Kejan Haynes
Lead Editor – Newsgathering
kejan.haynes@guardian.co.tt
The legal battle over the Government’s Maloney lockdown is escalating, with the State authorising three more British barristers to represent it in challenges to the Special Operations Act and the orders restricting movement in the community.
At the same time, Opposition Leader Pennelope Beckles-Robinson’s attorneys are preparing a constitutional challenge, arguing that the legislation cannot be used to override residents’ fundamental rights. They have also notified Commissioner of Police Allister Guevarro that they intend to add him as a defendant.
The three barristers—Sir James Eadie, KC, Robert Stephen Strang and Thomas David Henry Mountford—were authorised to practise in Trinidad and Tobago in notices published in Friday’s Gazette.
Eadie and Strang are authorised to represent the State in Beckles-Robinson’s proceedings against the Cabinet and Attorney General John Jeremie SC. The challenge concerns the Special Operations Act, the Special Operations (Closed Area) Order and the Special Operations (Curfew) Order, as well as the designation of the Maloney Buildings Housing Development and Policing District 2.
Mountford has been authorised to appear in Wendell Eversley’s constitutional case against the Attorney General. Jeremie confirmed that Mountford is part of the State’s legal team with British KC David Pannick. Eversley filed his challenge on November 16 and is represented by former prime minister and Opposition MP Stuart Young, SC.
Asked about the State’s decision to bring in additional British counsel, Young said: “I will advocate in the Courts for my client and the people of a Trinidad and Tobago as I have been retained to do.”
Jeremie said the State would defend claims brought against it.
“The State is not a party here to elective litigation. If a claim is filed against the State it will be defended,” he said.
He added: “I expect that these cases will ultimately land in London. I have chosen teams that I am comfortable with at the moment. Thank you for asking.”
The appointments come amid criticism of the Government’s spending on foreign legal representation. Pannick’s reported hourly rate is about £5,000, or approximately TT$44,650. The Gazette notices do not disclose the fees or rates for the newly authorised barristers.
The notices, signed by Jeremie and dated November 20, were made under Section 15A of the Legal Profession Act. The provision allows eligible Commonwealth citizens with at least ten years’ experience practising in England and Wales to be admitted for specified matters.
Maloney was declared a closed area on November 10, with a curfew from 9 pm to 5 am. The legislation gives police powers to conduct special crime-fighting operations in designated policing districts.
Beckles-Robinson’s attorneys argue that the Special Operations Act was passed by a simple majority and lacks the special provision required for legislation that limits constitutional rights. They say the Government must demonstrate that the restrictions are necessary and proportionate to the threat of crime, and that less restrictive measures would not have achieved the same objective.
Their proposed court action seeks to have five sections of the Act declared unconstitutional and the orders closing Maloney and imposing the curfew overturned.
In a letter dated Friday, Jeremie declined several assurances sought by the Opposition Leader, including greater transparency about movement permits and arrangements for residents who need to leave home for work, medical emergencies and other essential activities.
Jeremie said those operational decisions were for the Commissioner of Police and the Head of Special Operations. Cabinet and the Attorney General, he said, could not dictate how police carried out their duties. He said the Government was committed to respecting the Police Service’s independence.
In a further letter sent yesterday, Beckles-Robinson’s attorneys challenged the Government to produce the evidence behind the decision to impose the restrictions. They asked for information presented to Cabinet and Parliament, as well as details of other measures considered before the orders were made.
Jeremie has said the security services briefed the National Security Council and presented intelligence describing violent and dangerous lawlessness in Maloney. He said the information was sufficient to satisfy Cabinet and the President that the legal conditions for the orders had been met.
The attorneys have sent a separate pre-action letter to Guevarro and intend to add him as a third defendant in the proposed court action. They have asked Jeremie to confirm whether his office will represent the police chief.
They have given the Attorney General until 4 pm on Tuesday to provide a substantive response and requested confirmation that records relating to the operation—including permit applications, operational logs and body-camera footage—have been preserved.
