JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Thursday, May 15, 2025

Offer community, not a bullet

by

Ira Mathur
739 days ago
20230507
IRA MATHUR

IRA MATHUR

We were sit­ting in the stu­dio of Free­dom 106.5—jour­nal­ists and ed­i­tors Soyi­ni Grey and me, for a call-in pro­gramme on World Press Free­dom Day ably host­ed by Satesh Ma­habir, who I had worked with in the ear­ly days in tele­vi­sion (now a dy­nam­ic ra­dio chat show host) jug­gling us with Zoom par­tic­i­pants—me­dia pow­er­hous­es in­clud­ing Kay­mar Jor­dan (Man­ag­ing Ed­i­tor, GML), Irv­ing Ward, Suzanne Shep­pard (ed­i­tors/vet­er­an jour­nal­ists) and Jo­van John­son of the Ja­maica Glean­er. There were five of us.

I sud­den­ly thought of some­thing I had read—we are the sum of the av­er­age of the five peo­ple you spend the most time with. I hadn’t spent time with any of these col­leagues, but they felt like home. They were like the peo­ple I spend time with. It was May 3. World Press Free­dom Day.

We were ex­plor­ing chal­lenges fac­ing jour­nal­ists, each com­ing at it from mul­ti­ple view­points, in­clud­ing the cor­ro­sive ef­fects of so­cial me­dia on jour­nal­ism, lengthy ex­pla­na­tions as to why we must cov­er “bad” news (As the Fourth Es­tate, we stand as watch­dogs over all in­sti­tu­tions) the fact that jour­nal­ists are con­stant­ly ac­cused of bias by peo­ple whose agen­da the news doesn’t serve, the fact that jour­nal­ism is a vo­ca­tion, so of­ten jour­nal­ists die young, and on the job, work for rel­a­tive­ly low pay, for long and odd hours to meet dead­lines.

We spoke about the mur­der of our col­leagues in Haiti, Mex­i­co and Ukraine, and the con­stant vig­i­lance and fight for in­for­ma­tion from gov­ern­ment quar­ters.

We heard two news­casts while I was in the build­ing read by Satesh, and with each hour, the num­ber of mur­ders went up from two to five to two wound­ed men.

Now we heard it from both hats on—as jour­nal­ists in­ter­est­ed in the news AND cit­i­zens won­der­ing where this would stop. At that point, Soyi­ni Grey said some­thing that re­al­ly struck me. Jour­nal­ists need com­mu­ni­ty with one an­oth­er and be close to the peo­ple whose lives we cov­er.

That not on­ly made good sense (thank­ful­ly, the me­dia fra­ter­ni­ty is stronger, stretch­es from rook­ies to vet­er­ans and is more unit­ed than ever), but I re­alised lat­er it would help us live longer. Stick a pin there.

Lat­er that day, I was ac­cost­ed by a mem­ber of the pub­lic (we are like hair­dressers and doc­tors—peo­ple tell us every­thing) who loud­ly went on about how im­por­tant it was to own guns (some­thing, wor­ry­ing­ly, cer­tain politi­cians are call­ing for).

I re­alised with a start that once that hap­pened, our jour­nal­ists would be on the front­line—cov­er­ing more and more crime, with more guns about.

So let me just say what I told that loud man who want­ed a gun against the ban­dits based on my re­search.

Ac­cord­ing to the mag­a­zine, The Sci­en­tif­ic Amer­i­can, some 30 stud­ies show that more guns are linked to more crimes, in­clud­ing mur­ders and rapes. There is lit­tle re­search to show guns help pro­tect peo­ple.

The claim that gun own­er­ship stops crime is com­mon (in the US—and a grow­ing be­lief in Trinidad) and dri­ves laws that make it easy to own and keep firearms.

David Hemen­way, di­rec­tor of the Har­vard In­jury Con­trol Re­search Cen­ter: Even if keep­ing a gun at home can put your fam­i­ly more at risk.

“It may mean you take chances you shouldn’t oth­er­wise take, go to places where it’s not safe, but you feel safe.”

Where there are more guns, more op­por­tu­ni­ties ex­ist for peo­ple to steal them and use them ne­far­i­ous­ly.

Now I like to join up the dots. Ul­ti­mate­ly, all hu­man be­hav­iour is a de­sire to live long and sat­is­fy hu­man in­stincts and de­sires for love, pow­er, and com­mu­ni­ty. Young men get all three things in a gang, plus the prospect of in­famy. (If not fame)

What if, in­stead of hand­ing peo­ple guns, we hand them sports, art, or busi­ness, or sim­ply hands they could hold?

I have this fan­ta­sy of gov­ern­ment min­is­ters led by the prime min­is­ter and the po­lice force and com­mu­ni­ty work­ers walk­ing to­geth­er in­to the ar­eas where fam­i­lies feel iso­lat­ed, for­got­ten, with­out pur­pose, where peo­ple die young, shoot and are shot at.

I thought of that stu­dio again. Of how every­thing is con­nect­ed.

How jour­nal­ists and crim­i­nals, chil­dren, pen­sion­ers, the home­less, house­wives, busi­ness­peo­ple, politi­cians and judges are al­so cit­i­zens.

How we all face stress­es in our pro­fes­sions and com­mu­ni­ty, how right now we all feel un­der threat and how with the right kind of love, we might just heal by com­ing clos­er to­geth­er in safe spaces, by of­fer­ing a leg up, a help­ing hand in­stead of shut­ting up our doors.

Colum­nist Ira Math­ur is the pres­i­dent of MATT and the au­thor of an award-win­ning mem­oir, Love The Dark Days.

columnist


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored