As I sat down to write on horseracing, I could only hear the sound of the "Legends are Coming" running through my brain. And just as the organisers of this majestic once-in-a-lifetime event on Friday (May 10) have started with four World Cup-winning players from Brazil 2002 and beyond in Captain Cafu, Rivaldo, Kaka and Edmilson will be here. I pondered whether our horseracing heroes could be shown in a similar light to revive the sport in this country.
Last week around the world the top three-year-olds in the UK and the USA strutted their stuff over the past weekend with the 1000 and 2000 Guineas in England and the Kentucky Derby and Oaks in the US. One of the major features of the four races was the eclipse of the 2023 two-year-old champions, many of whom went into their respective races as strong favourites but with the exception of the two-year-old fillies champion in the US, all were comprehensively beaten. If history is anything to go by, this does not necessarily represent the end of their careers but comparisons to past greats have certainly ended for at least one horse, the so-called Coolmore Frankel, City of Troy.
When you look at all the interest and the growing momentum for this Legends vs T&T All Stars match, it sends a strong signal to many ahead of the match, that the people of this country appreciate a good product.
The first classic to be contested was the Kentucky Oaks at Churchill Downs in the US. The two-year-old fillies champion and Breeders Cup winner, Just FYI, was the lukewarm favourite given she had already tasted defeat in 2024 when making her debut in the Ashland Stakes at Keeneland. Although she reversed form with the winner that day, Leslie’s Rose, she was no match for the tough and cheaply bought, Thorpedo Anna. This filly was well supported in the market on the back of an impressive 2024 debut win in the Fantasy Stakes and she made no mistake when making all in the Oaks. This filly cost US $40,000 at the sales and must give hope to everyone that money does not buy a champion.
Just FYI ran on to be second but was always being held by the winner. Two fillies who showed promise for the future were Regulatory Risk and Ways and Means, both trained by Chad Brown. None of the other fillies showed much and it might be the better fillies did not contest the Oaks, particularly with the Bob Baffert fillies waiting in the wings for races outside of Kentucky.
Next it was the turn of the colts in the UK, with the 2000 Guineas being run off at Newmarket. This race was expected to be the three-year-old Coronation of the two-year-old champion, City of Troy. This son of Justify took the two-year-old season by storm, winning each of races with consummate ease. He was 4/6 to extend his unbeaten sequence but looked a shadow of the horse we saw in 2023. It is also noteworthy that both Just FYI and City of Troy are two-year-old champions sired by the unbeaten Justify who both failed to live up to expectations.
They are not the first Justify offsprings who appear not to be quite as good as three-year-olds as they were as two-year-olds but more evidence is probably needed. The flop of City of Troy threw open the race and the next best two-year-old in the race, Rosallion, ran his race in finishing second to the unbeaten and unraced, as a two-year-old, Notable Speech. There is a strong suspicion that the 2000 Guineas might turn out to be not quite as good as in prior years but time will tell.
The third home, Haatem, did win the Craven Stakes but he is a very well-exposed horse. Of the others, Ghostwriter (4th) and Task Force (7th) might progress to be the best of these albeit at different distances.
The Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs was next and although it produced an exhilarating three-horse finish, it is arguable that the quality was somewhat down on prior years. Once again, the two-year-old champion and Breeders Cup winner, Fierceness, was comprehensively beaten, having been sent off favourite after a dominant win in the Florida Derby. Justify had two sons in the race but neither figured with Just Steel (17th) and Just A Touch (20th) having their supporters but showing little in the race.
The winner Mystic Dan had the run of the race, scraping the inner rail throughout while the two horses that he nosed out Sierra Leone and Forever Young, having to take the overland route to make their challenge. Like the winner of the Kentucky Oaks, Mystic Dan was trained by Ken McPeek and ridden by Brian Hernandez, giving rider and trainer, a classic double. Sierra Leone who cost 2.3 million as a yearling compromised his chances by hanging to his right and would surely have won if he kept a straight line. His running style will always make him susceptible to horses with greater tactical pace for all he looks a Belmont horse. The Japanese runner has come closest for his country to date and with their other representative T.O. Password staying on strongly to be fifth, the Japanese are certainly getting closer. Mystic Dan was no match for Baffert’s Muth in the Arkansas Derby, and so a rematch between the two in the Preakness Stakes should be mouth-watering. Two horses who shaped well in the Derby with the future in mind are Catching Freedom (4th) and Resilience (6th) while it might be unwise to rule out Fierceness, given his wide draw and slow start may have compromised his chances on this day. And yet again I keep taking a page from the Legends campaign where our own local football legends can join with overseas footballers and wonder what has happened to those who manage the sport of Horseracing in terms of ideology.
The final classic of the early part of the season was the 1000 Guineas at Newmarket. As with the previous three classics, the race featured the two-year-old champion, Fallen Angel; a daughter of Justify, Ramatuelle – who was also an outstanding juvenile; Dance Sequence, aiming to give trainer/jockey combination of Charlie Appleby and William Buick, a classic double in the UK; and numerous unexposed fillies who showed ability in their classic trials. In the end, the winner was the lightly raced, Elmalka, who had only previously won her debut on the all-weather before a nice third in the Fred Darling. The first five horses were covered by a length which suggests the form may not be very strong with the two horses to take out of the race being the fourth and fifth, Ylang Ylang and Tamfanawho were both staying on strongly at the end. Ramatuelle gave Justify another second-place finish in a fillies’ classic while the two-year-old champion, Fallen Angel, like the UK two-year-old juvenile champion City of Troy, was comprehensively beaten.
The quality of the races in the UK and US, give local horse racing turfites quite a bit to enjoy. Long may it continue given the poor nature of the local racing fare and the fact that our three-year-old race is end of the month in Easter Guineas.
We need some "Legends in Horseracing" to come to this country to help restore the image of the sport.