JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Saturday, February 22, 2025

Regional economist: Time to replace TT dollar, remove VAT

by

933 days ago
20220804

As food prices con­tin­ue to sky­rock­et, cou­pled with high in­fla­tion, should T&T adopt sim­i­lar mea­sures as that of Bar­ba­dos which saw the re­cent widen­ing of its VAT-free bas­ket of goods?

T&T-born re­gion­al econ­o­mist Dr Justin Ram who re­sides in Bar­ba­dos rec­om­mends that the T&T Gov­ern­ment in­stead do away with Val­ue Added Tax (VAT) al­to­geth­er and im­ple­ment a sim­ple sales tax to not on­ly al­le­vi­ate the bur­den on cit­i­zens but stim­u­late eco­nom­ic growth.

De­scrib­ing VAT as a “cum­ber­some tax” Ram ex­plained, “Re­place it (VAT) with a gen­er­al, sim­pler sales tax at a low­er rate than what VAT is right now. The bulk of in­come should re­al­ly be com­ing from a sales tax and re­duce the bur­den of in­come tax­es par­tic­u­lar­ly on PAYE (Pay As You Earn) and on cor­po­ra­tion tax be­cause, ul­ti­mate­ly, you need to get in­vest­ment go­ing and give peo­ple the op­por­tu­ni­ty to get good pay­ing jobs.”

Last month Prime Min­is­ter of Bar­ba­dos Mia Mot­t­ley un­veiled an $18 mil­lion pack­age to pro­vide much-need­ed re­lief, ac­knowl­edg­ing the dai­ly con­straints Bar­ba­di­ans face in deal­ing with high prices for ba­sic goods, en­er­gy, and gas.

The Bar­ba­di­an Gov­ern­ment has added 44 more home and food items to the list of things that are ex­empt from pay­ing VAT as a re­sult of the re­lief mea­sures.

Some prod­ucts had cus­toms tar­iffs lift­ed, which al­lowed for price re­duc­tions for con­sumers which will last through Jan­u­ary 31 next year.

The Busi­ness Guardian al­so reached out to Trade Min­is­ter Paula Gopee-Scoon on whether there should be more VAT-free goods on the lo­cal shelves.

She said, “There are thou­sands of VAT-free food items in T&T, and this is in ad­di­tion to an­oth­er 20 ba­sic food items with­in most in­stances no du­ty.

“This Gov­ern­ment has paid enor­mous at­ten­tion to en­sur­ing that ba­sic food items are avail­able through the pro­vi­sion of close to US $1 bil­lion in FX sup­port. There have been no emp­ty shelves.”

But for T&T, Ram said, VAT has wider eco­nom­ic im­pli­ca­tions.

One of which is the Gov­ern­ment con­tin­u­ing to owe mil­lions in re­turns to busi­ness­es and these are of­ten paid late and thus crip­ple op­er­a­tions.

“In ef­fect, the Gov­ern­ment is tak­ing a loan via VAT pay­ments and not re­pay­ing the re­bates un­til much lat­er on, some­times years. That mon­ey is now out of the cor­po­rate hands and they can’t use that for in­vest­ment.

“That’s not a good thing. In­stead, im­ple­ment a small­er sales tax on every­thing, maybe there could be some ex­emp­tions, but that sim­ple sales tax could be about five per cent,” Ram fur­ther ex­plained.

This would, there­fore, would en­able the busi­ness en­vi­ron­ment to be en­hanced as there would now be rev­enue for rein­vest­ment in­to the econ­o­my.

Ram al­so warned that Gov­ern­ment should not be head­ing in the di­rec­tion of short-term tax fix­es giv­en the present in­fla­tion but rather fo­cus on trans­form­ing the econ­o­my; the big­ger pic­ture.

“Let’s face it. The econ­o­my need­ed trans­form­ing even be­fore this high lev­el of in­fla­tion. And what I keep hear­ing is we are go­ing to wait. We are to make short-term fix­es. Short-term fix­es are not what we need.

“We are al­ways go­ing to be vul­ner­a­ble to all these changes in the glob­al mar­ket which, be­fore were com­ing every few years but now seems to be com­ing every six months,” Ram not­ed.

Em­pha­sis­ing that the Gov­ern­ment needs to make the econ­o­my much more re­silient Ram sug­gest­ed one mea­sure must be pri­vate sec­tor in­vest­ment.

“Re­duc­ing cor­po­ra­tion tax, re­duc­ing tax­es on prof­it in­clud­ing div­i­dends, in­clud­ing share­hold­ings is some­thing you re­al­ly need to con­sid­er,” Ram said, adding that for house­holds to sur­vive they can­not do so from Gov­ern­ment hand­outs.

Rather, such sur­vival de­pends on ac­cess to good-pay­ing jobs, he main­tained.

Bar­ba­dos had al­so an­nounced a cut to its VAT from 17.5 per cent to 7.5 per cent for the pow­er charge up to the first 250 kilo­watt hours of res­i­den­tial elec­tric­i­ty bill to pro­vide as­sis­tance for house­hold­ers’ elec­tric­i­ty costs.

“As a re­sult, their cost will de­crease from $204.46 to $187.06 for them. This will cost the Bar­ba­dos gov­ern­ment $1.527 mil­lion each month, or just $10.5 mil­lion in to­tal, for the pe­ri­od from Au­gust 1 to Jan­u­ary 31,” Mot­t­ley had said.

How­ev­er, ac­cord­ing to Ram this is not prac­ti­cal for T&T.

Main­ly be­cause this coun­try al­ready en­joys low elec­tric­i­ty rates.

He said in Bar­ba­dos the cost of elec­tric­i­ty is around US 30 cents per kilo­watt hour while lo­cal­ly it’s around US six cents per kilo­watt hour.

“Elec­tric­i­ty is al­ready heav­i­ly sub­sidised in T&T. There’s no more room to sub­sidise that un­less you say you’re giv­ing away elec­tric­i­ty. And any­thing that re­quires Gov­ern­ment try­ing to con­trol the prices stay away from it.

“Even that pol­i­cy in Bar­ba­dos, I re­al­ly don’t agree with be­cause it even­tu­al­ly comes back to bite the Gov­ern­ment and the econ­o­my,” Ram warned.

Get rid of the TT $, re­form Cen­tral Bank

Re­gard­ing oth­er mea­sures at re­form­ing this coun­try’s econ­o­my, Ram ad­vised do­ing away with the TT dol­lar.

Like oth­er cur­ren­cies in the Caribbean, he said this on­ly serves to drag eco­nom­ic ac­tiv­i­ty.

In­stead, re­place these cur­ren­cies with the US dol­lar, Ram sug­gest­ed.

“Let every­one start un­der­stand­ing you are earn­ing a US dol­lar and this would smooth so many trans­ac­tions even at an in­ter­na­tion­al lev­el.

“The use of na­tion­al cur­ren­cies has many more costs than ben­e­fits be­cause you are still con­strained by hav­ing for­eign cur­ren­cy re­serves to back that lo­cal cur­ren­cy.

“So why not just put that for­eign cur­ren­cy re­serve in­to the hands of or­di­nary peo­ple and in­to the cor­po­ra­tion? Con­vert out the TT dol­lar in­to the re­serves,” Ram ex­plained.

That cur­ren­cy in cir­cu­la­tion, there­fore, will ul­ti­mate­ly be­come the re­serves which al­so means that trad­ing on a glob­al scale be­comes much eas­i­er, he added.

“For me that’s a big top­ic which needs to be con­sid­ered to help these coun­tries move for­ward,” Ram re­it­er­at­ed.

Is get­ting rid of the TT$ easy?

Ac­cord­ing to Ram it’s a process which is not dif­fi­cult.

For in­stance, the prices of goods and ser­vices can be both in TT and US cur­ren­cy which is a first step.

“So you al­ready then say the US cur­ren­cy be­comes legal­ly ac­cept­ed in the coun­try for all trans­ac­tions. It’s a par­al­lel sys­tem hap­pen­ing at the same time.

“And over time, like over a year, tran­si­tion to us­ing on­ly US cur­ren­cy. So you start to slow­ly roll back and get rid of the TT dol­lar while the US dol­lar be­comes the main thing,” Ram said.

Ad­di­tion­al­ly, he said TT dol­lar hold­ing will al­so be re­placed with the US dol­lar, mak­ing it more ben­e­fi­cial.

Ram al­so ref­er­enced a pa­per ti­tled, “The Time Has Come to Per­ma­nent­ly Re­tire All Our Caribbean Cur­ren­cies” by for­mer Gov­er­nor of the Cen­tral Bank of Bar­ba­dos DeLisle Wor­rell.

Ac­cord­ing to Wor­rell, the cur­ren­cies of Caribbean coun­tries have now out­lived their use­ful­ness, and have be­come a li­a­bil­i­ty.

They were de­vised at a time when most pay­ments were made us­ing notes and coins, is­sued in dis­tant met­ro­pol­i­tan cen­tres, Wor­rell out­lined, say­ing scarci­ty of the means of pay­ment was a se­vere hin­drance to com­merce.

“In re­sponse cur­ren­cy boards were set up, to is­sue lo­cal cur­ren­cy as need­ed in the colonies. The sys­tem worked well be­cause the lo­cal cur­ren­cy is­sue was backed by an equiv­a­lent val­ue of Ster­ling, in a glob­al sys­tem of fixed ex­change rates.

“In con­trast, nowa­days pay­ments are made most­ly by elec­tron­ic com­mu­ni­ca­tion, cred­it and deb­it cards, cheques and drafts, with set­tle­ment over dig­i­tized bank ac­counts,” Wor­rell ex­plained.

How­ev­er, he not­ed in to­day’s world an own cur­ren­cy has be­come a li­a­bil­i­ty for small economies, lim­it­ing ac­cess to in­ter­na­tion­al goods and ser­vices, ex­pos­ing res­i­dents to risks of cur­ren­cy de­val­u­a­tion and in­fla­tion, erod­ing the val­ue of do­mes­tic sav­ings, in­creas­ing eco­nom­ic in­equal­i­ties, pro­vid­ing a tool for un­pro­duc­tive gov­ern­ment spend­ing, and di­vert­ing at­ten­tion from the need to in­crease pro­duc­tiv­i­ty and en­hance in­ter­na­tion­al com­pet­i­tive­ness.

Wor­rell said while re­tir­ing lo­cal cur­ren­cy is seen by uni­formed ob­servers as a sur­ren­der of eco­nom­ic sov­er­eign­ty, ex­act­ly the op­po­site is true: ex­clu­sive use of the US dol­lar en­hances the range of choice open to the coun­try and its res­i­dents, in all in­ter­na­tion­al com­merce, be­cause such trans­ac­tions are con­duct­ed in US dol­lars or in cur­ren­cies that are con­vert­ible to US dol­lars.

“In con­trast, with the Bar­ba­dos dol­lars, you can­not buy or sell any­thing in near­by St Lu­cia, much less in the rest of the world.

“In a world where pay­ments and set­tle­ments are digi­tised, with no need for notes and coins, there is no lim­it on the com­mer­cial and fi­nan­cial sov­er­eign­ty of hold­ers of the US dol­lar,” Wor­rell fur­ther ex­plained.

Mon­e­tary re­form al­so in­volves a coun­try’s Cen­tral Bank.

Ac­cord­ing to Ram T&T’s Cen­tral Bank, just like its econ­o­my, is al­so in need of re­form.

“I don’t see what’s the point of the Cen­tral Bank. There’s no point. That’s a re­al in­sti­tu­tion­al bur­den with not much ben­e­fit,” Ram said.

He sug­gest­ed it be re­designed to ad­dress im­por­tant mea­sures like mon­e­tary pol­i­cy.

How­ev­er, Ram not­ed that while T&T’s econ­o­my is “much more” ad­vanced than Bar­ba­dos this coun­try still needs to con­tin­u­ous­ly re­form and im­prove its busi­ness en­vi­ron­ment to make it more en­abling es­pe­cial­ly for en­tre­pre­neurs to bring their ideas to fruition.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored