For a population that is renowned for having a nine-day memory, it is noteworthy that four months after the tragic death of Joshua Samaroo and the serious injury of his girlfriend Kaia Sealy in a police-involved shooting, the matter continues to grab national headlines.
In fact, it is arguable whether any other murder investigation in the last decade has provoked the public's ire as much as the January 20 shooting death of Samaroo, who was in a crashed car in St Augustine with Sealy at the time of the controversial incident.
The public's interest is partly due to the couple being young and representative of Trinidad and Tobago's two major ethnic groups. But the story was pushed to the top of many news cycles due to the very widely circulated video that showed, to most of the people who viewed it, Samaroo meeting his demise in a hail of police bullets as he had his hands up in the traditional sign of surrender.
However, the story has morphed from being seen as just another extrajudicial police killing—of which this country, quite unfortunately, has had too many—to something quite extraordinary, after T&T’s long-serving Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Roger Gaspard, last Thursday instructed that Sealy be charged with three counts of shooting with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, shooting at the police and the unlawful killing of Samaroo.
Those initial charges resulted in what can only be described as collective national disbelief, which was compounded on Tuesday when four additional charges relating to possession of a firearm and ammunition were laid against Sealy, who is currently receiving medical treatment in the US for injuries sustained in the January shooting.
The drama did not end there. The Samaroo case entered a different phase when a group of Kaia’s friends and supporters decided to stage a demonstration outside the DPP's office in Port-of-Spain on Wednesday.
As Deputy Commissioner of Police, Operations, Suzette Martin, acknowledged in a statement on Sunday that while protests are not prohibited under the current State of Emergency, all public gatherings must comply with the Emergency Powers Regulations. This, Martin added, meant the TTPS has a responsibility to maintain public safety and preserve public order, including the lawful dispersal of such assemblies if they are deemed a threat to public safety.
With that said, it would be difficult for the police service to sustain an argument that a few dozen people with placards and posters calling for the removal of the Commissioner of Police and the Minister of Homeland Security constituted either a threat to public safety or endangered public order.
What is more intriguing is the Emergency Powers (Prohibition of Public Protests and Demonstrations) Order, 2026, signed by the Commissioner of Police Allister Guevarro on Wednesday, which prevents protests within 500 metres of 15 key buildings, including the DPP's office, the Parliament, the Office of the President, the Office of the Prime Minister, the T&T Police Service headquarters and all police stations in the country.
Interestingly, the move was made by the CoP on the same day police shut down a request by Kaia’s friends and supporters for a protest outside the DPP’s office that ended in arrests.
It leaves one to wonder about the timing of the CoP’s latest move—the legality of which is also shrouded in doubt because the document had not been published in the T&T Gazette up to last night.
