Senior Reporter
kay-marie.fletcher@guardian.co.tt
Opposition MP Stuart Young has slammed the Government after local attorneys representing the State in the controversial Hadeed detention case claimed more than $3 million in legal fees, describing the charges as “obscene and abusive” and questioning whether taxpayers should have to foot the bill.
The fees stem from a legal battle involving prominent businessman Dominic Hadeed and his wife Genevieve, who were arrested in June over their suspected involvement in an alleged plot to assassinate Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar and other senior Government officials.
The couple spent nearly a month in detention under emergency powers before being released without criminal charges, but their legal challenge resulted in proceedings in the High Court and Court of Appeal.
Now, a written parliamentary response from Attorney General John Jeremie has revealed that two attorneys retained to represent the State have submitted legal bills totalling $3,034,375, with additional fees for two British King’s Counsel yet to be disclosed.
In a written response to Young, Jeremie revealed that attorney Gerald Ramdeen claimed $984,375 for the High Court proceedings and $1.25 million for the Court of Appeal, bringing his total to $2,234,375.
Attorney Dayadai Harripaul claimed $450,000 for the High Court and $350,000 for the Court of Appeal, totalling $800,000.
The parliamentary response also identified Sir James Raymond Eadie and Richard John Thomas, both British King’s Counsel, as having been retained to advise or represent the State.
However, no figures were provided for their services.
In July, Jeremie told Guardian Media that no fees had been paid to the attorneys at that stage, but defended the cost of the State’s legal representation.
Jeremie also defended the expenditure as necessary to uphold the rule of law at the time.
In a Facebook post yesterday, Young questioned the justification for the expenditure, particularly since neither Ramdeen nor Harripaul holds the designation of Senior Counsel.
He also raised concerns about the amount of taxpayers’ money being committed to the State’s legal defence while the substantive challenge arising from the Hadeeds’ detention remained unresolved.
He also accused the Government of misusing the Treasury and warned that the legal bill could climb even higher once the fees for the two British King’s Counsel are included.
Young said, “Look at the amount of fees requisitioned by non-Senior Counsel for the High Court and Court of Appeal so far. Gerald Ramdeen: $984,375.00 for the High Court and $1,250,000.00 for the Court of Appeal. Dayadai Harripaul: $450,000 for the High Court and $350,000 for the Court of Appeal. This is Kamla’s Kakistocracy’s use of the Treasury. Ask yourself if this was an appropriate use of $3,034,375 of our tax-paying dollars? For one, a matter that has not even been determined the State has so far incurred $3,034,375.00 in lawyers’ fees, plus two King’s Counsel sets of fees to come!! No requisitioned fees were provided for the English KCs. That is the Kakistocracy at work. I consider it obscene and abusive. We will remember. Time longer than twine!!!”
Also speaking to Guardian Media on the issue, Young added, “I find the fees to be extremely high.”
Questioned about the cost of retaining the two British King’s Counsel, Young said the Attorney General had provided no information on their fees.
He also expressed doubt that the British attorneys would have provided their services without payment.
Asked whether he intended to pursue the matter further, Young replied, “I shall be following up on these matters and more.”
However, it remains unclear how much of the $3 million claimed by Ramdeen and Harripaul has actually been paid by the State.
Attempts to contact Jeremie on the issue remained unsuccessful up to press time.
Meanwhile, Harripaul yesterday hit back at Young, accusing him of “hypocrisy” and questioning his criticism of legal fees when, according to her, millions of dollars were paid to private attorneys under the former People’s National Movement (PNM) administration.
In a strongly worded response to Guardian Media yesterday, Harripaul said, “I find it quite hypocritical, shameless, disgusting and repulsive for Mr Young of all people to be taking issue with fees that I have charged for work done on behalf of the State. Under the Rowley and Young regime, in one matter conducted on behalf of the State, the National Gas Company was charged 47 million dollars by private attorneys.”
She identified several attorneys and law firms she said had received substantial payments.
According to Harripaul, Senior Counsel Deborah Peake was paid $13,177,873, while Jason Mootoo, who she said was not Senior Counsel at the time, received $8,207,854.16.
She also identified payments of approximately $2.76 million to Ravi Heffes-Doon, who she said was not Senior Counsel, and $12,092,259.17 to the law firm Pollonais, Blanc de la Bastide and Jacelon.
However, when asked to explain how her own $800,000 in fees was calculated, Harripaul said she would only disclose the basis for her invoices if other attorneys explained their charges and the PNM disclosed the source of funding for the Balisier House.
She said, “When these attorneys disclose the basis of the fees they have charged and the work undertaken to justify this level of invoicing and when the PNM discloses the source of the funding that financed the construction of the edifice that stands upon Nos. 1 & 3 Tranquility Street Port-of-Spain, I too will disclose the basis for my invoices.”
Harripaul has previously worked alongside Ramdeen on court matters, serving as his instructing attorney. She also faced allegations that she was removed from the team of a sitting judge in 2012 after allegedly photocopying sensitive court documents without authorisation.
Guardian Media also sought responses from Ramdeen, Hadeeds’ attorney Faris Al-Rawi and Homeland Security Minister Roger Alexander but received no response up to press time.
Hadeeds challenge detention
On June 24, police arrested Dominic and Genevieve Hadeed at their home during a State of Emergency.
The arrests formed part of an investigation into an alleged conspiracy to murder Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar and other senior Government officials.
The couple denied the allegations and were detained without criminal charges being laid.
Three days later, on June 27, Homeland Security Minister Roger Alexander issued Preventive Detention Orders (PDOs) against them under the Emergency Powers Regulations.
The orders allowed the couple to remain in custody without criminal charges on preventive grounds.
However, the Hadeeds challenged their detention in court, questioning the legal basis for the orders and alleging violations of their constitutional rights.
Their legal challenge resulted in proceedings in the High Court, where their initial applications for habeas corpus and interim relief were refused.
The couple subsequently appealed, and on July 16, the Court of Appeal ruled in their favour on interim relief, ordering that they be released from prison and placed under strict house arrest conditions while their substantive challenge continued.
However, the State secured a stay of that decision from another Court of Appeal panel, allowing the couple to remain in custody while an appeal was pursued before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.
On July 23, Alexander revoked the PDOs after considering recommendations from a review tribunal and other legal, medical and public interest considerations.
The Hadeeds were subsequently released after spending nearly a month in detention without being charged with any criminal offence.
