JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Thursday, May 22, 2025

What went so disastrously wrong, TKR?

by

Colin Murray
602 days ago
20230928

Con­grat­u­la­tions to the Guyana Ama­zon War­riors (GAW)—the 2023 Caribbean Pre­mier League (CPL) cham­pi­ons!

When I pre­viewed the CPL be­fore the sea­son start­ed, I must ad­mit that I did not have the GAW any­where in the pic­ture. My tip to win the ti­tle was an­oth­er team that has nev­er lift­ed the tro­phy, the St Lu­cia Kings (SLK). I had them in the fi­nal against the Trin­ba­go Knight Rid­ers (TKR).

As I ex­plained then, be­sides hav­ing an ex­cel­lent all-round team, the man at the helm of the SLK, Faf du Plessis, is an in­spi­ra­tional leader and a good mo­ti­va­tor. He lifts the team’s spir­it when he scores runs at the top of the or­der, and play­ers play for him. I knew the ti­tle went with him when he was gone, but the SLK still did well to get in­to the play­offs.

Hav­ing ex­plained my ra­tio­nale for the SLK, the GAW had their own “Faf” in Im­ran Tahir. Who­ev­er con­sid­ered giv­ing this man the cap­tain­cy can on­ly be de­scribed as a stroke of ab­solute bril­liance. He has been with the fran­chise for years, and now, at the ripe young age of 44, he was hand­ed the cap­tain­cy.

Just as when he bowls, there is a pas­sion in his lead­er­ship. He en­cour­ages, mo­ti­vates, ad­vis­es, em­pathis­es, dis­cuss­es, and, per­haps most im­por­tant­ly, be­lieves in his play­ers. He is a true leader; he is what cap­tain­cy is all about, and not on­ly his per­for­mance with the ball but his gen­uine care and at­ten­tion to the needs of his team­mates all played a mas­sive part in them win­ning the ti­tle.

Ad­min­is­tra­tors be­lieve in giv­ing the best play­er the cap­tain­cy be­cause they are wor­ried they might get up­set and not give their best. Still, a good crick­et cap­tain is worth their weight in gold, es­pe­cial­ly if they can mo­ti­vate their play­ers and have them play­ing be­yond their abil­i­ty, which is pre­cise­ly what Tahir was able to do; his body lan­guage and his emo­tions rubbed off on his team. From the first game, this team looked like a team with a mis­sion. We have seen GAW teams win games hand­some­ly in the past, but there was a dif­fer­ence here. Every­thing in their game seemed to have a pur­pose.

Their plan­ning was good, and their ex­e­cu­tion was even bet­ter right from their first full game when they man­han­dled the in­ept St Kitts and Nevis Pa­tri­ots (SKNP) and then whipped the Ja­maica Tallawahs (JT). They jour­neyed to the (Queen’s Park) Oval and com­fort­ably beat the TKR but the ic­ing on the cake was when they had to de­fend six runs in the last over against the Bar­ba­dos Roy­als (BR). Tahir gave the ball to Gu­dakesh Motie, and they won by three runs and cel­e­brat­ed the vic­to­ry as if they had won the ti­tle. You knew then that there was some­thing spe­cial about skip­per Tahir and the GAW.

Crick­et fans in the re­gion, ex­cept in Guyana, ex­pect­ed them to choke again and not go all the way, es­pe­cial­ly when they lost to the SLK by sev­en wick­ets. But it was a great wake-up call for them, and even though they lost the play­off to TKR, they would re­group and come again. That they cer­tain­ly did, and they caught a com­pla­cent TKR team to­tal­ly un­aware in ar­guably the most one-sided fi­nal since 2016 when the GAW were bun­dled out for 93 and lost to the JT by nine wick­ets, a very sim­i­lar re­sult to the 2023 fi­nal.

I have main­tained that TKR has al­ways been able to get the right play­ers to play for the fran­chise, but this year, the GAW got it right with one play­er, in par­tic­u­lar, 21-year-old left-hand­ed Pak­istan open­er Saim Ayub. He scored 478 runs at an av­er­age of 43.45, a strike rate of 142.26 with four half-cen­turies, a mod­el of true con­sis­ten­cy. Al­so wor­thy of men­tion was Shai Hope, who scored 481 runs at an av­er­age of 53.44, a strike rate of 140.23 with one cen­tu­ry and four half-cen­turies. The odd time they failed, the bat­ting was still propped up one time or an­oth­er by the likes of Shim­ron Het­my­er, Azam Khan, and Keemo Paul when he was fit.

The cham­pi­ons lacked an­oth­er con­sis­tent open­er at the top to give them a good start but the lev­el-head­ed Hope soon made a mock­ery of them not get­ting good open­ing starts and to­geth­er with Ayub, took the game away from their op­po­nents. Are the West In­dies se­lec­tors not look­ing at crick­et? Hope has to play in all for­mats of the game, and I would give him the cap­tain­cy of the Test team, but per­haps they don’t have the bel­ly to bite the bul­let and do what is right for West In­dies crick­et. In ad­di­tion to Hope, there are some ex­cit­ing prospects around West In­dies crick­et, but where do they go af­ter CPL?

The bowl­ing of the GAW was al­so good. As the say­ing goes, bowlers win match­es, and they did pre­cise­ly this in the fi­nal. Dwaine Pre­to­rius sur­prised me. He bowled far bet­ter than I thought he would have. He bowled sen­si­bly and scalped 20 wick­ets, fol­lowed by the best bowler in the tour­na­ment, Tahir, with 18, and Motie, with 15 wick­ets, who im­pressed me from the first time I saw him at the in­ter­na­tion­al lev­el; he is im­prov­ing all the time. Ro­mario Shep­herd bowled well at times and got 12 wick­ets, but he still has to be a lot more con­sis­tent and can learn a thing or two in terms of his vari­a­tion from Pre­to­rius. Ad­di­tion­al­ly, the GAW field­ing was ex­cep­tion­al; they looked fit and up to the task. Their back­room staff, led by Lance Klusen­er, de­serves all the cred­it.

So, what went wrong with TKR? I did say crick­et is a game of glo­ri­ous un­cer­tain­ties, and TKR proved just that. They bat­ted atro­cious­ly. It is prob­a­bly the worst bat­ting per­for­mance ever by a TKR team in the his­to­ry of the CPL. Out­side of Chad­wick Wal­ton, who was dis­missed with one that kept low, and Kea­cy Car­ty, every oth­er bats­man from 1-9 looked like they just felt they had to turn up, and the GAW would be in awe at their pres­ence. I have heard some of the most ridicu­lous the­o­ries on so­cial me­dia about why they lost. My dear read­ers, please re­frain from that. It was one of those nights when the TKR bats­men didn’t fire, and the GAW was pumped up. I al­so loved that many fans were hop­ing that (Sunil) Nar­ine and com­pa­ny could have pro­duced mag­ic on the night and dis­missed the GAW for less than 94 runs. In­deed, wish­ful think­ing, but Ayub and Hope had dif­fer­ent thoughts.

TKR still fin­ished sec­ond, and the fans should be proud. It sim­ply means they have some work to do, and come 2024, they have to plan bet­ter to take the ti­tle. I wish for the 2024 CPL to see more qual­i­ty over­seas play­ers in the re­spec­tive fran­chis­es, as that is lack­ing with­out call­ing names. Check through the teams and see how many are names that can turn a fran­chise in­to a win­ning unit. Un­for­tu­nate­ly, not many! Good­bye, CPL 2023. Thanks for the mem­o­ries!

Ed­i­tor’s note: The views ex­pressed in the pre­ced­ing ar­ti­cle are sole­ly those of the au­thor and do not re­flect the views of any or­gan­i­sa­tion of which he is a stake­hold­er.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored