JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, February 9, 2025

Dumping grounds for corpses

Crim­i­nals dis­pos­ing of bod­ies in aban­doned lots, forests (runover head­line)

by

118 days ago
20241014

On Oc­to­ber 1, a par­tial skele­ton, be­lieved to be the re­mains of 19-year-old Maria Paul, was found buried near a house on Bab­wah Trace, Bar­bu­da Road, Waller­field. Paul was last seen alive on Sep­tem­ber 12 and was be­lieved to be mur­dered.

In­ves­ti­ga­tors are still await­ing the re­sults of a DNA test to con­clu­sive­ly de­ter­mine whether the re­mains are those of Maria Paul.

On Oc­to­ber 4, the de­com­pos­ing body of Cunu­pia used car deal­er Sachel Kunge­be­har­ry was found in a shal­low grave in Pokhor Road, Long­denville. Kunge­be­har­ry was kid­napped by men dressed in tac­ti­cal po­lice gear.

The dis­cov­ery of the two sets of re­mains high­light­ed the preva­lence of the bod­ies be­ing dis­card­ed by their killers in a bid to con­ceal the crime.

In this Guardian Me­dia In­ves­ti­ga­tion, we look at how many more bod­ies may be undis­cov­ered in re­mote lo­ca­tions across T&T.

Se­nior Re­porter

shane.su­perville@guardian.co.tt

Head of the Hunter’s Search and Res­cue team Capt Val­lence Ramb­harat says there are at least 15 ar­eas across Trinidad that are used to dis­pose of the bod­ies of mur­der vic­tims.

Ramb­harat, who has led the vol­un­teer group of hunters and track­ers in search of miss­ing per­sons through dense forests for years, said the bod­ies of mur­der vic­tims are typ­i­cal­ly found in re­mote cor­ners of north­east­ern, cen­tral and south­ern Trinidad.

In the north, he iden­ti­fied the Heights of Aripo, Heights of Gua­napo, Cu­mu­to, Waller­field, Cara­po and Dump Road in Ari­ma as ar­eas of con­cern.

In cen­tral Trinidad, bod­ies are of­ten found in aban­doned lands in Ca­roni, Mon Plaisir Road, Cunu­pia, Clax­ton Bay and Car­li Bay and fur­ther south, in ar­eas around the M1 and M2 Tasker Roads, Fyz­abad, as well as aban­doned ar­eas around Pt Fortin and San­ta Flo­ra.

These are ar­eas con­nect­ed by wind­ing net­works of dirt tracks and un­of­fi­cial clear­ings ac­cessed from mul­ti­ple di­rec­tions and dif­fi­cult to mon­i­tor.

“In terms of dis­pos­ing of bod­ies, you have hun­dreds of kilo­me­tres of roads that are agri­cul­ture ac­cess roads, old Ca­roni roads, old oil­field roads, you have or­phan roads and all these come in­to play when we have to search,” he said.

“It’s an ar­du­ous task, it takes days to search a des­ig­nat­ed area but as we do more and more of it, we’ve nar­rowed down par­tic­u­lar places where we have to look.”

Fol­low­ing the dis­cov­ery of the bod­ies of Ari­ma court clerk An­drea Bharatt in Feb­ru­ary 2021 and Kei­thisha Cud­joe, a year lat­er in the Heights of Aripo, that par­tic­u­lar por­tion of the North­ern Range has been a hotbed of ac­tiv­i­ty for his team.

“In the past four years, we know for a fact that there are oth­er un­of­fi­cial dump­ing sites,” Ramb­harat said.

“Since the An­drea Bharatt search, we’ve par­tic­i­pat­ed in a square me­ter by square me­ter search with the po­lice in 2021 and we did re­cov­er bones, but we don’t know what be­came of them (the re­mains).

“As a search team, we’re al­ways in the Heights of Aripo, we are al­ways in touch with the res­i­dents, they would nor­mal­ly do the main road go­ing up­hill to the vil­lage.”

Al­though the Heights of Aripo gets plen­ty of at­ten­tion, Ramb­harat said oth­er ar­eas across the coun­try might al­so be the fi­nal rest­ing place of miss­ing peo­ple.

In Au­gust, the charred re­mains of a man be­lieved to be Venezue­lan na­tion­al Wilmer Jose Mar­quez were found in a pineap­ple field in Dig­i­ty Trace, Pe­nal.

How­ev­er, an of­fi­cer from the Homi­cide Bu­reau of In­ves­ti­ga­tions was hes­i­tant to de­scribe these ar­eas as “dump­ing grounds” for mur­der vic­tims, al­though he ad­mit­ted that cer­tain ar­eas are used more than oth­ers for dis­card­ing bod­ies.

The of­fi­cer said the po­lice are wary of cer­tain ar­eas.

“While we un­der­stand that there is a con­ve­nience for the dis­crete dis­pos­al (of bod­ies), we have not la­belled it as a dump­ing ground in­trin­si­cal­ly.

“There are se­clud­ed ar­eas where pa­trols are sparse­ly spo­radic that might be con­ve­nient to crim­i­nals want­i­ng to make a quick dump,” he said.

San­dra, 45, is a life­long res­i­dent of the Heights of Aripo. The vast for­est on the out­skirts of her vil­lage was once a com­fort­ing, peace­ful es­cape from the vi­o­lence of T&T’s ur­ban cen­tres. How­ev­er, since sev­er­al bod­ies have been found in the forests sur­round­ing her home in the Aripo Vil­lage, it no longer feels like the quaint rur­al com­mu­ni­ty of her girl­hood.

“Just dri­ving up here you could feel the heav­i­ness and weight on your shoul­ders,” she said. “So just imag­ine liv­ing up here, it wears on you af­ter a while.”

In the past three years, hu­man re­mains have been found down the steep precipice off Aripo Road which con­nects the vil­lage on the bor­der of Ari­ma and Va­len­cia in the foothills of the North­ern Range.

Every dis­cov­ery adds to the un­ease of Aripo vil­lagers.

In an in­ter­view in Ju­ly, San­dra said it had been a while since hu­man re­mains were found in the for­est, but she felt oth­er bod­ies re­main undis­cov­ered. That both­ers her every time she en­ters and leaves the vil­lage.

“Not long af­ter they found her (An­drea Bharatt’s re­mains) I thought they would have sent more of­fi­cers to comb the forests.

“There could be a lot of oth­er peo­ple buried there that we don’t even know about,” she said.

“You pass here some­times and smell all kinds of scents, we just as­sume it’s a dead dog or a cat, not know­ing it could be a per­son.”

Like many oth­er com­mu­ni­ties on the edge of the North­ern Range, Aripo has sev­er­al at­trac­tions for na­ture lovers in­clud­ing hik­ing trails, rivers, a wa­ter­fall and the Oil­bird Caves fur­ther north.

How­ev­er, San­dra said the dis­cov­ery of hu­man re­mains has led to a no­tice­able drop in vis­i­tors to the area.

She said she re­cent­ly in­vit­ed friends for a riv­er lime but the of­fer was po­lite­ly de­clined.

“Peo­ple just aren’t com­ing in here as they used to. We have a nice riv­er and they told me no way they’re com­ing here. From the time they hear Aripo, they al­ready made up their minds.”

She adds that res­i­dents avoid en­ter­ing and leav­ing the area af­ter dark as ban­dits have been known to wait in the bush­es for passers-by. This to­geth­er with the poor vis­i­bil­i­ty makes the vil­lage iso­lat­ed once the sun sets.

“If you go out the road, you have to come back in for a cer­tain time be­cause there’s al­ways the pos­si­bil­i­ty that some­body might block the road.

“Some­times peo­ple come in af­ter hours and they say they see­ing strange ve­hi­cles just parked up, so they still do­ing their mis­chief.”

In Feb­ru­ary 2022, Pub­lic Util­i­ties Min­is­ter Mar­vin Gon­za­les and Ari­ma MP Pen­ne­lope Beck­les-Robin­son, with as­sis­tance from the TT Elec­tric­i­ty Com­mis­sion (T&TEC), over­saw the in­stal­la­tion of 14 elec­tric­i­ty poles and 32 LED street lights.

The project cost $296,786.11.

Gon­za­les said then that the project was ex­pect­ed to con­tin­ue as more fund­ing be­comes avail­able. Asked if there were any plans to in­stall CCTV cam­eras at the lo­ca­tion, Gon­za­les said such de­ci­sions are not un­der his min­istry.

One res­i­dent said the in­stal­la­tion of the lights pro­vid­ed lit­tle re­lief as sev­er­al of them were dam­aged and reg­u­lar­ly need­ed re­pair­ing.

The man said while he felt safe in Aripo Vil­lage, the Aripo Road on the out­skirts of the vil­lage could be dan­ger­ous af­ter dark.

“If you hap­pen to bounce up some­body putting down a crime, that im­me­di­ate­ly puts you at risk too. Just see­ing some­one do­ing a crime means you can end up in the same prob­lems.”

Head of the North­ern Di­vi­sion Snr Supt Miguel Mon­trichard ad­mit­ted that pa­trolling such treach­er­ous ter­rain is dif­fi­cult. These chal­lenges have stoked fears that por­tions of this is­land are dif­fi­cult to po­lice, so crim­i­nals are free to com­mit crimes with im­puni­ty.

Kei­thisha’s aunt still lives with grief

On Jan­u­ary 24, 2022, Kei­thisha Cud­joe said good­bye to her friends af­ter a lime in Bel­mont. The 21-year-old Diego Mar­tin na­tive had re­cent­ly moved to Co­corite and was ea­ger to re­turn home af­ter the evening out.

Her de­com­pos­ing body was found on Jan­u­ary 28 in the Heights of Aripo, 31 miles away from her home.

For Ayan­na Cud­joe, Kei­thisha’s aunt, adding to the grief of los­ing a close rel­a­tive is the dis­ap­pear­ance of her 19-year-old son last No­vem­ber.

Saleem Joseph went to vis­it a friend at the Mt Hope Hos­pi­tal but al­though he re­as­sured an aunt that he would be re­turn­ing home short­ly, the teen was nev­er seen again.

Re­call­ing the day she vis­it­ed the Foren­sic Sci­ence Cen­tre to iden­ti­fy Kei­thisha’s body, Cud­joe said the ad­vanced de­com­po­si­tion of the body was some­thing she would nev­er for­get.

“I re­mem­ber the pathol­o­gist ex­plain­ing to me what to ex­pect be­fore I could go in the room to iden­ti­fy her body. He said what I knew as my niece was not what I was go­ing to see and from that point the anx­i­ety hit me. I couldn’t breathe. When I saw my niece I had to ask how this per­son liv­ing with them­selves. I hope she is haunt­ing them,” she said.

Cud­joe said since Kei­thisha’s mur­der the fam­i­ly has not re­ceived up­dates from the po­lice in­ves­ti­ga­tors on whether a sus­pect was ever ar­rest­ed or charged for the mur­der.

“It’s just some­thing we all have to live with it seems. She was some­thing to us and the way they just threw her away is hard,” she said.

Cud­joe waits for her son’s re­turn but ad­mits that liv­ing with­out know­ing what hap­pened to him has put a strain on the fam­i­ly. She tries to stay strong for her daugh­ter, Saleem’s sis­ter but mourns him pri­vate­ly.

“I won’t get to hear him say, Mom, you’re go­ing to be a grand­moth­er. I don’t know what hap­pened to him. All I can do is sit and wait,” she said

Bod­ies dumped (put in a box)

• Feb­ru­ary 2021 - the body of 23-year-old law clerk An­drea Bharatt was found at the bot­tom of a precipice in the Heights of Aripo, days af­ter she en­tered a taxi in Ari­ma.

• Two days af­ter An­drea Bharatt’s re­mains were found, po­lice in a fol­low-up sweep of the area found a bag con­tain­ing a sep­a­rate set of re­mains that have still not been iden­ti­fied.

• Jan­u­ary 24, 2022 - Kei­thisha Cud­joe, 21, left a lime with friends in Bel­mont. Her de­com­pos­ing body was found on Jan­u­ary 28 in the Heights of Aripo.

• April 2022 - a de­com­pos­ing body was found near the site where An­drea Bharatt’s body had been found a year ear­li­er. In­ves­ti­ga­tors have not been able to con­firm the iden­ti­ty of the in­di­vid­ual.

• Ju­ly 18 - the body of Bran­don Bruce, 21, was found on Smith­field Road, Aripo. The head was cov­ered in plas­tic held in place with duct tape and there was a sin­gle gun­shot wound to the stom­ach.

• Au­gust 10 - a farmer found charred re­mains be­lieved to be Wilmer Jose Mar­quez, in Dig­i­ty Road, Pe­nal.

• Au­gust 22 - the tor­so of a man was found wrapped in a large plas­tic bag in Hold­er Trace, Barataria. A skull was found near­by to­geth­er with a piece of scalp.

• Oc­to­ber 1 - a par­tial skele­ton, be­lieved to be 19-year-old Maria Paul was found near a house on Bar­bu­da Road, Waller­field.

• Oc­to­ber 4 - the de­com­pos­ing body of Cunu­pia busi­ness­man Sachel Kunge­be­har­ry was found in a shal­low grave in Pokhor Road, Long­denville.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored