Caribbean countries must push for more grant financing to prepare climate resilience projects, rather than using scarce grant resources to make development bank loans cheaper, economist Avinash Persaud has said.
Persaud, special adviser to the president of the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) on climate change, said the region’s inability to prepare bankable projects was a major obstacle to accessing the financing needed to address its growing climate vulnerabilities.
Speaking on Friday during a panel discussion on Multilateral Development Bank and Development Partner Collaboration to Scale Caribbean Climate and Resilience Finance at the Caricom Pavilion on the sidelines of COP31, Persaud argued that grant funding should be directed towards feasibility studies, pre-feasibility assessments and engineering work.
He said while Caribbean countries had significant resilience needs, relatively few projects were reaching the multinational financing stage because governments lacked the resources to develop them.
“The problem is that that money is actually the riskiest of all,” Persaud said, explaining that feasibility studies could establish that a proposed project was not viable, leaving a government with debt but no infrastructure to show for it.
He argued that this made grant financing particularly important during the early stages of project development.
Persaud said multilateral climate funds and multilateral development banks were increasingly working together, but their collaboration was often resulting in grant resources being used to reduce the cost of loans.
While acknowledging the benefits of cheaper borrowing, he said this was not necessarily the most effective use of limited grant funding.
He recalled his experience working alongside Caribbean governments, noting that countries would be prepared to undertake projects at interest rates of four or even 3.5 per cent, compared with the 9.0, 10 or 11 per cent rates at which some governments borrowed.
“The problem is the project is unbankable. That’s the obstacle. And it’s unbankable because engineering costs millions of dollars,” he said.
Persaud cited water management infrastructure as an example, explaining that proper project preparation in one Caribbean country could cost US$7.5 million.
He called for grant resources to be redirected towards these early-stage costs, arguing that feasibility studies financed with public money should be published so other countries and development partners could benefit from the work.
He described project preparation as a public good that could help unlock a pipeline of investment-ready climate resilience projects across the region.
On private sector financing, Persaud said there was significant potential to attract institutional investors, given the estimated US$100 trillion in private sector funds invested globally.
However, he cautioned that private investors were not charities and required identifiable revenue streams to justify their investments.
He said such opportunities were more readily available in climate mitigation projects, including solar farms, wind turbines and hydroelectric power, than in climate resilience infrastructure.
Persaud suggested that multilateral development banks, including the Caribbean Development Bank (CDB) and the IDB, could help private investors manage foreign exchange and credit risks without necessarily committing substantial amounts of their own capital.
Their balance sheets, he said, should be preserved for areas where private financing was less readily available, particularly public infrastructure.
He also highlighted the region’s limited fiscal space, linking mounting public debt to the recurring costs of natural disasters.
Persaud referenced a University of the West Indies project which found that 50 per cent of the increase in Caribbean debt was associated with natural disasters.
He said this left governments exposed to higher interest rates and pressure on their credit ratings, making additional borrowing, even at concessional rates, an insufficient solution.
He pointed to Caribbean-led innovations in debt restructuring, including debt swaps, as another avenue for financing resilience.
Through arrangements involving highly rated guarantees and collaboration with institutions such as the CDB, countries could reduce borrowing costs by four to six percentage points.
The savings could then be capitalised into a lump sum to finance resilient infrastructure.
Persaud also cited regional initiatives involving the CDB, the Development Bank of Latin America and the Caribbean (CAF) and the World Bank, saying their collaboration had helped create larger-scale debt swap arrangements.
However, he returned to what he described as the fundamental requirement for progress: adequate project preparation.
“None of these projects can happen unless the pre-feasibility has been done,” he said.
