroke is the sec­ond com­mon­est cause of death in T&T, few­er than a to­tal of ten carotid op­er­a­tions are done an­nu­al­ly at our ma­jor hos­pi­tals,” he said. 

In the court fil­ings, Sa­roop claimed while Laloo was com­plet­ing his in­tern­ship in the Unit­ed King­dom (UK) in 2019, he was told he was se­lect­ed for a fel­low­ship to ob­tain the post­grad­u­ate train­ing be­tween that year and 2027, which would be fund­ed by the UK’s Na­tion­al In­sti­tute of Health Re­search. 

Say­ing the fel­low­ship is on­ly award­ed to four stu­dents in the UK an­nu­al­ly, Sa­roop said: “It was an in­valu­able op­por­tu­ni­ty to de­vel­op his ca­reer and bet­ter serve his coun­try.” 

Laloo in­formed the min­istry of the op­por­tu­ni­ty and was told he had to re­turn to T&T to make the ap­pli­ca­tion for de­fer­ral of ser­vice and to seek the ap­proval of Chief Med­ical Of­fi­cer Dr Roshan Paras­ram. 

Laloo com­plied but was on­ly in­formed his ap­pli­ca­tion was re­ject­ed in March this year, af­ter he had al­ready be­gun the train­ing.

“He was busy fo­cus­ing on his pro­gramme and was op­er­at­ing on the ba­sis of a le­git­i­mate ex­pec­ta­tion that his ap­pli­ca­tion had been or would be ap­proved and the let­ter of ap­proval was prob­a­bly caught up in bu­reau­cra­cy,” Sa­roop said. 

In his law­suit, Laloo’s old­er broth­er Mark is not chal­leng­ing the pol­i­cy but rather its ap­pli­ca­tion to his post­grad­u­ate stud­ies. 

Mark was award­ed the open schol­ar­ship in 2009 and stud­ied in the Unit­ed King­dom (UK), where he qual­i­fied as a vet­eri­nary sur­geon from the Uni­ver­si­ty of Ed­in­burgh in 2015. 
He was giv­en a two-year de­fer­ral for short-term em­ploy­ment in the UK be­fore be­ing grant­ed a three-year de­fer­ral to pur­sue post­grad­u­ate train­ing in small an­i­mal med­i­cine. 

He claimed that when he com­plet­ed the pro­gramme, he ap­plied for an­oth­er three-year ex­ten­sion to do post­grad­u­ate stud­ies in ad­vanced vet­eri­nary prac­tice at the Roy­al Col­lege of Vet­eri­nary Sur­geons but it was de­nied. In his law­suit, the el­der Laloo is claim­ing his ap­pli­ca­tion was un­fair­ly de­nied by the min­istry. 

His lawyers point­ed out that their client’s ap­pli­ca­tion was de­nied as it was wrong­ly claimed he was pur­su­ing the de­fer­ral on three grounds as op­posed to two, which is per­mit­ted un­der the pol­i­cy. They not­ed that the per­ma­nent sec­re­tary took al­most 18 months to re­spond to Laloo’s ap­pli­ca­tion and he had to en­rol in the post­grad­u­ate pro­gramme, which he is fi­nanc­ing him­self and is not avail­able lo­cal­ly.  

The sib­lings are al­so rep­re­sent­ed by Anand Ram­lo­gan, SC, Kent Sam­lal, Jayan­ti Lutch­me­di­al, Gary Ramkissoon and Natasha Bis­ram.

CLICK FOR MORE NEWS


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored