Crime, security and economic confidence have become increasingly intertwined, prompting business organisations across T&T to back stronger action against violent crime, while calling for any expansion of the Special Operations Act (SOA) to be targeted, intelligence-driven and carefully monitored.
From San Fernando and Arima to San Juan, Tunapuna and Tobago, chambers and business associations say crime continues to undermine investment, business growth and public confidence.
While supportive of efforts to restore law and order, they are urging that any extension of special security measures be guided by credible intelligence, measurable results and regular reviews to ensure effectiveness while minimising disruption to legitimate businesses and law-abiding citizens.
Chairman of the Confederation of Regional Business Chambers (CRBC), Vivek Charran, said recent reductions in crime should not diminish concerns about the severity of criminal activity in some communities.
“The seriousness of the crimes in some areas, where the authorities believe the Special Operations Act may assist or add meaningful value, should be a careful consideration,” he said.
Charran noted that where authorities identify communities facing serious gang violence and security threats, the legislation may have a role in helping to restore public safety.
However, he stressed that any expansion must be backed by sufficient police resources, intelligence capabilities, equipment and logistical support.
In addition to operational readiness, Charran said regular reviews and safeguards would be necessary to ensure businesses remain functional and that the rights of law-abiding citizens are respected throughout any special operations.
T&T Chamber: Crime is a national development issue
A similar view was shared by the T&T Chamber of Industry and Commerce, which framed crime as more than a security concern.
It argued that crime has evolved into a national development issue with direct implications for investment, employment and economic growth.
“Crime is a national development issue. Protecting employees and customers, ensuring the safe movement of goods and enabling businesses to operate with confidence are essential to investment, jobs and economic growth.”
While supporting decisive intervention in communities affected by violence, the T&T Chamber stressed the importance of maintaining an environment where legitimate commerce can continue uninterrupted.
“National security measures should not be implemented to be a hindrance to business and commerce, or negatively impact our Small and Medium Sized Entrepreneurs (SMEs) who contribute to the economic stability of the country,” it added.
It noted that any consideration of extending special operations to other areas should be guided by evidence, the requirements of the law and appropriate safeguards for citizens and businesses as it called for measurable objectives, regular reporting and clear performance indicators.
Further, the private sector organisation stated that clear communication with affected communities and businesses is equally important as practical arrangements for employees, deliveries and essential services, respect for citizens’ rights and accessible complaints procedures would help minimise disruption and build public confidence.
San Fernando chamber supports expansion with safeguards
Echoing the call for balance, President of the Greater San Fernando Area Chamber of Commerce, Kiran Singh, said the need for strategic intervention is recognised and there may be justification for extending special operations into other areas if the current measures are delivering results.
“We must recognise that crime does not respect geographical boundaries. Therefore, if the existing framework is proving effective in disrupting criminal networks and restoring a sense of security in targeted communities, there is merit in considering its application elsewhere,” he said.
However, he cautioned that effectiveness should be measured by long-term improvements rather than short-term enforcement statistics.
“The effectiveness of this legislation must not be measured solely by the number of arrests or the intensity of security operations, but by whether it produces sustainable improvements in public safety and restores confidence among citizens and the business community,” Singh said.
He also advocated for accountability mechanisms, warning that security measures should not unnecessarily disrupt legitimate business activity or infringe upon individual rights.
Among the recommendations put forward by the chamber are clear operational boundaries, periodic reviews, stakeholder consultation, protections for businesses and employees, and the use of body-worn cameras by police officers.
San Juan demands intelligence-led action
The importance of intelligence gathering was a recurring theme among stakeholders, particularly for the San Juan Business Association.
President Abrahim Ali said any decision to restrict movement or impose special measures in a community must be based on credible intelligence and clear evidence.
“There must be much more intelligence when they’re going into an area, particularly when they want to lockdown that area and take away the liberty and rights of freedom from the citizens,” said Ali.
Ali argued that authorities must have sufficient information to justify operations and produce meaningful results and that “they must have good information leading them into arrests and seizures of arms and ammunition and whatever illicit things they’re looking for.”
At the same time, he warned against prolonged restrictions that could place unnecessary burdens on businesses and residents.
“These lockdowns should not be inevitably too long and exhausting to the residents.”
He maintained that enforcement efforts should target criminal elements directly rather than broadly affecting entire communities.
“Whenever you’re going into an area, it should be because you have enough information, evidence and intelligence to see that you’re going to get some items that really requires being seized and you’re getting some charges laid on citizens who may be involved in criminal activities,” he added.
Responding specifically to questions about San Juan, Ali said he does not believe the district currently warrants blanket restrictions.
Instead, he argued that intelligence should determine where intervention is needed.
“What we require is intelligence on the ground that will say to the police and the persons responsible for security that there are some areas that need attention and may need or require lockdowns to get it under control,” he said.
Arima group wants results assessed
While some organisations have expressed support for the expansion of special operations, president of the Arima Business Association, Sudesh Ramkissoon, said the measure should be given an opportunity to demonstrate its effectiveness before conclusions are drawn.
“The intention of the bill should be when an area has become heated, this particular action will be taken to coordinate a particular area to try and resolve the issue so that it doesn’t affect the rest of the public,” he said stating that a fair assessment could only take place after authorities have had sufficient time to implement the legislation.
He suggested that the true test would come after restrictions are lifted and communities return to normal operations.
Ramkissoon also noted that not every community necessarily requires the same response and that interventions should be tailored to local conditions.
Tobago chamber warns against economic fallout
Concerns about unintended economic consequences were also raised by the chairman of the Tobago Division of the T&T Chamber of Industry and Commerce, Curtis Williams, who said crime continues to undermine investor confidence, business expansion and broader economic development.
“The safety and security of our citizens, businesses and communities must remain a national priority. Crime continues to present a serious challenge to economic activity, investor confidence, business expansion and ultimately, the quality of life of our people,” he said.
While supporting decisive interventions where necessary, Williams agreed any expansion of the SOA should be evidence-based and carefully coordinated as he cautioned that poorly managed restrictions could create economic disruptions without delivering meaningful security improvements.
“It must not simply become a broad-based exercise that inconveniences law-abiding citizens and businesses without producing measurable improvements in public safety,” he said.
Williams added that Tobago’s tourism-dependent economy makes the island particularly vulnerable to any measures that restrict movement or commercial activity stressing, “Our concern is that poorly managed restrictions on movement, commercial activity and access to communities could have unintended economic consequences, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises that are already operating in a challenging business environment.”
Tunapuna organisation seeks balance and oversight
That emphasis on balance was echoed by President of the Greater Tunapuna Chamber of Industry and Commerce (GTCIC) Ramon Gregorio who supports strong action against crime and believes extending the SOA to additional hotspots should be considered where there is clear evidence that criminal activity is threatening communities and businesses.
However, Gregorio said any expansion must be accompanied by clear oversight mechanisms and measurable outcomes.
“Any extension must be guided by proper intelligence, measurable results and a clear understanding of the impact on the people who live and operate businesses in these areas,” he said, warning against the risk of unfairly stigmatising entire communities because of the actions of a minority.
To ensure accountability, Gregorio called for clear operational guidelines, defined timelines and regular assessments of effectiveness.
He added that businesses should be consulted where operations may affect opening hours, customer access, employee movement and deliveries.
At the same time, Gregorio stressed that enforcement alone cannot solve the country’s crime challenges.
