DEREK ACHONG
Senior Reporter
A man has suffered a second defeat in his malicious prosecution case over being charged with cursing and obstructing a police officer during Point Fortin Borough Day celebrations in 2014.
In a judgment delivered earlier this week, Appellate Judges Mark Mohammed, Ricky Rahim and Devindra Rampersad dismissed Carlus Findley's appeal against a decision by a judge to reject his case.
According to the evidence, on May 3, 2014, Findley was with his wife and relatives at the celebrations when he was arrested by a female police officer and charged with using obscene language in public and obstructing her.
Findley denied any wrongdoing and claimed that he was framed after he confronted another police officer for allegedly making obscene gestures towards his wife.
He claimed that he was choked by one officer and repeatedly hit with a baton by another before being arrested.
The charges were eventually dismissed by a magistrate after the charging officer failed to attend court. Findley subsequently filed a case for wrongful arrest, false imprisonment and malicious prosecution.
In determining the case, former High Court judge and current Appellate Judge Avason Quinlan-Williams took issue with the fact that Findley did not call his wife or relatives as witnesses to support his claim about the purported incident between his wife and a police officer.
She found that the charging officer had reasonable and probable cause to charge him and did not act with malice.
The appeal panel agreed with lawyers for the Office of the Attorney General, who argued that Justice Quinlan-Williams' decision in Findley's case could not be faulted.
The judges found that although the case was dismissed because of the charging officer's carelessness, she had reasonable grounds to arrest and charge him.
Findley was ordered to pay $9,666 in legal costs for the failed appeal.
The AG's Office was represented by Gayatri Dass, Rachel Jacob and Savitri Maharaj. Ted Roopnarine represented Findley.
