JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Tuesday, April 8, 2025

White Trini finds Caribbean identity

by

20161024

Land sur­vey­or Ivan Laugh­lin has de­signed and over­seen ur­ban plan­ning projects for sev­er­al decades. Laugh­lin be­lieves in sus­tain­able de­vel­op­ment and ex­pan­sion of vil­lages to in­spire com­mu­nal to­geth­er­ness and en­cour­age de­cen­tral­i­sa­tion away from the ur­ban cen­tres. In a se­ries ex­clu­sive to the T&T Guardian, Laugh­lin will es­pouse his vi­sion for the de­vel­op­ment of T&T's rur­al ar­eas like To­co and the east coast. To­day, Laugh­lin speaks to Tony Rakhal-Fras­er about his life and in­spi­ra­tion for his vi­sion of de­vel­op­ment.

He re­signed from the Queen's Park Crick­et Club in 1966 be­cause he felt that the club dis­crim­i­nat­ed against non-whites; he be­came at­tract­ed to the rad­i­cal per­spec­tives of the New World Group as its mem­bers sought to chart a new course for a post-colo­nial Caribbean and its peo­ple.

As a stu­dent on the UWI St Au­gus­tine Cam­pus in the rev­o­lu­tion­ary 1960s, Ivan Laugh­lin, white and mid­dle-class, im­mersed him­self in the Black Pow­er re­volt, and was part of the march to Ca­roni un­der the ban­ner of "Africans and In­di­ans Unite."

"There was some fric­tion amongst the stu­dents on the march. Ged­des Granger saw what was go­ing on. He told me: 'Ivan, or­gan­ise the stu­dents; get them to­geth­er.'

"So I am say­ing to my­self, here I am, a white man in a Black Pow­er move­ment, and I am be­ing asked to sort out dif­fi­cul­ties amongst the black stu­dents. It gave me a lift (Granger's man­date) be­cause it made me re­alise that when you have to con­front fun­da­men­tal is­sues of life, no longer is it seen in white or black; you are just a hu­man be­ing strug­gling for strong eter­nal be­liefs of a civil­i­sa­tion."

Laugh­lin's per­spec­tive and role were in di­rect con­flict with his eth­nic (Irish and French Cre­ole her­itage) and so­cial class back­ground, out­side of the main­stream of the black ma­jor­i­ty.

His grow­ing-up years were spent not "down the is­lands" in the lap of priv­i­lege, even though there was so­cial in­ter­ac­tion amongst his "kin­dred," but first on Long Cir­cu­lar Road, and then on a fam­i­ly es­tate in Mara­cas (St Joseph) Val­ley.

Dur­ing his teen years, Ivan got a per­spec­tive of Port-of-Spain from an at­tic in which his fa­ther lived on Fred­er­ick Street, his par­ents hav­ing sep­a­rat­ed.

He spent hol­i­days "see­ing and feel­ing the city come alive."

His sec­ondary school years were at the Abbey School at Mount St Bene­dict, to which he ped­dled to and from the es­tate. At the school he came un­der the lib­er­al tute­lage of Dutch prin­ci­pals of the Abbey and had a glo­ri­ous ex­pe­ri­ence as a crick­et-lov­ing boy with El­lis "Puss" Achong (in­ven­tor of the "Chi­na­man"), Clif­ford Roach (who scored the first cen­tu­ry and dou­ble for WI) and Lance Mur­ray, who all spent a ses­sion at the school with the boys. It was Mur­ray (Deryck's fa­ther) who in­flu­enced him in­to the pro­fes­sion of land sur­vey­ing and be­ing a mem­ber of the QPCC.

Sur­vey­ing the land, from beach to bush

This taste of ur­ban and rur­al life made an im­pres­sion on Laugh­lin, and the rur­al was con­sol­i­dat­ed when he be­came an ap­pren­tice sur­vey­or (a white man labour­er, re­al­ly) hav­ing to tra­verse the vil­lages and live with peo­ple in Matelot, Ce­dros, To­co, Ma­yaro, and so on.

"Then I had to in­ter­face with the peo­ple in those ar­eas and the crews; you have to en­counter all kinds of hard­ships, in the bush, on the coast­line; work­ing with old­er men drink­ing rum. Our job was to tell the sto­ry of the face of the earth, un­der­stand the voic­es of land and what they are telling you; and so, too, the voic­es of the peo­ple," says Laugh­lin.

"But the is­sue of race was some­thing that you had to be ex­treme­ly con­scious about, and it forced me to have to think very care­ful­ly about what my life was about in this place. What it made me re­alise was that I had to know about the Caribbean."

He al­so had the fright­en­ing ex­pe­ri­ence of hav­ing to wait out the fierce Hur­ri­cane Janet ("Janet hide in de moun­tain, Janet lick down a mil­lion build­ing"–Lord Melody) on board a schooner in the Bridgetown port. At UWI in the 1960s, hav­ing been per­suad­ed by Lloyd Best to take a de­gree in eco­nom­ics and gov­ern­ment, Laugh­lin found him­self among post-colo­nial in­tel­lec­tu­als of the ilk of Dr James Mil­lette, Best, Nor­man Gir­van, and George Beck­ford of the New World Group.

He read in­ces­sant­ly, in­clud­ing the writ­ings of Ched­di Ja­gan, Er­ic Williams and CLR James. But Laugh­lin's defin­ing mo­ment in his grow­ing con­scious­ness came with an evening spent with CLR James at the com­mu­ni­ty cen­tre in St Ann's.

The im­pact of CLR James, Frank Wor­rell

"His im­pact on my think­ing as a man of the Caribbean was pro­found; I owe a great deal to him," says Laugh­lin.

That en­counter with CLR was in the lead-up to the 1966 gen­er­al elec­tion in which James, along with the likes of Stephen Ma­haraj, George Weekes and Bas­deo Pan­day, con­test­ed on the tick­et of the Work­ers and Farm­ers Par­ty–a par­ty with a de­cid­ed­ly so­cial­ist ori­en­ta­tion.

"My mind be­came filled with knowl­edge of the Caribbean, and that fixed my ori­en­ta­tion and an­chored me in this place. It made me re­alise that the Caribbean is a unique kind of civil­i­sa­tion. And the per­son out­side of CLR that made a tremen­dous im­pact on me was Frank Wor­rell.

"In 1961 when Wor­rell took the WI crick­et team to Aus­tralia and mould­ed to­geth­er Caribbean peo­ple, he went against the tra­di­tions of po­lit­i­cal dis­in­te­gra­tion. He was one of the great­est lead­ers the Caribbean has known."

But arm­chair pol­i­tics did not suit Laugh­lin's per­son­al­i­ty. He dived deep in­to elec­toral pol­i­tics as a mem­ber of Tapia, the uni­ver­si­ty-bred par­ty of in­tel­lec­tu­als.

In the run-up to the 1976 poll, Laugh­lin hit the road spread­ing the Re­view, the par­ty's news­pa­per which he and the hi­er­ar­chy of the par­ty hawked up and down the coun­try.

"I had the south run, de­liv­er­ing pa­pers and en­gag­ing in di­a­logue from San Fer­nan­do to Fyz­abad and the deep south. Once I did a run in St James, stop­ping at all of the wa­ter­ing holes along the way. By the end of the line, hav­ing ac­cept­ed in­vi­ta­tions to 'fire one,' I was quite drunk."

At the 1976 polls, Ivan came up against George Cham­bers in the St Ann's con­stituen­cy–one which Cham­bers had ruled over since its cre­ation in 1966. As record­ed, Ivan Alexan­der Laugh­lin (Tapia) re­ceived 679 votes; George Michael Cham­bers (PNM) at­tract­ed 6,853.

It was a chas­ten­ing time for Ivan and his col­leagues. De­spite at­tract­ing much cam­paign plat­form at­ten­tion, not one of them was able to se­cure his or her de­posit.

"At the end of the elec­tion I was flat broke and had to be­gin to re­or­gan­ise my life," says Laugh­lin.

Changes, per­son­aland pro­fes­sion­al

Laugh­lin's do­mes­tic life had tak­en on a change. He had been di­vorced from his first wife, one of his own race and so­cial class. His sec­ond mar­riage was to an In­di­an woman, Tho­ra Char­iandy, whom he had met on cam­pus.

This was not well ac­cept­ed by his own.

"Al­so, I was no longer in re­li­gion and mak­ing my own life, and I mar­ried an In­di­an woman, so in those sit­u­a­tions it was nev­er an easy thing; there were times when I felt I was os­tracised for be­ing mar­ried to an In­di­an woman. How­ev­er I was ac­cept­ed by the fam­i­ly of my wife."

But Laugh­lin stood his ground, just like when he had re­signed from Queen's Park.

"I re­mem­ber Ger­ry Gomez say­ing to me some­time af­ter I had re­signed: 'Ivan, I ad­mire you; you stood by what you be­lieved in and I have to say that it is some­thing I ad­mire.' That gave me some sense of not be­ing com­plete­ly out on a limb."

One project Laugh­lin de­vel­oped was Home Farms, a hous­ing set­tle­ment which fore­cast the Sou Sou Lands project. Laugh­lin's


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored