The withdrawal of FIFA vice-president Mohamed bin Hammam, the first person to mount a significant challenge to the organisation's president, Sepp Blatter in almost a decade, from the election race for the post to "clear his name," leaves CONCACAF president Jack Warner in a curious position. Bin Hammam's decision might well have been moot, considering the suspension order handed down by FIFA's Ethics Committee while the presidential contender and Jack Warner, a man he described as "his good friend," are being investigated on charges of offering US$40,000 bribes to members of the Caribbean Football Union (CFU) for their votes in FIFA's 2011 election.
It's now almost a foregone conclusion that Blatter will be returned to the FIFA presidency for a fourth term unopposed while the two men, now linked through the ethics charges as his challengers, will need to respond to the probe occasioned by the report crafted by Chuck Blazer, the only American serving on the organisation's executive committee since 1996. The suspension of the two accused men from active duty is clearly the correct course of action while they are being investigated on these allegations, particularly when FIFA's probity as the governing body for football is coming under increasing scrutiny.
This is not a time for FIFA to proceed as an organisation with anything less than a close reading of its own rules of conduct.
Since October 2010, while FIFA was managing its selection of the host nations for the 2018 and 2022 World Cup finals, serious questions were being raised about the methods employed to influence the voting process. Because of those investigations, executive committee member Reynald Temarii of the Oceania Football Federation was suspended from football related activity for three years and Nigeria's Amos Adamu for one year. Both men continue to protest their innocence of the charges. Other FIFA officials suspended as part of that investigation include Botswana's Ismael Bhamjee (four-year suspension), Mali's Amadou Diakite and Tonga's Ahongalu Fusimalohi (three years each) and Slim Aloulou of Tunisia (two years).
For UK football fans, it would be a bittersweet victory, and the penalty for these ethics lapses would provide little salve for the humiliation of losing an opportunity to host the largest incarnation of the game that England gave to the world. During that rash of ethics accusations, Warner brashly weathered the outrage of English journalists, who ceaselessly recounted the stories of his interactions with the UK politicians and royalty who wooed his voting bloc. Those accusations are hardly the only ones levelled at the CONCACAF President who controls a large block of FIFA votes in that role, but it remains to be seen whether Warner can emerge unscathed from this investigation, which appears to have placed him in opposition to long standing supporter Sepp Blatter.
In play from the point of view of football observers is Jack Warner's position as the pre-eminent voice for football in this part of the hemisphere, but the football supremo's position on the field goes beyond the beautiful game and Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar must be aware of the consequences to Trinidad and Tobago of this level of international scrutiny of her Minister of Works and Transport. When questions were raised about Jack Warner's dual positions with FIFA and the Government of Trinidad and Tobago, it was argued by some that Warner's work with FIFA would redound to the benefit of Trinidad and Tobago. Given what has transpired over the last fortnight, that clearly is no longer a sustainable argument.
At the press conference in Zurich, Ethics Committee Chair Petrus Damaseb announced that there was a case for Warner and Bin Hammam to answer, that they were suspended from football activity until it was answered and that there were no grounds to stop the election next week. With bin Hammam off the slate, it seems that Blatter, cleared of any charges by the committee, will be elected by acclamation.
But where will that leave Jack Warner? It won't be until June or July that the final investigation of FIFA is expected to be concluded, but with Blatter claiming to be aware of the alleged payments to the CFU, the outlook looks grim for Warner.