Senior Reporter
dareece.polo@guardian.co.tt
The People’s National Movement (PNM) has filed a motion of no confidence against Housing Minister David Lee, asking the House of Representatives to advise the President to revoke his appointment with immediate effect.
The motion, filed on Monday in the name of Trincity/Maloney MP Camille Robinson-Regis, invokes section 77(3) of the Constitution. It argues that maintaining public confidence requires integrity and ministerial responsibility.
PNM chairman Marvin Gonzales said Lee was entitled to the presumption of innocence but should leave public office while defending himself against the criminal charges.
“This matter will not go away, Mr Lee. Because as long as you continue to face criminal, serious criminal charges on your conduct in public office — we are saying that you are entitled to the presumption of innocence. But whilst you do so you must leave public office and go and fight your case in the courts,” Gonzales said.
He said the PNM’s position was consistent with its previous calls for public officials to leave office amid serious allegations, citing former ministers Jack Warner and Mary King.
“We are asking the Prime Minister what has changed with respect to David Lee?”
The motion comes as some residents of Lee’s Caroni Central constituency question his political future and his record as their representative.
During a visit to parts of the constituency, Guardian Media found many residents were not immediately accessible. Some were behind the gates of their properties, while others were not at home. Those seen outdoors were mostly elderly residents and pensioners.
Residents offered mixed views. Some defended Lee’s record, pointing to improvements in the water supply. Others raised concerns about roads, drainage and his accessibility.
Lee secured 18,431 votes at the last general election, from an electorate of 31,460. Caroni Central has been a stronghold of the United National Congress (UNC), which has won every general election in the constituency since it was recreated in 1991.
For 56-year-old Joycelyn Ali, Lee has helped ensure her household has a reliable water supply.
“First of all I wanna tell you all I have water in meh pipe. And why I saying that is, for the last 10 years, we never had water. We used to get water once, twice a week. Sometimes once a week. We have water in our tap since David Lee in power.”
Ali described Lee as a good representative who had supported residents and helped address their concerns. But she said her support for him did not mean she was condoning the allegations before the court.
“I am not condoning it. Only (God can) judge. Let the law take its course. That’s me. If he’s guilty, face the consequence. If he’s not, I support him. Either way, I support him.”
A resident who spoke on condition of anonymity said Lee should step aside until the matter was resolved.
“When things go like that you’re supposed to step down til everything in order,” he said.
The resident said his concerns also included the community’s drainage and roads.
“Water ain’t all. Look at the condition of the place. This want drainage. Here want box drain to pull the water and when water ent pulling from the road it damaging the road,” he said.
A 67-year-old woman who has lived in the area for about 20 years urged people to give Lee a chance.
“I think give him a chance,” she said, adding that “everybody deserves a second chance”.
She said conditions had improved under Lee, particularly the water supply, which residents now receive when they request it. She also recalled water-related difficulties under the previous administration.
A 71-year-old man who has lived in the constituency for 40 years gave a different assessment. He pointed to the main road and questioned Lee’s accessibility.
“If you look at the road alone, that main road there, that road needs fixing. And yuh don’t see he around here at all. Yuh don’t see him. You have to go to the office to meet he and when you go dey to meet him, yuh stand a chance not to see him. So, I don’t think his performance is good here.”
He suggested the constituency’s long-standing political loyalty might have contributed to a lack of accountability.
“Once they know is a safe seat, they don’t care about you. Most of the MPs who pass through here, they never perform, eh. Because is UNC MP, they sure about that.”
Joseph Showers said integrity in public office was crucial. “I think they should move him. Because, the fraud thing,” he said.
Dereck Jhinoo, who has lived in the constituency for 15 years, said he had seen Lee once during the election campaign and questioned his contribution to the area.
“Look at the condition of the roads up here. A place like Freeport. Dah is one of dey stronghold. So, to me, it ain’t no positive with he.”
Jhinoo agreed Lee should step down while the matter was before the courts. He also complained that residents had to fight for basic improvements.
An Arena resident said Lee had never visited to introduce himself or offer assistance.
“He have never come to say, well, OK, you is the man from here representing we. Come and give us a lil, if is a lie self, come and give us something. Never,” the resident said.
The resident said Lee should step down if convicted.
