JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, April 4, 2025

Injury, ice and POLICE during the COVID-19 lockdown

by

Ria Ramnarine
1804 days ago
20200426
Ria Ramnarine - Beyond The Game logo

Ria Ramnarine - Beyond The Game logo

Due to the cur­rent COVID-19 pan­dem­ic and the in­struc­tions to stay at home, many gym-go­ers and fit­ness fa­nat­ics are find­ing ways to en­sure that they re­main en­gaged in some form of phys­i­cal ac­tiv­i­ty or the oth­er.

Even the usu­al­ly seden­tary folks are join­ing in, fol­low­ing the many op­tions avail­able es­pe­cial­ly on so­cial me­dia. Face­book and In­sta­gram in par­tic­u­lar, are cur­rent­ly flood­ed with work­out videos, in­vi­ta­tions to join group ses­sions, and of­fers for per­son­al train­ing.

It is fair­ly safe to say thou­sands of peo­ple are en­gag­ing in var­i­ous forms and cat­e­gories of ex­er­cise and fit­ness which in­clude run­ning, HI­IT (high in­ten­si­ty in­ter­val train­ing), Taba­ta, yo­ga, cir­cuits, dance, gym­nas­tics and even con­tact sports like box­ing and kick­box­ing.

Af­ter all, there are con­stant re­minders to keep fit to sup­port your im­mune sys­tem and to stay healthy both men­tal­ly and phys­i­cal­ly. How­ev­er, there does not seem to be much dis­cus­sion on in­juries, or rather the treat­ment of in­juries, dur­ing these chal­leng­ing times, where­by one may not have easy ac­cess to a doc­tor or phys­io­ther­a­pist or such.

Most peo­ple are ac­cus­tomed to RICE (Rest, Ice, Com­pres­sion, El­e­va­tion), and it is a method that has been com­mon­ly used by both ath­letes and the av­er­age joe "work­ing out".

The RICE pro­to­col was in­vent­ed and coined by Dr Gabe Mirkin and pub­lished in 1978 in the best-sell­ing Sports Med­i­cine Book. It would, there­fore, be a sur­prise to many, that the same Doc­tor who in­vent­ed and coined the RICE pro­to­col, has since re­tract­ed his state­ments. Dr Mirkin is said to have in­di­cat­ed that the use of ice on in­juries may de­lay heal­ing in­stead, in the book, "Iced! The Il­lu­sion­ary Treat­ment Op­tion", Sec­ond Edi­tion, by Gary Reinl, 2014.

In an ar­ti­cle on his web­site, www.dr­mirkin.com, "Why Ice De­lays Re­cov­ery", Dr Mirkin al­so states: "Coach­es have used my "RICE" guide­line for decades, but now it ap­pears that both ice and com­plete rest may de­lay heal­ing, in­stead of help­ing".

He based his state­ments on a study of 22 sci­en­tif­ic ar­ti­cles (The Amer­i­can Jour­nal of Sports Med­i­cine, Jan­u­ary 2004) that did not find any sol­id ev­i­dence that the use of ice ac­cel­er­at­ed the heal­ing process of in­juries. Dr Mirkin fur­ther cit­ed a study in The Amer­i­can Jour­nal of Sports Med­i­cine, (June 2013) that while cool­ing de­layed swelling, it did not speed up the re­cov­ery of dam­aged mus­cles. The ar­gu­ment pre­sent­ed is that ic­ing pre­vents in­flam­ma­tion. How­ev­er, in­flam­ma­tion is the first step in the heal­ing process of tis­sue and mus­cle.

De­spite the above, oth­er stud­ies and ar­ti­cles have shown pos­i­tive re­sults in the use of ice, al­so known as cryother­a­py. The more re­cent pro­to­cols for treat­ment of in­juries are PRICE (Pro­tec­tion, Rest, Ice, Com­pres­sion, El­e­va­tion) and PO­LICE (Pro­tec­tion, Op­ti­mal Load­ing, Ice, Com­pres­sion, El­e­va­tion). The web­sites www.sports-health.com and www.physio-pe­dia.com both share the prin­ci­ples and tips on how to use ice with­in the treat­ment of in­juries.

Need­less to say, the ex­ist­ing stud­ies and re­search may give con­flict­ing in­for­ma­tion on ic­ing in­juries. How­ev­er, the ef­fect on pain is not dis­put­ed. The anal­gesic ef­fect of cryother­a­py, whether in the form of an ice pack, a pack of frozen peas or cold wa­ter im­mer­sion, has been proven in ba­si­cal­ly all doc­u­men­ta­tion. If for no oth­er rea­son, us­ing ice for an in­jury or mus­cle aches and sore­ness, can mean a sig­nif­i­cant­ly less painful ex­pe­ri­ence.

Still, we would like to look at pos­si­ble ways and rec­om­mend­ed meth­ods to treat mi­nor in­juries, aches and pains ob­tained from ex­er­cis­ing (es­pe­cial­ly nowa­days while at home).

The PO­LICE pro­to­col is easy to un­der­stand and fol­low.

Pro­tect: Aim - To pro­tect the in­jured tis­sue from un­due stress that may dis­rupt the heal­ing process; How - This could in­clude splint­ing or ban­dag­ing, mak­ing a sling, or us­ing crutch­es. Make sure the method of pro­tec­tion can ac­com­mo­date swelling; When and du­ra­tion - Im­me­di­ate­ly and for 3-5 days de­pend­ing on in­jury sever­i­ty.

Op­ti­mal Load­ing: Aim - To stim­u­late tis­sue heal­ing since too much rest can slow down re­cov­ery; How - Start sim­ple ex­er­cis­es gen­tly and care­ful­ly, then pro­gres­sive­ly work up to nor­mal lev­els of strength and move­ment; When and du­ra­tion - Rest for at least 24 hours af­ter in­jury, then be­gin a pro­gres­sive load­ing pro­gram un­til need­ed.

Ice: Aim - Ice helps con­strict the blood ves­sels there­by lim­it­ing bleed­ing, swelling and re­duces pain; How - Crushed ice wrapped in a damp tow­el or cloth is best; ice packs; or even a frozen pack of peas. Be sure that a cloth or tow­el is placed be­tween the skin and ice; When and du­ra­tion - The soon­er the bet­ter. Rec­om­mend­ed for 10-15 min­utes, every 3-4 hours, for up to 72 hours. (Be care­ful to re­frain from over-ic­ing).

Com­pres­sion: Aim - To re­duce and min­i­mize swelling; How - An elas­ti­cat­ed ban­dage can work. Wrap over­lap­ping each lay­er by half. Do not wrap too tight­ly!; When and du­ra­tion- As soon as pos­si­ble fol­low­ing in­jury and con­tin­ue for the first 72 hours to one week.

El­e­va­tion: Aim - To low­er the blood pres­sure to pre­vent swelling. Al­so to fa­cil­i­tate drainage of flu­id through the lym­phat­ic sys­tem. En­sure that the low­er limb is above the lev­el of the pelvis; How - Us­ing pil­lows, foot­stools, slings, etc; When and du­ra­tion - As soon as pos­si­ble fol­low­ing in­jury and at least for the first 72 hours.

PO­LICE pro­to­col adapt­ed from "Acute Soft Tis­sue In­jury Man­age­ment Up­date", writ­ten by Dr Chris Bleak­ley, phys­io­ther­a­pist, and lec­tur­er. He wrote the ar­ti­cle based on a doc­u­ment pub­lished by Phys­ios in Sport - As­so­ci­a­tion of Char­tered Phys­io­ther­a­pists in Sports and Ex­er­cise Med­i­cine (ACPSEM) in SportEX Med­i­cine, 2013, in which the PO­LICE pro­to­col was high­light­ed and high­ly rec­om­mend­ed.

Af­ter the first 72 hours, a slow tran­si­tion can be made to­wards us­ing heat. Heat in­creas­es and stim­u­lates blood flow, helps to re­lax mus­cles and pro­vides some re­lief to aching joints.

The rec­om­men­da­tions are not "one size fits all" and may need to be ad­just­ed ac­cord­ing­ly. Al­so, the very first step in case of an in­jury would be to speak with a doc­tor be­fore at­tempt­ing self-care.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored