Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
The Water and Sewerage Authority (WASA) has suffered another defeat in its property dispute over a parcel of land in San Juan.
Chief Justice Ronnie Boodoosingh and Appellate Judges Ricky Rahim and Frank Seepersad dismissed WASA’s appeal against Anderson Richards. The panel delivered its judgment less than an hour after hearing submissions at the Hall of Justice in Port-of-Spain.
WASA argued that a High Court judge was wrong to find that Richards acquired title to the land through adverse possession. But Justice Seepersad, who delivered the decision, said the judge’s assessment of the evidence could not be faulted.
“Most of the complaints maintained by the appellant invite a different evaluation of the factual material which the trial judge considered,” he said.
The panel examined the alleged weaknesses in the decision but found that WASA had not shown the judge was plainly wrong or that any procedural complaint materially affected the outcome.
The case concerned a 5,000-square-foot parcel at Glen Road, El Socorro Road, San Juan. Herbert Johnson, a friend of Richards’s mother who worked for WASA from 1973 to 1991, began planting a vegetable garden there in 1977.
Richards said Johnson invited him to help cultivate the land while he was still a minor, in exchange for pocket money. In December 2015, a bailiff hired by WASA evicted Richards and destroyed his crops.
Richards sued, claiming that he and Johnson had occupied the land without interruption for more than the 16 years required to establish adverse possession.
WASA argued that Johnson had been granted a personal, non-assignable licence to cultivate the land, which ended when he stopped actively planting crops in 1995.
The High Court judge rejected WASA’s argument that only Johnson could claim the land. She found that Richards could acquire title even if he and Johnson had not continuously cultivated it. She also questioned WASA’s position that cultivation was prohibited to protect the water aquifer, given its claim that it had licensed Johnson to cultivate the land.
Richards was represented by Navindra Ramnanan.
