SHALIZA HASSANALI
Senior Investigative Reporter
shaliza.hassanali@guardian.co.tt
A family paid $4,500 to retrieve the body of a woman who died at the Eric Williams Medical Sciences Complex (EWMSC), after her daughter said funeral agency representatives warned that the hospital mortuary’s refrigeration was faulty and offered to store the body.
The agency disputes the family’s account. Health Minister Dr Lackram Bodeo said he would ask the regional health authorities to investigate the operations of funeral home touts outside hospitals.
Hyacinth Berrot, 68, died on November 12 from heart complications after being admitted to Ward 3 at the hospital. Her daughter, Marisa Samuel, said she returned to the EWMSC the following day to collect her mother’s belongings and was approached by representatives of a funeral agency operating outside the hospital.
Samuel said they told her the mortuary’s refrigeration was not working properly and warned that her mother’s body could be returned blackened and unrecognisable.
“I got scared. It really frightened me. I started to cry,” said Samuel, a mother of four.
The representatives offered to store Berrot’s body at their funeral home in Tunapuna for two weeks at no charge, Samuel said. She said she accepted the offer while the family considered what to do.
When Samuel returned to collect her mother’s death certificate on November 14, she said a funeral home worker again spoke with her and the body was taken to the agency that day.
Samuel later received a call saying she would have to pay $7,500 for two days of refrigeration. Believing the family was being exploited, she contacted her cousin, Daniel Wilson, owner of Siloh Funeral Services Ltd in Mayaro, for help.
Samuel said the agency offered to conduct the burial for $7,500 after the family objected to the charge.
When family members went to collect Berrot’s body on November 16, Samuel alleged, a worker told them it had already been embalmed.
“Nobody gave them the authority to do anything with mommy’s body,” Samuel said.
Wilson said the family asked for the body to be released and offered $1,500 to cover its removal from the hospital and two days of refrigeration. He said the agency refused.
Samuel said the family went to the Tunapuna Police Station and filed a report against the agency for withholding her mother’s body. She said police told them they could not intervene because it was a private matter. She showed the Sunday Guardian a receipt for the citizens’ report.
Wilson said he sought legal advice and was told he would need to apply for an injunction to have the body released. He said the process could have taken several days.
With time passing and the family wanting to proceed with the burial, Samuel said relatives went to another police station for help. On November 19, police visited the funeral agency to resolve the matter.
Wilson said the agency agreed to accept $4,500 to release the body. Family members remained reluctant to pay, he said, because they believed the sum was too high.
“I did not want this to drag on any longer, so I paid the money,” Wilson said.
The body was taken to Wilson’s funeral home for burial. A copy of the agency’s receipt shown to the Sunday Guardian indicated that the payment was made in cash.
“All we wanted was a decent and dignified burial,” Samuel said.
Wilson said he intended to take legal action. He accused the representatives of misleading Samuel about the hospital mortuary’s refrigeration to obtain the body and then promising free storage.
“That is falsifying information in order to obtain a body. Then you promised free refrigeration,” he said.
Wilson said funeral home touts should not be allowed to operate in hospitals, arguing that their presence added to the distress of grieving families.
“They need to be moved out completely,” he said.
“Why are they preying on grieving people? They cannot continue to do this,” Samuel said.
Samuel, 50, said she has several health complications. She said she contracted severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in 2021, which severely affected her lung function. She also has an enlarged heart, requires ongoing care at five clinics and takes medication daily.
Her father died four years ago. Samuel said her mother had been the family’s pillar and that the dispute over the body had compounded the family’s grief.
“Mommy was the pillar in the family. She did not deserve this. All we wanted was a decent and dignified burial.”
Agency disputes family’s account
On Thursday, the Sunday Guardian contacted a worker at the funeral agency who had spoken with Samuel and Wilson. The worker said the family’s concerns had been settled and disputed their account.
“The family knew that the misinformation came from one of the relatives, not from us. The information is not truthful. I think they know I will take legal action,” she said.
The worker described the matter as a family affair and said the family had come to the agency and “did the necessary”.
She said police had intervened and the matter had been cleared up. Asked whether $4,500 was a reasonable fee to transport Berrot’s body, she again said the newspaper should publish the correct information.
The worker said the body had been at the agency since Saturday and that she would rely on the courts and police to defend the agency.
Funeral association raises concerns
Keith Belgrove, president of the Association of Funeral Professionals of Trinidad and Tobago, said some funeral homes had been taking advantage of vulnerable families outside hospitals.
Belgrove alleged that the agency secured Berrot’s body by claiming the hospital mortuary’s refrigeration service was not working properly. He described that as a misrepresentation of the facts.
“That makes them heartless vultures. They are predators waiting to pounce,” he said.
Belgrove said the association would support Wilson in court and would testify if needed. He said it was not the first complaint the association had received about the agency.
He said touts operated freely at hospitals and were “loitering on the government’s compound”. Many, he added, were not registered with the association and lacked embalming accreditation.
“They prey on the sensitive emotions of the bereaved, putting families in further distress. Where are the RHAs and CEOs of these hospitals? Are they condoning this unethical behaviour?” he said.
Belgrove said he had repeatedly written to hospitals about the issue and urged them to post signs warning bereaved families about touts. He said he received complaints about funeral homes every day and described the practice as financial exploitation.
He also questioned the amount paid to transport Berrot’s body. Belgrove said such a transfer from Mount Hope to Tunapuna typically cost between $950 and $1,250, while most funeral homes charged between $250 and $300 a day to store a body.
Health Minister Dr Lackram Bodeo said he would ask the regional health authorities to look into the operations of touts outside hospitals.
Previous court case
In September 2023, High Court judge Avason Quinlan-Williams granted an injunction ordering Casket Emporium Funeral Home in Tobago to release the body of Odwin Thomas, who died on July 28 that year.
The case was brought by Thomas’s son, Handell, represented by attorney Martin George.
Thomas said he met funeral home owner Shirelle Clarke on August 3. Clarke allegedly told him he could finance his father’s funeral arrangements using an invoice prepared by the funeral home. Thomas signed an agreement to pay the fees when financing became available.
When he could not obtain financing, Thomas asked for his father’s body to be returned on August 9. He claimed Clarke demanded $16,000 before releasing it, including $6,000 for embalming and $10,000 for storage charged at $2,000 a day.
Thomas said he had not authorised the embalming and had not been told about the daily storage fee. He told the court that other funeral homes charged a standard storage fee of $250 a day.
After the body was not returned following a letter demanding its release, George applied for an injunction. The court ordered the funeral home to release the body to Thomas. Under the judgment, Thomas was required to pay $1,750, which had been tendered as a reasonable storage fee, rather than the funeral home’s $56,000 bill for storage and embalming.
