JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Monday, July 7, 2025

T&T’s constitutional arrangements blocking progress

by

Dr Vanus James
17 days ago
20250619
Economist Dr Vanus James

Economist Dr Vanus James

Vanus James

Let us be clear. The coun­try has en­tered Kam­la II’s reign in 2025 with a bad eco­nom­ic and po­lit­i­cal hand – a los­ing hand based on the his­tor­i­cal record.

The con­sti­tu­tion ul­ti­mate­ly says that the prime min­is­ter is re­spon­si­ble to play the hand, but so far, no prime min­is­ter has suc­ceed­ed. It is al­so worth not­ing that no To­ba­go House As­sem­bly (THA) chair­man or chief sec­re­tary has de­liv­ered suc­cess in To­ba­go ei­ther.

What­ev­er the ob­fus­ca­tions of the con­sti­tu­tion or the THA Act, it is in fact the col­lec­tive re­spon­si­bil­i­ty of cit­i­zens to work out why we are fail­ing and the way for­ward. So, let us take a shot.

First, the in­her­i­tance. T&T is still run­ning what Best called an al­most pure plan­ta­tion econ­o­my, fea­tur­ing ex­ces­sive de­pen­dence on a high­ly cap­i­talised oil and gas in­dus­try that is op­er­at­ed by in­ter­na­tion­al cor­po­ra­tions. It pro­duces and ex­ports a pri­ma­ry or in­ter­me­di­ate prod­uct that main­ly ser­vices in­ter­na­tion­al in­ter­me­di­ate con­sump­tion. Every Mon­day morn­ing, it is buf­fet­ed by ei­ther sharp price in­creas­es that cre­ate a “gold­en age” ac­com­pa­nied by a false sense of suc­cess or a col­lapse of prices that pro­duce “gall and worm­wood,” an­oth­er term Best used to de­scribe se­ri­ous so­cial and eco­nom­ic trou­ble.

Even the Her­itage and Sta­bil­i­sa­tion Fund fund­ed by oil sur­plus­es in good times is not suf­fi­cient in­sur­ance against that kind and scale of tur­moil.

The his­tor­i­cal record is full of sim­i­lar eco­nom­ic and so­cial gy­ra­tions and dis­rup­tions caused by de­pen­dence on sug­ar, co­coa and co­conut, to name a few plan­ta­tion in­dus­tries.

Sec­ond, in the rest of the econ­o­my there are still large pools of un­der­e­d­u­cat­ed and, more gen­er­al­ly, un­der­cap­i­talised work­ers in ac­tiv­i­ties such as agri­cul­ture, re­tail, and “make work” gov­ern­ment pro­grammes, like CEPEP, URP and oth­ers.

Over­all, about 60 per cent of the coun­try’s labour force is un­der­e­d­u­cat­ed and un­der­cap­i­talised. In To­ba­go, that un­der­e­d­u­ca­tion rate is clos­er to 68 per cent and most are un­der­em­ployed by the Gov­ern­ment sec­tor. In all these ac­tiv­i­ties labour ef­fi­cien­cy, when prop­er­ly mea­sured, is very low.

Our most fa­mous Pro­fes­sor of Eco­nom­ics, Arthur Lewis, de­scribed that in­ef­fi­cien­cy as a “mar­gin­al prod­uct of labour that is near ze­ro and some­times even neg­a­tive”.

These con­di­tions make eco­nom­ic trans­for­ma­tion away from oil and gas both nec­es­sary and dif­fi­cult, but they al­so point the way for­ward.

Two ba­sic prin­ci­ples

Now, there are three ba­sic prin­ci­ples of eco­nom­ic trans­for­ma­tion and de­vel­op­ment that emerge from the life’s work of the two es­teemed pro­fes­sors re­ferred to above.

The first ba­sic prin­ci­ple is that we must find a way to grow ac­tiv­i­ties that pro­duce cap­i­tal – out­put used to pro­duce out­put - faster than the ac­tiv­i­ties that pro­duce con­sumer sup­plies.

And, we must grow labour pro­duc­tiv­i­ty in the con­sumer sup­ply ac­tiv­i­ties while re­struc­tur­ing.

For easy ref­er­ence, cap­i­tal-pro­duc­ing ac­tiv­i­ties re­fer here to those that pro­duce ed­u­ca­tion, health­care, fi­nan­cial ser­vices, cre­ative out­put (like the Car­ni­val in­dus­tries), hous­ing stock, phys­i­cal and dig­i­tal in­fra­struc­ture and the like.

The sec­ond ba­sic prin­ci­ple is that we must in­creas­ing­ly ra­tio­nalise our in­ter­na­tion­al trade to­wards in­creas­ing ex­ploita­tion of the coun­try’s struc­ture of com­par­a­tive ad­van­tage. Struc­ture, be­cause ul­ti­mate­ly, what is at is­sue is the abil­i­ty of the coun­try to un­der­take many ac­tiv­i­ties and so pro­duce types of out­put much more ef­fi­cient­ly than oth­ers.

In par­tic­u­lar, leav­ing aside oil and gas as in­her­i­tance, we can pro­duce the cap­i­tal ser­vices men­tioned above much more ef­fi­cient­ly than the con­sumer sup­plies, so we must shift our trade in­creas­ing to­wards those.

In fact, there is an or­der­ing of ef­fi­cien­cy of the prod­ucts which is in­formed by the in­ten­si­ty of use of high lev­els of knowl­edge, skills, and self-con­fi­dence used to pro­duce them, the high rate at which val­ue is added, and the reg­u­lar­i­ty of in­no­va­tion and cre­ativ­i­ty dur­ing pro­duc­tion.

The or­der­ing runs from ter­tiary ed­u­ca­tion, health­care and fi­nan­cial ser­vices, through the cre­ative in­dus­tries to the ser­vices of as­so­ci­at­ed plant and ac­com­mo­da­tion fa­cil­i­ties, on to tourism which pro­vides a plat­form for ex­port­ing the oth­er ser­vices. At the low end of the or­der­ing are man­u­fac­tured con­sumer sup­plies.

The or­der­ing is re­in­forced by the fact that as lo­cal and glob­al in­comes grow, an in­creas­ing share of it is spent on the high­ly ranked prod­ucts. In­no­va­tion and cre­ativ­i­ty cause some in­dus­tries to jump the queue; in our case, the cre­ative in­dus­tries would up­set the or­der, jump­ing the line from time to time.

In prac­tice, we have cor­nered our­selves near to or at the bot­tom of this list but there is room at the top. And, from the avail­able ev­i­dence, there are coun­tries right here in the Caribbean that are suc­cess­ful­ly ex­ploit­ing that room.

St Kitts/Nevis is mov­ing in­creas­ing­ly in­to the pro­duc­tion and ex­port of ter­tiary ed­u­ca­tion to com­ple­ment their beach tourism in­dus­try. The Ba­hamas has been mov­ing in­to fi­nan­cial ser­vices to un­der­write their long-stary tourism prod­uct. Both Cay­man and Bermu­da have found a way to pen­e­trate the glob­al fi­nan­cial ser­vices in­dus­try and op­er­ate as lead­ers in it, al­beit with British cov­er. All four cas­es are achiev­ing growth with de­vel­op­ment and with­out the in­sta­bil­i­ty ex­pe­ri­enced by T&T which can on­ly grow with­out de­vel­op­ment. If we fol­low their lead, the econ­o­my could be put on a path to growth with de­vel­op­ment in un­der 50 years.

Lewis point­ed out that cap­i­tal pro­duc­tion by Caribbean coun­tries makes com­mon­sense as well as eco­nom­ic sense. It is not wise for a peo­ple to spend scarce for­eign ex­change on im­port­ing stuff it can pro­duce ef­fi­cient­ly, even if with in­ter­na­tion­al help, and it makes sense to ex­port some of what is pro­duced as a source of for­eign ex­change.

A key clue here is that the gains from re­struc­tur­ing out­put and trade are ris­ing wages and ris­ing prof­its and prof­it rates. Ris­ing prof­its and prof­it rates can at­tract in­ter­na­tion­al prof­it-seek­ing risk-fi­nance and for­eign di­rect in­vest­ment, so we need not think of do­ing this alone. It is pos­si­ble to at­tract in­ter­na­tion­al col­lab­o­ra­tion to un­der­take the trans­for­ma­tion. What is more, a care­ful look at the his­tor­i­cal record will re­veal that no coun­try has made the trans­for­ma­tion with­out in­ter­na­tion­al col­lab­o­ra­tion main­ly achieved through cap­i­tal and skill in­flows; not Ba­hamas, or Cay­man, or Chi­na, not Japan, to cite just a few. Even so, we must be clever when go­ing about all this.

By and large, this is the agen­da of eco­nom­ic trans­for­ma­tion that must be un­der­stood and em­braced by Trinidad, by To­ba­go, and by Trinidad and To­ba­go, and es­pe­cial­ly by the new gov­ern­ment of Kam­la II.

The crit­i­cal third prin­ci­ple

Fail­ure to un­der­stand these is­sues has pro­duced ex­ces­sive de­pen­dence on oil and gas (be­fore that sug­ar), and sys­tem­at­ic fail­ure to pur­sue a rel­e­vant de­vel­op­ment agen­da over sev­en decades. That fail­ure rests on un­der-ap­pre­ci­a­tion of the crit­i­cal sig­nif­i­cance of the third prin­ci­ple of trans­for­ma­tion­al growth ar­tic­u­lat­ed in dif­fer­ent ways by both Lewis and Best – the need for sound and well-in­formed fa­cil­i­tat­ing pub­lic poli­cies.

When run­ning an un­der­cap­i­talised econ­o­my, mar­kets can­not be left alone to pro­duce the re­struc­tur­ing of out­put and trade need­ed to solve ex­ist­ing prob­lems. There are too many bar­ri­ers and bot­tle­necks to al­low the mar­kets to do the job of mov­ing re­sources around, all root­ed in cap­i­tal sup­ply short­ages.

For ex­am­ple, a straight­for­ward mat­ter like the lack of avail­abil­i­ty of cred­it at suit­ably low cost could block the ini­tia­tives of en­tre­pre­neurs in the cre­ative in­dus­tries. The same ap­plies to phys­i­cal and dig­i­tal in­fra­struc­ture.

Sound poli­cies and in­ter­ven­tions of ac­tive gov­ern­ment are need­ed to mo­ti­vate and fa­cil­i­tate the move­ment of lo­cal and in­ter­na­tion­al cap­i­tal with knowl­edge­able and skilled work­ers in­to the right in­dus­tries.

Ac­tive gov­ern­ment it­self may al­so have to be en­tre­pre­neur­ial, even if that is un­like­ly to be suc­cess­ful at the lev­el of the Cab­i­net in Trinidad or the Ex­ec­u­tive Coun­cil in To­ba­go. More like­ly, com­mu­ni­ties will have to be lib­er­at­ed and em­pow­ered.

Sound poli­cies re­quire an ad­e­quate flow of da­ta, in­for­ma­tion and knowl­edge to de­ci­sion­mak­ers and law­mak­ers along­side rapid learn­ing on the job.

Da­ta, in­for­ma­tion, knowl­edge and fast learn­ing are like the fu­els on which an econ­o­my and so­ci­ety runs.

So, a huge prob­lem con­fronting the coun­try is that the cur­rent con­sti­tu­tion­al arrange­ments in Trinidad and in To­ba­go amount to sys­tem­at­ic bar­ri­ers to the nec­es­sary flows.

T&T has his­tor­i­cal­ly run a con­sti­tu­tion­al­ly man­dat­ed ex­ec­u­tive Gov­ern­ment. Cab­i­net has run the coun­try un­der var­i­ous in­car­na­tions of the cur­rent Sec­tion 75(1) with no arrange­ments for leg­isla­tive over­sight and thus in­ad­e­quate arrange­ments for rou­tine and sys­tem­at­ic da­ta, in­for­ma­tion and knowl­edge shar­ing and com­mu­ni­ca­tion. The pub­lic ser­vice is a use­ful but very in­ad­e­quate de­vice for this pur­pose.

Sec­tion 34 of the THA Act #40, 1996, pro­vides sim­i­lar­ly for au­thor­i­tar­i­an Ex­ec­u­tive Coun­cil rule in To­ba­go.

The re­sult of this de­sign was cor­rect­ly char­ac­ter­ized by Gyp­sy dur­ing the reign of ANR: “Cap­tain you tell we what to do” even if you do not re­al­ly know the state of the ship and that it is sink­ing.

Over the past 69 years, these arrange­ments have pro­duced a se­quence of gov­ern­ments that have all failed and have all left of­fice un­der cri­sis and cloudy con­di­tions – all have failed to ad­dress ei­ther the con­sti­tu­tion­al or eco­nom­ic im­per­a­tives of the coun­try’s de­vel­op­ment.

The ev­i­dence is there for all to see. The dark clouds of en­er­gy price col­lapse and re­lat­ed bud­get crises have re­curred in 5 or 10 year cy­cles, de­pend­ing on how you count. The his­to­ry of To­ba­go is broad­ly sim­i­lar, with sim­i­lar caus­es and a track record of chron­ic de­pen­dence on Trinidad.

A word to the wise

This his­tor­i­cal record is a warn­ing to KPB and the coun­try that she has again in­her­it­ed “a los­ing hand,” as pok­er play­ers would say. She has in­her­it­ed con­di­tions that are eeri­ly sim­i­lar to those in­her­it­ed by ANR in 1986.

Mid-term bud­getary re­views are on us, and the specter of au­thor­i­tar­i­an re­spon­si­bil­i­ty looms large for KPB. She can­not fold and she can­not win un­less she buys new cards.

Her on­ly path to suc­cess is to learn from the past and move im­me­di­ate­ly to ini­ti­ate ac­tion to ad­dress both sources of re­peat­ed fail­ure:

(i) leg­isla­tive­ly man­dat­ed arrange­ments for ef­fec­tive da­ta, in­for­ma­tion and knowl­edge shar­ing and com­mu­ni­ca­tion with all stake­hold­ers; and

(ii) leg­isla­tive­ly man­dat­ed ini­tia­tives to push to­wards eco­nom­ic re­struc­tur­ing and trade in ac­cor­dance with the struc­ture of com­par­a­tive ad­van­tage.

It is on­ly in that con­text that the coun­try can work out sen­si­ble and po­lit­i­cal­ly fea­si­ble risks and ap­proach­es to mid-term bud­get­ing and the up­com­ing 2026 bud­get. On­ly in that con­text can the so­ci­ety dis­ci­pline stake­hold­er in­stincts to pur­sue self-in­ter­est and want more with­out re­gard to af­ford­abil­i­ty. That path is very nar­row and mined with an au­thor­i­tar­i­an cul­ture, so walk­ing it re­quires ap­pro­pri­ate pol­i­tics on the part of KPB and the stake­hold­ers of the coun­try.

We know what is to be done but whether we can grap­ple with the chal­lenges of au­thor­i­tar­i­an­ism while try­ing to do it is quite an­oth­er mat­ter that re­quires clever de­vices of na­tion­al dis­course and give and take.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored

Today's
Guardian

Publications

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

Jaggasar returns as National Parang president

8 hours ago
Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Jamaican Maroons celebrate, question land rights

8 hours ago
Sherron Harford

Sherron Harford

Sherron Harford

Sherron Harford

Sherron Harford’s holistic mission

to transform the lives of girls

Yesterday
Despite finding out just three days earlier—on December 23—that I had breast cancer, I still got dressed and showed up on December 26, Boxing Day, for a birthday party. I didn’t go to escape the truth. I went to remind myself I was still here, still living, still me.

Despite finding out just three days earlier—on December 23—that I had breast cancer, I still got dressed and showed up on December 26, Boxing Day, for a birthday party. I didn’t go to escape the truth. I went to remind myself I was still here, still living, still me.

Despite finding out just three days earlier—on December 23—that I had breast cancer, I still got dressed and showed up on December 26, Boxing Day, for a birthday party. I didn’t go to escape the truth. I went to remind myself I was still here, still living, still me.

Despite finding out just three days earlier—on December 23—that I had breast cancer, I still got dressed and showed up on December 26, Boxing Day, for a birthday party. I didn’t go to escape the truth. I went to remind myself I was still here, still living, still me.

Nicole Drayton’s breast cancer journey–Fear, faith, and fighting back

Yesterday