Senior Reporter
shane.superville@guardian.co.tt
PNM chairman and former National Security minister Marvin Gonzales says his concerns about the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service’s (TTPS) comparison of murder figures for 2026 and 2024 remain valid, despite the service’s explanation for using those years.
In a statement on Friday, Gonzales criticised the TTPS for comparing the murder toll in 2024, when the PNM was in office, with that of 2026, when the UNC is in office. The comparison showed a 46.2 per cent drop in murders between the two years.
Gonzales called the presentation “misleading” and urged the Police Service Commission (PolSC) to audit the crime statistics published by the TTPS.
In a media release yesterday, the TTPS explained that 2024 was the year with the highest number of murders in the country’s history, making it an important benchmark for assessing progress.
“As a result, comparisons against 2024 provide an important measure of how the country has progressed from the most severe levels of violence ever experienced,” the release stated.
The TTPS said both short-term comparisons between successive years and longer-term comparisons were useful in assessing crime trends and informing strategy and policy.
“Year-on-year comparisons remain an important tool for measuring immediate changes in crime levels and are routinely used by the TTPS,” the release stated.
“These comparisons answer the question of whether crime is increasing or decreasing when measured against the corresponding period of the previous year.
“Historical comparisons serve a different purpose. They allow the service and the public to assess progress against their most challenging periods in the nation’s history and determine whether long-term reductions are being achieved and sustained.”
When contacted yesterday, Gonzales said his criticism of the comparison remained valid.
“This is a serious matter. When the TTPS is boasting of a 46 per cent decrease in crime, it begs one to wonder what they have been analysing,” he said.
“When you check the year-on-year, it’s really an eight per cent (decrease), notwithstanding the emergency powers which were invoked.”
Gonzales said comparing 2024 and 2026, when different political parties were in office, risked introducing a political dimension to a national issue.
“What in fact they are doing is comparing when the PNM is in office to when the UNC is in office,” he said.
“When did we ever witness the TTPS presenting statistics on when one political party is in office as opposed to when another political party is in office? That is what is happening.”
Gonzales said he believed the comparison was undermining the integrity of the Police Service.
