Derek Achong
Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
The widow of one of the victims of a diving tragedy at Paria Fuel Trading Company’s Pointe-a-Pierre facility in 2022 has been allowed to continue a workmen’s compensation claim while simultaneously pursuing a negligence lawsuit over his death.
Delivering a decision last week, Appellate Judges Charmaine Pemberton and Avason Quinlan-Williams upheld an appeal from Celisha Kurban over a decision by a High Court Master to stay the claim in relation to her deceased husband Fyzal.
In applying for the stay, the divers’ employer, Land and Marine Contracting Services Ltd (LMCS), through its lawyer Dinesh Rambally, suggested that it should not be allowed to proceed based on pending negligence lawsuits brought against it and Paria.
In March, Justice Wrenerson Lochan agreed that allowing both sets of litigation to continue in parallel would result in duplication, increase legal costs and time, and the possibility of inconsistent findings on central legal issues.
He suggested that the workmen’s compensation claims could be considered after the negligence lawsuits are determined, as the latter would help streamline the legal issues in the former.
The appeal panel disagreed with Master Lochan and found that the cases could be determined simultaneously.
The judges remitted the claim to Master Lochan for his consideration and ordered LMCS to pay $23,000 in legal costs to Kurban, who was represented by Prakash Ramadhar, Saira Lakhan and Devi Ramnarine.
The stay was sought by LMCS after Master Lochan rejected an application from Paria to extract itself from the Workmen’s Compensation Act claims.
The legislation provides for compensation to be paid to workers or their families if they die or are left permanently disabled during an incident while working. Claims are not dependent on the employer being found negligent in relation to the injury or on an employee being found to have contributed to their injury.
In cases where a dead workman leaves behind dependants who were wholly dependent on his earnings, the employer is required to pay a lump sum of 36 months’ earnings.
The judicial officers would assess an appropriate portion of the maximum amount if the dead workman does not have any dependants or if his/her dependants were not wholly dependent on him/her.
Workers who survive but are left totally or partially disabled can potentially receive a larger payout based on their dependants and the extent of their disability.
On February 25, 2022, Kurban, Yusuf Henry, Christopher Boodram, Rishi Nagassar and Kazim Ali Jr, whose father owns LMCS, were sucked into the 30-inch-diameter pipeline they were performing maintenance work at Paria’s facility.
All were seriously injured but Boodram managed to make his way to the entrance of the pipeline and was rescued.
LMCS officials were blocked from attempting to rescue their colleagues.
Three of the divers’ bodies were recovered on February 28, while Nagassar’s was recovered the following day.
Cabinet initially appointed a five-member team to investigate the incident but eventually appointed a Commission of Enquiry (CoE) due to public criticism.
In its report, the commission, chaired by King’s Counsel Jerome Lynch, presented several dozen recommendations including charges under the OSH Act.
Paria’s then-general manager Mushtaq Mohammed, its terminal operations manager Collin Piper, LMCS director Kazim Ali Snr, and the companies were slapped with a series of charges under the OSH Act.
A magistrate is still expected to consider the future of the charges as they were filed before the Privy Council determined a landmark case over the time limit for bringing such prosecutions.
Before Boodram and his deceased colleagues’ families filed their negligence claims, LMCS wrote to their lawyers suggesting that they should direct their legal action for negligence to Paria.
LMCS’s lawyers dismissed any imputation of culpability attached to it by the commission and claimed that Paria should be held solely liable for what transpired.
LMCS did admit that it owes the workers’ families and Boodram for workmen’s compensation but claimed that payments could not be made until its claim to its insurer is determined.
In early April last year, former prime minister Stuart Young announced that the Cabinet had decided to make a one-time ex-gratia payment of $1 million each to Boodram and his colleagues’ families without admitting liability.
He claimed that the delay in the settlement of the cases was due to insurers for LMCS and Paria disagreeing on which company was liable.
However, the payments were not made when there was a change of government later that month.
In January, the current government led by Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar made good on the promise as the ex-gratia payment was made to Boodram and his colleagues’ families.
Paria was represented by attorney Shiv Sharma.
