JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, March 16, 2025

Health experts say PM’s move to end SoE mistimed

by

1217 days ago
20211114

rishard.khan@guardian.co.tt

Since Prime Min­is­ter Dr Kei­th Row­ley sig­nalled the in­ten­tion on Sat­ur­day to end the State of Emer­gency (SoE), con­cerns have been ex­pressed over the de­ci­sion to do so amidst a cur­rent spike in cas­es.

Pub­lic health diplo­mat and epi­demi­ol­o­gist with over 30 years ex­pe­ri­ence, Dr Far­ley Cleghorn, shares a sim­i­lar sen­ti­ment that the lift­ing of the State of Emer­gency may have been mist­imed.

Asked dur­ing an in­ter­view with Guardian Me­dia about con­cerns that the move was mist­imed, Cleghorn said: “I couldn’t dis­agree with that.”

One of the pri­ma­ry bases for his eval­u­a­tion is the coun­try’s low vac­ci­na­tion up­take along with a par­al­lel health­care sys­tem that may not be able to ac­com­mo­date in­creased cas­es—es­pe­cial­ly in its In­ten­sive Care Units (ICUs).

“That is the kind of key ques­tion that a gov­ern­ment has to ask it­self when you’re say­ing we’re go­ing to lift a State of Emer­gency- if we can tol­er­ate more cas­es with­out over­bur­den­ing the health­care sys­tem?”

He said in the Unit­ed King­dom the de­ci­sion to re­open schools was fea­si­ble be­cause they were able to tol­er­ate the in­crease in cas­es while keep­ing the death rate low.

“But what I’m see­ing in Trinidad is that doesn’t nec­es­sar­i­ly play out. Our death rates are still go­ing up which means our health ser­vices de­liv­ery for peo­ple with COVID-19 is not as ef­fec­tive as it can be,” he said.

Cleghorn said part of the prob­lem is the lat­est trend of pa­tients pre­sent­ing too late to hos­pi­tals, which in­creas­es their chance of dy­ing.

For al­most a month, the Min­istry of Health has been warn­ing that the ICUs across the par­al­lel health­care sys­tem has been al­most at ca­pac­i­ty on a dai­ly ba­sis.

He at­trib­uted the cur­rent in­crease to the promi­nence of the more trans­mis­si­ble Delta vari­ant among the pop­u­la­tion in com­bi­na­tion with the re­turn of sec­ondary school stu­dents to face-to-face class­es.

Cleghorn said he un­der­stood the predica­ment the Gov­ern­ment is in try­ing to man­age the pan­dem­ic.

“I un­der­stand the think­ing of gov­ern­ment which is how do we get past the eco­nom­ic and so­cial ef­fects of the pan­dem­ic while man­ag­ing the med­ical out­comes,” he said.

Pae­di­a­tri­cian Dr David Bratt al­so shared a sim­i­lar view about the Prime Min­is­ter’s de­ci­sion, say­ing: “for me, it makes no sense at all.”

In­ter­nal med­i­cine spe­cial­ist Dr Joel Teelucks­ingh was re­served in judg­ing the de­ci­sion to lift the State of Emer­gency but not­ed that its ef­fec­tive­ness is yet to be as­sessed.

“We would need analy­sis whether or not the State of Emer­gency and lock­downs were of any ben­e­fit for the last six months and that da­ta is still forth­com­ing,” he said.

A fur­ther in­crease in COVID-19 cas­es when the State of Emer­gency is lift­ed is a re­al threat that even the Min­is­ter of Health, Ter­rence Deyals­ingh, fears as he ex­pressed as a guest on The Morn­ing Pan­chay­at on Akash Vani 106.5FM last week.

“I am death­ly afraid of that be­cause then the par­ty­ing is go­ing to start back and all of these things are go­ing to start back and cas­es would most like­ly sky­rock­et and our health care sys­tem, the par­al­lel health care sys­tem, maybe over­whelmed and we are deal­ing with the known Delta vari­ant...what hap­pens if to­mor­row you hear about an­oth­er vari­ant which is more dead­ly what are we go­ing to do?” he said then.

De­spite hav­ing greater vac­cine cov­er­age than T&T, many coun­tries around the world have re-en­tered in­to “lock­downs” due to surg­ing cas­es among its un­vac­ci­nat­ed pop­u­la­tion- most re­cent­ly Aus­tria, a coun­try with 65 per cent of its pop­u­la­tion ful­ly vac­ci­nat­ed.

Asked if it’s a sit­u­a­tion T&T may end up in the fu­ture Cleghorn said: “As a sci­en­tist and an epi­demi­ol­o­gist, the an­swer is clear­ly yes. We have to pre­serve that op­tion.”

How­ev­er, now that the de­ci­sion has been made to lift the State of Emer­gency and bring an end to the cur­few, Cleghorn said the Gov­ern­ment need­ed to fo­cus on en­cour­ag­ing vac­cine up­take.

“If I then had to put my ef­fort in­to some­thing I would put it in­to re­al­ly bol­ster­ing the abil­i­ty to up peo­ple to get vac­ci­nat­ed and to get boost­ers. This is some­thing you have to find new ways (to do),” he said.

He said the strate­gies need to tar­get those who are vac­cine re­sis­tant/un­will­ing and the vac­cine-hes­i­tant pop­u­la­tion. To do this he said the cur­rent ap­proach needs to change.

“There’s a lim­it to the ef­fec­tive­ness of giv­ing in­for­ma­tion to peo­ple, even ac­cu­rate sci­en­tif­ic in­for­ma­tion,” he said.

“When I say that the Min­is­ter of Health or the Chief Med­ical Of­fi­cer or the Prime Min­is­ter...they’re all giv­ing valu­able in­for­ma­tion on a reg­u­lar ba­sis but that is not ef­fec­tive in reach­ing the re­sis­tant, the hes­i­tant, the un­will­ing,” he not­ed.

He said a more grass-roots ap­proach was need­ed to dis­sem­i­nate ac­cu­rate in­for­ma­tion and en­cour­age­ment di­rect­ed at those who are vac­cine-hes­i­tant.

Bratt al­so be­lieves this is the route the Gov­ern­ment need­ed to ex­plore.

“How do you get peo­ple to have trust? That is the ques­tion. Peo­ple don’t trust the Gov­ern­ment. Peo­ple don’t trust big phar­ma­cy. Fine. So how do we get around that?” he said.

Cleghorn sug­gests there is even a place in a re­vised plan to in­crease vac­cine up­take for strate­gic vac­cine man­dates, which he said, “have al­ways been part of pub­lic health man­age­ment strate­gies.”

“What you need is a port­fo­lio strat­e­gy. A port­fo­lio strat­e­gy says what is the room for man­dates and how would those be ex­e­cut­ed? And then what does it leave out and what would be a non-man­dat­ed strat­e­gy for them?” he said.

Cleghorn ac­knowl­edged that en­cour­ag­ing vac­cine up­take among peo­ple is a ma­jor chal­lenge not iso­lat­ed to T&T and ex­tends to coun­tries around the world, in­clud­ing the Unit­ed States.

He said it’s im­por­tant the pub­lic un­der­stands that while the State of Emer­gency is be­ing lift­ed, it does not mean the threat of COVID-19 is no longer present.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored