Despite a recent call by former prime minister Dr Keith Rowley for Trinidad and Tobago to “complete its independence” by severing ties with the United Kingdom’s Privy Council, there remains strong opposition on the ground to such a move.
This has been revealed in the results of a new public opinion poll carried out just over a week ago in both Trinidad and Tobago.
Asked whether T&T should abolish appeals to the Privy Council, most respondents in Trinidad (45 per cent) said “No,” compared to 25 per cent who said “Yes” to ending the current relationship with the London law lords.
The remaining 30 per cent of 1,650 participants in the Hamid Ghany survey, commissioned by Guardian Media, were undecided.
Over in Tobago, where 530 people were polled, public sentiment was quite similar. Forty-five per cent of those surveyed said they were in favour of maintaining ties with the Privy Council, while 21 per cent were opposed.
The other 34 per cent were non-committal.
The April 10-13 survey comes less than a month after Rowley’s impassioned appeal to the country to end ties with the Privy Council and to adopt the Port-of-Spain-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) as its final court of appeal.
Rowley, whose People’s National Movement (PNM) Government has been in the forefront of efforts to remove jurisprudential colonial vestiges, made the call immediately after Britain imposed visa restrictions on Trinidad and Tobago nationals.
But with the Opposition United National Congress (UNC) seemingly dead set against making the CCJ this country’s final court of appeal and replacing the Privy Council, Rowley could do nothing else but openly vent his frustrations on the matter, which requires two-thirds majority support in the Parliament for adoption.
“It is unjust, it is disgraceful that they (Britain) would disregard our wider national interest, put a fee on us and tell us while you have to come to us to have our law lords tell you what is right and wrong, you have to pay for a visa to come and do that,” Rowley said.
Delivering his final address as prime minister to PNM supporters on March 16 at a political rally at Woodford Square, Port-of-Spain, he went as far as to warn the country to “get the hell out” of the Privy Council.
“If you think they [the British) have come around to treating us like equals, you have another thought coming. Many of them still believe that we are substandard; (that) we are inferior, and they should treat us how they want to treat us …
“Trinidad and Tobago must complete its independence and get the hell out of the Privy Council,” he stressed.
“(But) what really rots my gut is that I have to also swallow that the highest court of this land is in London at the Privy Council and if you have to go to the Privy Council, you have to go there by way of some arrangements they make for you. Do you really feel independent where your highest court is in a foreign country and the foreign country leaders would put down the arrangements by which you could come to that country?”
The poll was conducted in the marginal constituencies of Barataria/San Juan, Chaguanas East, Cumuto/Manzanilla, La Horquetta/Talparo, Mayaro, Moruga/Tableland, Pointe-a-Pierre (now called Claxton Bay), San Fernando West, St Joseph, Toco/Sangre Grande and Tunapuna, as well as Tobago.
It has a margin of error of +/- 2.5 per cent for Trinidad and +/- 4.0 per cent based on recent political and boundary shifts.