I understand and appreciate the power of credit unions.
I know of someone who made their financial dreams come true because of a credit union.
The credit union’s reasonable interest rates helped him secure a mortgage and fund his son’s education.
This is however not an isolated incident.
Credit unions have saved many lives.
Sadly, I have also seen the negative aspects of a credit union.
A decade ago I was assigned to cover the Commission of Enquiry into the Hindu Credit Union.
And it was heartbreaking to see people sitting in the witness box telling of their experiences of losing the money they had saved.
One such person was Camini Cole who told the Commission of Enquiry that she could only get back $500 after she had invested her life savings.
According to a T&T Guardian report during that hearing, Jennifer Gobin said the lack of oversight by the Commissioner of Co-operatives into the growth and expansion of the HCU was one factor to consider.
“And although I may cry, it’s crying out of anger because the people who have the power vested in them to actually make the situation better are just not doing anything about it. Whoever has caused this situation to happen—while I am not saying Mr Harnarine solely caused the demise of the HCU—I am saying I am certain he enjoys his quality of life while myself and my family continue to suffer. There’s some unfairness about that,” Gobin told the commission.
Gobin, who spoke of counselling other cash-strapped shareholders of the HCU, said the commission was the first forum that allowed them to outline their woes.
She explained that the shareholders could not drum up the money to pay for a lawyer and had written to ten attorneys seeking representation but were rejected. She said a letter was also sent to the Ministry of Finance with a request for financial assistance to pay for legal representation but the advice was to seek help from the Legal Aid Authority.
Today, as we celebrate International Credit Union (ICU) Day, it is the perfect time for us to consider that we need to ensure there is proper regulation for our credit unions.
Credit unions, as financial co-operatives, are supervised by the Co-operative Development Division which is under the remit of the Ministry of Youth Development and National Service.
It is peculiar that this ministry is responsible for credit unions.
“The Government takes the Credit Union Movement very seriously. This Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) helps Co-operatives, through the Co-operative Development Division, to tap into the expertise of the Central Bank of T&T,” Minister of Youth Development and National Service Foster Cummings said.
I sincerely hope this sentiment holds true.
Recently both Eastern Credit Union and Venture Credit Union have been in the media for various reasons.
I will not return to what those issues are in this space only to say that the hundred if not thousands of lives in those institutions as well as the entire credit union industry must be properly protected.
The collapse of an institution such as the HCU is something we should never experience again.
There is reassurance as there is some measure of self-regulation.
The Co-operative Credit Union League of T&T is the legitimate national umbrella body for credit unions in the country. It represents 688,000 members, 129 credit unions, and $17 billion in assets.
Its core function includes advocacy, lobbying, and training and development for and on behalf of credit unions and their members.
While credit unions offer many of the same services as banks, they possess some distinct advantages.
Let’s count the ways:
Both financial institutions offer similar services, including chequing and savings accounts, auto loans, and mortgages, but the main difference is the fact that credit unions have members, not customers, and these members own the institution.
A bank is a company, and like most companies, a bank aims to maximise profits for its shareholders.
A credit union is a cooperative—and often not-for-profit—institution that is owned by its members who democratically elect a board of directors.
Credit unions focus on members’ needs and provide credit at reasonable rates. Loans at credit unions require little or no fees while the fees at banks are quite high.
Unlike banks, however, credit unions only service members, who can join the union only if they meet certain eligibility requirements such as residential status, place of employment, or membership in certain civic organisations.
Originally developed to provide an alternative to for-profit banks, credit unions continue to serve that purpose today, on both a local and national level.
International Credit Union Day celebrates the spirit of the global credit union movement. The day is recognised to reflect upon the credit union movement’s history, promote its achievements, recognise hard work, and share member experiences.
Commemorated on the third Thursday of October since 1948, the ultimate goal of the credit union movement is to raise awareness about the tremendous work that credit unions and other financial cooperatives are doing around the world.
The theme this year is “Empower Your Financial Future with a Credit Union.”