Senior Reporter
kay-marie.fletcher@guardian.co.tt
Opposition Leader Pennelope Beckles is threatening legal action against the Government over the controversial Maloney lockdown, giving Attorney General John Jeremie and Cabinet until Friday to introduce immediate safeguards for residents whose constitutional rights she believes are being violated.
In a ten-page pre-action protocol letter dated November 17, Beckles is challenging the constitutionality of several provisions of the legislation and the legality of the orders declaring the Maloney Buildings Housing Development a closed area and imposing a nightly curfew.
The letter, served by attorneys Hove and Associates, gives the Government until Friday 4 pm to confirm that immediate safeguards will be implemented to protect residents’ rights.
A second deadline of 4 pm on November 24 has been set for a full response, including documents detailing the police intelligence and circumstances relied upon to justify the operation.
Beckles has threatened to take the matter to court if the Government fails to meet the deadlines, seeking to overturn the Maloney orders and have several provisions of the Special Operations Act declared unconstitutional.
Speaking at an Opposition media conference yesterday, Beckles confirmed that she had instructed her attorneys to pursue the matter in the public interest, arguing that the Government had failed to adequately justify the restrictions.
She said, “As the leader of the Opposition, I have also given instructions for an application to be filed. Because this is basically public interest litigation. And therefore, I have decided that this matter is sufficiently important to do precisely that.”
The development follows a separate constitutional challenge filed on Monday by social activist Wendell Eversley, whose legal team is led by former prime minister Stuart Young, SC.
Eversley’s lawsuit is seeking several declarations, including that the Special Operations Act is unconstitutional, null and void.
Beckles’ pre-action protocol letter identifies six grounds for the proposed legal challenge, including allegations that the Government failed to satisfy the legal requirements for imposing the restrictions, that the measures are disproportionate and that the permit and curfew regime is not “prescribed by law”.
It also raises concerns about the constitutional rights of detained persons, possible political bias and the Prime Minister’s involvement in operational policing decisions.
It emphasises that the Government has not demonstrated why ordinary policing measures were insufficient to address the violence in Maloney.
According to the letter, Section 11(1)(b) of the Act requires that ordinary law enforcement measures be unable to address the situation before the extraordinary powers can be invoked.
Beckles’ attorneys contend that there is no evidence Cabinet took reasonable steps to establish whether that legal threshold had been met before advising the President to issue the orders.
They are now demanding the written request from Commissioner of Police Allister Guevarro, any supporting intelligence assessments, the relevant Cabinet note and minute, and the advice submitted to the President.
The letter also requests the statement of the grounds for imposing the orders, all material relied upon to establish that the necessary legal conditions existed, and a map clearly identifying the boundaries of the closed area.
Beckles is further demanding the intended duration of the restrictions and details of any review mechanism, proposed end date or criteria for bringing the operation to an end.
Another significant demand concerns police body-camera footage and records of the operation.
The letter also confirms that separate requests under the Freedom of Information Act have been made to the Office of the Prime Minister, the Attorney General’s Office, the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service and the Ministry of Homeland Security.
However, Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar has dismissed Beckles’ threatened legal action, accusing the PNM of wasting the Attorney General’s time and questioning why anyone would oppose the police operation in Maloney.
Responding to questions from Guardian Media yesterday, Persad-Bissessar said, “The PNM should stop wasting the AG’s time with this nonsense. She should be happy that the TTPS is clearing out gangs and firearms from Maloney. I can’t see why anyone would be against that.”
However, the Prime Minister did not directly address the constitutional concerns raised in Beckles’ pre-action protocol letter or the demands for evidence justifying the restrictions.
Attorney General Jeremie did not respond to questions up to press time.
