Guyana may have won a mediocre tournament (though filled with exciting matches), but there is nothing in their performance to send shivers down the spine of any of the other teams which will be competing in South Africa. To participate in the Champions League, Guyana will need a lot of special individual performances, and the truth is Guyana does not possess the calibre of players to produce anything special. This team is just not up to international standard and will be a poor representative for this region. Guyana was not the best team in the tournament. Rather they were the best performing team in the current format, which is why the WICB will need to revisit the format of this tournament. Certainly a lot more matches should be played on a possible home and away basis.Guyana is a fighting team but you sense they played at their optimum and can go no further. The surfaces in South Africa will favour some pace and swing bowling but the Guyanese bowlers lack quality pace and their leading batsmen, Ramnaresh Sarwan, Travis Dowlin, Narsingh Deonarine and Siewnarine Chattergoon struggle against quality fast bowling.
I am afraid Guyana may create such a poor impression, that they will erode the goodwill as we look to earn two places in future IPL Champions League tournaments. While they have unearthed a bristling young talent with tremendous potential in 19-year-old Jonathan Foo, they must be careful as to how he is nurtured. There were some early indications he may be arrogant, which is the curse that dominates our talented youngsters, even in T&T. But sometimes, confidence may be mistaken for arrogance. Additionally, Foo will need to improve his strength work and be careful of his eating habits, less he falls into the same trap as Sarwan and Deonarine who have both put on too much weight in the wrong places. Guyana's fitness, both mental and physical, will be crucial in South Africa and therefore their overall fielding will have to improve. But it is not only in their batting that Guyana will have problems. Their bowling also has constraints. Do we really believe that the batsmen in the Champion League will have sleepless nights thinking of Guyana's opening bowlers, Eusuan Crandon and Christopher Barnwell or worse yet, will they be mesmerized by Lennox Cush lollipops or Devendra Bishoo's spin.
I hope the Guyanese population is not too annoyed by my observations.
I am doing this so their expectations will not be too high. My fear is there will be so much expected of these Guyanese players that unless we are open and honest, they will be shell shocked and devastated if they are humiliated and shamed in South Africa. The West Indies Cricket Board can start immediately to have a proper set-up for the team before and after they return from this tournament. If you examine the list of teams competing, one can understand the predicament they will be in. These are all professionally run organisations with proper team structures in every department, with the players only required to concentrate on the field. Guyana, as most of the teams in the Caribbean, will not have that sort of organisation. Instead it may very well be more one of disorganisation, especially as this current Guyanese team performed so well amidst reports that they would be sacked before the semifinal if they attempted to cover up a sponsor's name on their clothing. This continues to be the problem with the WICB, the role of the territorial boards in ignoring the basic principle of intellectual property rights.
So let us be honest, Guyana will not only fail to progress past the first round but in their group with Royal Challengers Bangalore and Mumbai Indians, South Australian Redbacks and South Africa's Highveld Lions, they face the prospect of losing all their preliminary matches. Can anyone say that Rahul Dravid, Jacques Kallis, Kevin Pietersen and Cameron White will be relishing the thought of facing Guyana's spin twins of Cush and Bishoo? It will be like taking candy from a baby for these men, who have been brought up on a diet of quality spin bowlers. Even Sachin Tendulkar will be happy and so too Dwayne Bravo and Kieron Pollard who will both get a chance to exact revenge on their Caribbean opponents. Shahid Afridi of South Australian Redbacks will be licking his chops at the thoughts of having Team Guyana as a succulent dessert. And let us not the forget players Neil McKenzie, Alviro Petersen, Andre Nel and a new and Lasith Malinga. Guyana's first match will be on September 12, at Centurion and their last of four matches in the first round on September 21, against Highveld Lions at Johannesburg. It is not Guyana's fault that they played only three serious matches to reach the finals. We need to ensure that rain does not allow us to be represented poorly in the future.
There is little doubt that both T&T and Jamaica are best equipped to handle overseas battles based on their recent history and the quality of their players. T&T lost because they had one terrible game and then got their batting order wrong. I still felt they could have won if Denesh Ramdin had used his brain instead of trying brawn. Jamaica on the other hand, played as if some of their players did not want to be there. Paul Campbell and his management produced a team under a badly overweight Tamar Lambert who was a disaster with bat and ball. Chris Gayle, one of the world's best T20 players never settled. He definitely did not look like he was supporting Lambert and his close friends, Wavell Hinds and Marlon Samuels, were no different. But Guyana have done what it had to do to get to South Africa. So congratulations. But they will fall short unless they can make some changes and additions. That, in itself is a problem since management will hesitate to change a winning team. They will need a quality opening fast bowler and at least two fit batsmen. It is not too late for Guyana to make these changes, starting with the return of Shivnarine Chanderpaul, otherwise they must prepare themselves for abject humiliation and hitherto, we in the Caribbean as well. So be it then.