Commissioner of Police Erla Harewood-Christopher has been given a one-year extension by the Cabinet but not all stakeholders are happy with the decision.
The announcement was made in a media release yesterday, hours after Attorney General Reginald Armour had told Parliament that a decision on the CoP’s fate would come by today.
Wasting no time to weigh in on the matter, Opposition Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar expressed disappointment at the decision at the latest installation of the party’s anti-crime talks in Morvant.
“Before I came here, we are sitting in the Parliament and I got a piece of news and that news doesn’t give me any assurance that within the next year, things will get any better with the crime in Trinidad and Tobago,” Persad-Bissessar told the gathering.
“You know what that news was? The Government has now extended the contract of the present Commissioner of Police.”
As boos and jeers filled the air, Persad-Bissessar underscored, “Now I have no pain or no trouble with that Commissioner of Police. In fact, we voted for her when the matter came to Parliament last time, we voted, we said give her a chance and we have given her a chance. But it is with a heavy heart that I report this tonight because I am even more worried what will be happening during the course of this year.”
Urging those present to give the police their due, Persad-Bissessar added, “We pray to God that Erla will be able to lead them in this year, but I tell you my heart is very heavy in hearing this.” (See page 7)
Former commissioner Gary Griffith also waded into the decision.
“I think the extension of Erla is expected, and maybe even appropriate. Any independent office holder that shows competence, success and popularity above that of this Government, is deemed as a threat.
“Remember, Erla, when measured in performance and competence by international experts, could not place in the top 15 of those who applied for CoP or deputy CoP and based on her performance and competence, or lack of, in the last year, it is indeed most appropriate for her extension, as her standard equates with that of the Security Minister and chair of the National Security Council,” Griffith said in a statement.
“So in terms of competence, accountability and performance, birds of a feather. You cannot appoint a James Bond or a Rambo to work with the Mr Bean and Tommy Joseph of T&T national security. So her extension fits in perfectly.”
Meanwhile, former Police Service Commission (PolSC) member Martin George called on the Government to inform the public what led to its decision.
George said, “One has to question on what basis the Cabinet, which is constitutionally the directing head of the country, on what basis would they have made that decision and have found the confidence to say ‘well done, keep doing what you’re doing’. Because to the average citizen and the ordinary man on the street, keep doing what you’re doing only signals and spells a continuing disaster and a complete failure of the national security apparatus.”
George, an attorney, said crime is a concern of the citizens of T&T and each and everyone looks to the commissioner at the helm.
However, commenting on the CoP’s performance, former Public Services Association (PSA) president Clyde Weatherhead said, “As Gary Griffith says, let us judge on the murder issue and we will see. We’ve had more mass shootings within the last couple months of the tenure of this commissioner. She keeps telling us, ‘well, say a prayer and let’s hope it gets better’. At the same time, she says ‘we’re on top of it’ but we’re not having a situation where murders are declining in a serious way. We had a short drop, a glitch last year, when compared to the year before but we were still over 500 murders for the year. We’re never getting back to that 2002 figure of 200.”
He added, “We’ve been told by the Commissioner of Police that the police are working assiduously, her favourite word, to eliminate the gangs but that’s since she’s taken office and it seems that the gangs are thriving.”
Also contacted yesterday, T&T Police Service Social and Welfare Association (TTSSWA) president Gideon Dickson said he was “watching and observing like everyone else.”
However, at the time of the announcement, he said he would have to discuss the matter with the executive before he could comment.
Some senior police officers also said yesterday that they were not surprised their boss will serve for another year. They said her posture in meetings and planning for events as far as September this year had given them the impression she already knew her contract had been renewed. Sources also said they believed the contract would have been renewed because the PolSC’s call for applications for the top cop position, which ended on May 3, would have taken another five or six months to complete the process.