JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, March 14, 2025

A disastrous West Indies Test Series - What went wrong, again?

by

Colin Murray
225 days ago
20240801

Many of you must be ex­treme­ly dis­ap­point­ed in the per­for­mance of the West In­dies team in the re­cent­ly con­clud­ed Test se­ries against Eng­land.

Fresh from the morale-boost­ing eu­pho­ria of their lone vic­to­ry against Aus­tralia in the fi­nal Test back in Jan­u­ary, hopes were high that the Ma­roon Army would car­ry that mo­men­tum in­to the Eng­lish sum­mer and put up a spir­it­ed fight against Eng­land. How­ev­er, the re­al­i­ty was a far cry from such op­ti­mism, and you would not be fault­ed if you had ex­pect­ed bet­ter, more com­pet­i­tive per­for­mances from Kraigg Brath­waite's team.

It's no se­cret that Eng­lish con­di­tions pose a unique chal­lenge for West In­dies bats­men. They are to­tal­ly dif­fer­ent from the hard pitch­es and sun­ny, hu­mid weath­er in Aus­tralia in Jan­u­ary. Did the Crick­et West In­dies (CWI) board tru­ly be­lieve that this in­ex­pe­ri­enced squad was ca­pa­ble of win­ning or draw­ing the se­ries against a con­fi­dent Eng­land squad in Eng­lish con­di­tions?

First­ly, out­side of the first class sea­son in the re­gion in March/April, the ma­jor­i­ty of the play­ers were not play­ing first class crick­et (the red ball ver­sion of the game), so it should come as no sur­prise that the West In­dies bats­men looked out of their depth. In a se­ries that was card­ed for 15 days of crick­et, West In­dies was ham­mered three times by their op­po­nents in just nine days. Do the pow­ers that be re­al­ly care, or is it just tak­en for grant­ed and a feel­ing of res­ig­na­tion ac­cept­ed that the West In­dies will lose?

So, let’s move on to an­oth­er chap­ter in the sor­ry lega­cy of West In­dies crick­et. West In­dies played two Tests against Aus­tralia in Jan­u­ary, and six months lat­er, they played an­oth­er three Tests. Let’s be re­al­is­tic - the In­ter­na­tion­al Crick­et Coun­cil (ICC) does not care about West In­dies crick­et, un­like in the 70s and 80s when, as David Rud­der’s lyrics go in the West In­dies an­them, "we ruled the crick­et world". The team was in de­mand, play­ing maybe 15 or more Test match­es in a year. Now, who re­al­ly cares if West In­dies plays six or 12 Test match­es an­nu­al­ly spread six months apart?

Let us re­turn to the tour that was des­tined to fail. When you view the num­ber of Test match ap­pear­ances for four of the first six bats­men be­fore the se­ries be­gan, Mikyle Louis: 0, Kirk McKen­zie: 3, Al­ick Athanaze: 4 and Kavem Hodge: 2, there is a grand to­tal of nine Tests be­tween them so play­ing in for­eign con­di­tions where the ball is mov­ing ap­pre­cia­bly in the air, it was al­ways go­ing to be a strug­gle. The prepa­ra­tion for this tour, or rather the ab­ject lack there­of, was noth­ing short of far­ci­cal. A soli­tary week of train­ing and a three-day warm-up match against young­sters at Beck­en­ham hard­ly con­sti­tutes ad­e­quate prepa­ra­tion for a Test se­ries against a for­mi­da­ble op­po­nent such as Eng­land.

Sure­ly, these play­ers need­ed some ex­tend­ed warm-up games to ful­ly un­der­stand what they were fac­ing. Even the leg­endary Clive Lloyd's team, blessed with the likes of Gor­don Greenidge, Vi­vian Richards and Alvin Kallicha­ran, didn’t take such a cav­a­lier ap­proach when they came to Eng­land to play a five-Test se­ries. Clive Lloyd's ‘in­vin­ci­ble’ West In­dies would have spent weeks ac­cli­ma­tis­ing and hon­ing their skills, play­ing a se­ries of games against coun­ty op­po­si­tion where they would mas­sacre the coun­ty bowlers. In­deed, it is a stark re­minder of the gulf that has formed be­tween the glo­ry days of West In­dies crick­et and the present.

I at­tend­ed the first Test match at Lord’s as I want­ed to see first­hand how the team would han­dle the con­di­tions. His­to­ry would show the game end­ed one hour in­to the third day, and some of the fans were not on­ly dis­ap­point­ed in the quick out­come of the game, but you could hear the pity in the voic­es of the Eng­lish fans com­ment­ing on the de­cline of West In­dies crick­et. I was amazed at the sell­out crowds at Lord’s; even on that fate­ful third day with West In­dies start­ing the day on 79 for 6, Lord’s was packed. I sup­pose it was Jim­my An­der­son’s farewell, and the fans want­ed to send him off in style.

I feel it for the play­ers as they would have gone to Eng­land with a cer­tain lev­el of con­fi­dence but not with a firm un­der­stand­ing of the mag­ni­tude of their task, with, as I sug­gest­ed, prepa­ra­tion that could on­ly be con­sid­ered a joke. Even the two most ex­pe­ri­enced play­ers could not help the cause as cap­tain Brath­waite scored 166 runs from six in­nings, and Ja­son Hold­er scored 155 runs from six in­nings and took on­ly three wick­ets for the se­ries. Com­pare that to the top two Eng­lish play­ers: Joe Root with 291 runs from three in­nings and Ben Stokes with 192 runs from five in­nings with one not out and five wick­ets. The play­ers un­doubt­ed­ly bear re­spon­si­bil­i­ty for their per­for­mances, but the sys­temic is­sues with­in West In­dies crick­et can­not be ig­nored.

No­body seems to “ral­ly” around the West In­dies team, par­tic­u­lar­ly the ICC. The West In­dies needs heavy fi­nan­cial in­vest­ment if its test crick­et is to sur­vive. Un­der the ICC's new rev­enue-dis­tri­b­u­tion mod­el, In­dia is set to re­ceive a whop­ping US$230 mil­lion per year be­tween 2024-27; Eng­land will re­ceive US$41 mil­lion and US$38 mil­lion to Aus­tralia. The West In­dies is pro­ject­ed to re­ceive US$28 mil­lion, so it is no won­der the team can on­ly train for a week and play a fete match be­fore the Eng­land Test match se­ries. It is a dis­grace that the game's gov­ern­ing body shows such lit­tle re­gard for the re­gion that once dom­i­nat­ed world crick­et. It's time for a change. The CWI must chal­lenge the ICC on this dis­par­i­ty in its fund­ing. It's time for CWI to fight for its play­ers, de­mand fair treat­ment from the ICC, and in­vest in the fu­ture of West In­dies crick­et. How is crick­et meant to be­come a glob­al sport if one team gets more than the oth­er teams com­bined? Yes, I un­der­stand that In­dia gen­er­ates the most rev­enue for the ICC, but this skewed fund­ing mod­el is un­sus­tain­able and does not serve crick­et as a glob­al sport. This fi­nan­cial chasm is re­flect­ed on the field, where the gulf in tal­ent and prepa­ra­tion is painful­ly ev­i­dent time and time again.

I feel it for the play­ers as much more can be done for them and to en­cour­age oth­er gift­ed play­ers in­to the Test are­na. I am al­so not naive as I am well aware that they, at times, played some poor crick­et. The bowl­ing, while show­ing flash­es of bril­liance, lacked con­sis­ten­cy. The Eng­lish bowlers, with the ex­cep­tion of An­der­son and Wood, are hard­ly world-beat­ers. Yet, they man­aged to ex­ploit the West In­dies' frail­ties with ruth­less ef­fi­cien­cy. Eng­land bowled with a plan and at­tacked with very few loose balls be­ing bowled, while the West In­dies bowlers bowled too many loose balls and were pun­ished every time they strayed in line or length.

The road to re­demp­tion for the West In­dies be­gins at Queen's Park Oval, Port-of-Spain as the first Test against a very good South African team starts on Wednes­day (Au­gust 7). The play­ers will feel more con­fi­dent at home, and I ex­pect a bet­ter per­for­mance from them. I hope the crowds, like in Eng­land, come out in their num­bers to ral­ly around the West In­dies.

One can on­ly hope for the team to re­dis­cov­er its fight­ing spir­it and give the home crowd some­thing to cheer about. The Oval needs to be a fortress, a place where the West In­dies can re­claim some of their lost pride. If no one in au­thor­i­ty cares about the play­ers, per­haps the fans will come out and show some love to the play­ers. Fans must ral­ly around the team. Fill the stands, make some noise, and show these play­ers that there are peo­ple who still be­lieve in them. Be­cause if we don't, who will? I am cer­tain they will show some fight and pedi­gree. See you at the Oval on Wednes­day!

Ed­i­tor’s note: The views ex­pressed in the pre­ced­ing ar­ti­cle are sole­ly those of the au­thor and do not re­flect the views of any or­gan­i­sa­tion in which he is a stake­hold­er.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored