Derek Achong
Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
The Court of Appeal has ordered the release of a man who was convicted of murder based on the evidence of his cousin.
Delivering an oral judgment after hearing submissions at the Hall of Justice in Port-of-Spain, Appellate Judges Mark Mohammed, Gillian Lucky and Ricky Rahim upheld Adim “Psycho” Reece’s appeal over his conviction.
The appeal panel declined to order a retrial for Reece as his cousin, Sherman Lambkin, on whose evidence the entire case against him was based, was himself murdered in a home invasion in April.
Reece was accused of murdering Devon Poptee on December 26, 2005.
Lambkin claimed Reece came to visit him and other relatives in Valencia and asked him and a friend to identify a group of men who had stabbed him (Lambkin) a little over a week before.
Lambkin claimed that they met Poptee, whom he described as a friend, near a bridge.
He claimed that Reece asked Poptee to help identify Lambkin’s attackers, and he led them through a track leading to a river.
Lambkin claimed that Reece instructed him and his friend to walk ahead while he stayed behind with Poptee.
He claimed that he saw Poptee stooping down and then heard a gunshot. He alleged that Reece threatened him and his friend over talking about what they witnessed before they left the area.
Poptee’s body was found by residents the following morning. An autopsy revealed that he had been shot in the head.
Lambkin was eventually arrested by police but was released after implicating his cousin.
Homicide detectives obtained a warrant for Reece’s arrest but it was executed over a year and a half later.
Reece was convicted of the crime by former High Court Judge and current Appellate Judge Carla Brown-Antoine at the end of a judge-alone trial in September 2022.
In the appeal, Reece’s lawyer Daniel Khan, of Justitia Omnibus Chambers, successfully argued that the trial judge failed to carefully consider whether Lambkin had an interest to serve when he implicated his cousin.
Justice Mohammed found that the judge unduly relied on police officers claiming that Lambkin was cleared as a suspect and the fact that he was not interrogated over fabricating the case against Reece during the trial.
He also noted that the judge should have considered Lambkin’s connection to Reece’s purported action in seeking out his (Lambkin) attackers. He pointed out that the judge should have also considered that Lambkin only cooperated with the police after he was held as a suspect.
In considering whether a retrial was appropriate, the panel agreed with Reece’s other lawyer Michelle Gonzales, who questioned the State’s ability to successfully prosecute the case without Lambkin.
While she accepted Assistant Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Anju Bhola’s submission over the State’s ability to use transcripts of Lambkin’s testimony from the first trial, Gonzales pointed out that Lambkin could not answer pertinent questions over the veracity of his claims against Reece that arose during the appeal.
Justice Mohammed said: “There would be a grave disadvantage that would skew the fairness of a retrial.”
The decision meant the immediate release of Reece, who participated in the appeal from prison via video conferencing.
Reece was also represented by Harrynarine Singh.
