JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Saturday, May 17, 2025

Will MHIL shares be part of NIF2?

by

744 days ago
20230504

In re­spond­ing to a mo­tion on the ad­journ­ment in the Sen­ate on Tues­day, Min­is­ter in the Min­istry of Fi­nance, Bri­an Man­ning, said the Gov­ern­ment is plan­ning to in­tro­duce a Se­ries D of bonds is­sued by the Na­tion­al In­vest­ment Fund Hold­ing Com­pa­ny (NIF), which would be con­sid­ered NIF2.

Mr Man­ning re­mind­ed the Sen­ate that the first tranche (Se­ries A) of the NIF bonds is due to ma­ture on Au­gust 9, 2023, and that the Min­istry of Fi­nance is cur­rent­ly fo­cussed on en­sur­ing that suf­fi­cient funds are avail­able to pay the hold­ers of first tranche $1.2 bil­lion. NIF was is­sued in three tranch­es in Au­gust 2018.

"Af­ter this, NIF will launch a Se­ries D bond, us­ing ap­pro­pri­ate State as­sets, which can be con­sid­ered to be a NIF2 is­sue. The terms of the Se­ries D NIF bonds will be sim­i­lar to the orig­i­nal NIF bonds, ap­pro­pri­ate­ly ad­just­ed for cur­rent mar­ket con­di­tions."

Read­ers should take care­ful note of the fact that Mr Man­ning said NIF2 will be launched af­ter Au­gust 9, "us­ing ap­pro­pri­ate State as­sets."

The is­sue that Mr Man­ning did not an­swer was whether NIF2 would in­clude Cli­co's shares in Methanol Hold­ings In­ter­na­tion­al Ltd (MHIL), a hold­ing com­pa­ny for the Oman-based methanol pro­duc­er that the in­sur­ance com­pa­ny owns in part­ner­ship with Switzer­land-based petro­chem­i­cal gi­ant, Pro­man.

NIF was in the news last week Tues­day as a re­sult of re­sponse giv­en by Mr Man­ning to an­oth­er mo­tion on the ad­journ­ment by Sen­a­tor Mark.

At that sit­ting last week, Mr Man­ning dis­closed that on Feb­ru­ary 21, 2023, NIF ac­cept­ed an of­fer from Cli­co to ac­quire 17 per cent of its shares in MHIL.

He al­so dis­closed that on Jan­u­ary 9, 2023, Gov­ern­ment ac­cept­ed an of­fer from Cli­co to ac­quire 19.63 per cent of its MHIL shares "as part of the re­duc­tion of the debt owed to the Gov­ern­ment of the Re­pub­lic of Trinidad and To­ba­go (GORTT)."

Mr Man­ning re­vealed, as well, that Cli­co was look­ing to dis­pose of 36.63 per cent of its shares in MHIL to con­form with the 2018 In­sur­ance Act, which stip­u­lates that in­sur­ance com­pa­nies in T&T should not hold more than 20 per cent of any en­ti­ty. Cli­co's in­ten­tion, there­fore, is to sell 36.63 per cent of its shares in MHIL and re­tain 19.90 per cent of the methanol pro­duc­er.

In his pre­sen­ta­tion to the Sen­ate on April 25, 2023, the Min­is­ter in the Min­istry of Fi­nance, al­so dis­closed that Cli­co had en­tered in­to a joint share val­u­a­tion agree­ment on No­vem­ber 1, 2021, with a com­pa­ny called Con­sol­i­dat­ed En­er­gy Ltd (CEL), which is the in­vest­ment hold­ing ve­hi­cle for the shares held by Pro­man in MHIL.

The pur­pose of the joint share val­u­a­tion agree­ment was to con­duct an in­de­pen­dent val­u­a­tion of the MHIL shares, joint­ly owned by Cli­co and Pro­man.

"It was agreed that Cli­co's of­fer for sale of MHIL shares will be a max­i­mum of 36.63 per cent and a min­i­mum of 16 per cent and that any of­fered shares not tak­en up by CEL would be of­fered to GORTT for debt re­duc­tion and any re­main­ing shares there­after would be of­fered to a non-com­pet­i­tive third par­ty," said Mr Man­ning.

He added that Cli­co of­fered its 36.63 per cent block of MHIL shares to CEL by let­ter dat­ed No­vem­ber 2, 2022, in ac­cor­dance with the joint share-val­u­a­tion agree­ment and the in­de­pen­dent val­u­a­tion re­port.

"CEL re­spond­ed to Cli­co's of­fer with coun­terof­fers as to quan­ti­ties, price and con­di­tions that were all out­side of the share-val­u­a­tion agree­ment and the of­fer made to them. Hence, CEL's re­sponse was deemed by Cli­co to be a re­jec­tion of its of­fer," and Cli­co then pro­ceed­ed to of­fer the shares to the Gov­ern­ment and NIF as per the joint share val­u­a­tion agree­ment.

Mr Man­ning al­so said: "To date, Cli­co has signed share-ac­qui­si­tion agree­ments and share trans­fer forms with the Gov­ern­ment of the Re­pub­lic of Trinidad and To­ba­go and NIF, but the share reg­is­ter of MHIL has not yet been amend­ed to re­flect the trans­fers."

Claire Gomez-Miller, the ex­ec­u­tive chair of Cli­co, said the fol­low­ing in re­sponse to ques­tions from me last Thurs­day:

"All GORTT and NIF agree­ments and doc­u­ments have been signed and sent to MHIL for ex­e­cu­tion.

"The trans­ac­tion can on­ly be com­plet­ed when the MHIL share reg­is­ter shows the ti­tle has been legal­ly changed from Cli­co to GORTT and NIF.

"NIF can­not recog­nise the ac­qui­si­tion in their fi­nan­cials un­til they have ti­tle to the shares."

Ms Gomez-Miller state­ment in­di­cates that the trans­fer of the shares to the Gov­ern­ment and NIF has NOT been com­plet­ed and will on­ly be com­plet­ed when the MHIL share reg­is­ter shows the ti­tle has been legal­ly changed from Cli­co to GORTT and NIF

Sev­er­al is­sues arise from the dis­clo­sure of the facts, so far, on the is­sue of NIF and NIF2 by Bri­an Man­ning and Claire Gomez-Miller:

1) What is the rea­son the MHIL share reg­is­ter was not amend­ed, as at April 25, 2023, even though Cli­co had signed the share-ac­qui­si­tion agree­ments and share trans­fer forms for the Gov­ern­ment and NIF in Jan­u­ary and Feb­ru­ary 2023?

My own sus­pi­cion–for the two-month de­lay in amend­ing the MHIL share reg­is­ter to re­flect the trans­fer of shares to the Gov­ern­ment and NIF–is that there is a dis­pute be­tween Cli­co and Pro­man in­volv­ing lawyers and the in­ter­pre­ta­tion of the joint share-ac­qui­si­tion agree­ment.

From what I can de­duce from Mr Man­ning's April 25 re­sponse, the dis­pute could sur­round the fol­low­ing is­sues:

* Were CEL's coun­terof­fers as to quan­ti­ties, price and con­di­tions part of the ne­go­ti­at­ing process or did the coun­terof­fers fall "out­side of the joint share-val­u­a­tion agree­ment and the of­fer made to them," as Mr Man­ning stat­ed?

In oth­er words, does a coun­terof­fer, in and of it­self, rep­re­sent a re­jec­tion of the orig­i­nal of­fer?

* Is the NIF a true third par­ty of the Gov­ern­ment?

It is use­ful to note that NIF is 100 per cent owned by the Gov­ern­ment, its of­fice is in the Min­istry of Fi­nance build­ing on In­de­pen­dence Square and all five of its di­rec­tors are em­ploy­ees of the Min­istry of Fi­nance: Jen­nifer Lutch­man is the deputy per­ma­nent sec­re­tary; Nadi­ra Ly­der is the co­or­di­na­tor of PPPs; Dex­ter Jag­ger­nauth is pro­gramme man­ag­er at the Strate­gic Man­age­ment and Ex­e­cu­tion Of­fice; Hay­den Man­zano is ex­ec­u­tive di­rec­tor of the In­vest­ments Di­vi­sion and Cindy Pierre is state coun­sel II in the Of­fice of the Trea­sury So­lic­i­tor.

2) If the joint share-val­u­a­tion agree­ment stat­ed that any shares of­fered to, but not tak­en up by, CEL, would be of­fered to the Gov­ern­ment for debt re­duc­tion, why didn't the Gov­ern­ment alone ac­cept the of­fer from Cli­co, there­by elim­i­nat­ing the in­sur­ance com­pa­ny's debt to it, and then dis­trib­ute shares to NIF af­ter­wards?

I want to end by say­ing that I agree 1000 per cent with a state­ment made by Min­is­ter of Fi­nance, Colm Im­bert in the 2020 bud­get that "NIF is a sig­na­ture achieve­ment of this PNM Gov­ern­ment, giv­ing back to tax­pay­ers, as we promised, sig­nif­i­cant re­turns on pub­lic funds used in the bailout of Cli­co."

NIF is al­so clear­ly a per­son­al sig­na­ture achieve­ment of Mr Im­bert, as it has deep­ened and widened the in­vestor base of T&T. NIF has al­so pro­vid­ed in­di­vid­u­als and com­pa­nies with tax-free in­vest­ments that have paid, and will con­tin­ue to pay, hand­some re­turns.

It would be a tragedy if the Gov­ern­ment's im­ple­men­ta­tion of NIF2 were de­layed at this time as a re­sult of the in­ter­pre­ta­tion of an agree­ment.

For the good of all the po­ten­tial in­vestors in NIF2, may I be so bold as to call for the two sides to find the cen­tre on this is­sue.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored