JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, February 14, 2025

Minister slams ‘lying WASA manager’, says major shake-up coming for 2021

by

Shaliza Hassanali
1517 days ago
20201220
Minister of Public Utilities Marvin Gonzales, right, chats with Paramin residents during a visit to the area earlier this month.

Minister of Public Utilities Marvin Gonzales, right, chats with Paramin residents during a visit to the area earlier this month.

A ma­jor shake-up is ex­pect­ed to take place soon at state-owned Wa­ter and Sew­er­age Au­thor­i­ty (WASA), as Min­is­ter of Pub­lic Util­i­ties Mar­vin Gon­za­les moves to make the or­gan­i­sa­tion ef­fi­cient come 2021.

Part of the re­struc­tur­ing ex­er­cise may lead to job loss­es, a cut in over­time, an over­haul of the man­age­ment, and will in­clude the in­tro­duc­tion of tech­nol­o­gy to de­tect leak­ing pipelines and low wa­ter pres­sure in com­mu­ni­ties.

Minister of Public Utilities Marvin Gonzales.

Minister of Public Utilities Marvin Gonzales.

Michael Ramsingh

The dis­clo­sure came from Gon­za­les last week, just days af­ter a de­tailed re­port on WASA’s lin­ger­ing is­sues along with rec­om­men­da­tions to trans­form the be­lea­guered or­gan­i­sa­tion in­to a pro­duc­tive and prof­itable one was sub­mit­ted to Prime Min­is­ter Dr Kei­th Row­ley for re­view. For decades, WASA has been plagued with a host of prob­lems that no gov­ern­ment has been able to ad­dress.

In Sep­tem­ber, Row­ley ap­point­ed a Cab­i­net sub-com­mit­tee chaired by Gon­za­les and in­clud­ed min­is­ters Don­na Cox, Pen­ne­lope Beck­les and Franklin Khan to look in­to the op­er­a­tions of WASA and come up with a com­pre­hen­sive plan to turn around the cash-strapped com­pa­ny.

Gon­za­les, who did not re­veal the con­tent of the re­port, said he was dis­sat­is­fied with WASA’s ser­vice to com­mu­ni­ties, lack of staff ac­count­abil­i­ty, hefty over­time bills, and the mil­lion-dol­lar bonus­es paid out to work­ers. He is al­so un­hap­py that WASA is fac­ing mount­ing debts and a stag­ger­ing $600 mil­lion owed to con­trac­tors which can­not be ac­count­ed for by the au­thor­i­ty.

Gon­za­les, who as­sumed of­fice in Au­gust, said he nev­er an­tic­i­pat­ed WASA to be in such “a bad and chron­ic state.”

He said WASA which was op­er­at­ing on “au­topi­lot”, is “dys­func­tion­al” and in a “cri­sis”.

The min­is­ter said a lot of things tak­ing place at the au­thor­i­ty were “un­ac­cept­able and wor­ry­ing” as pay­ing cus­tomers de­serve a re­li­able wa­ter sup­ply.

Minister of Public Utilities Marvin Gonzales, left, with WASA officials.

Minister of Public Utilities Marvin Gonzales, left, with WASA officials.

Mis­led by man­ag­er, some not do­ing their jobs

Gon­za­les said he had sol­id ev­i­dence that some of WASA’s man­agers were not do­ing their jobs.

A month ago, Gon­za­les said he asked WASA’s tech­ni­cal staff to find out why Paramin res­i­dents were not re­ceiv­ing wa­ter. First, he was told some is­sues need­ed to be sort­ed out. Then he got a re­port stat­ing that every­thing was OK.

“The last re­port I got was that the en­tire com­mu­ni­ty was get­ting an ef­fi­cient wa­ter sup­ply. But the res­i­dents kept telling me a dif­fer­ent sto­ry, they were still not get­ting wa­ter.”

Re­al­is­ing some­thing was wrong, Gon­za­les said he vis­it­ed Paramin with a WASA man­age­ment team on­ly to find out from res­i­dents that their taps had been dry for weeks.

“In oth­er words, I was be­ing mis­led by the man­age­ment of WASA as to the true sit­u­a­tion tak­ing place on the ground. Can you imag­ine if the Prime Min­is­ter had asked me what was the sit­u­a­tion in Paramin? I would have re­port­ed to him what was re­port­ed to me by se­nior man­age­ment in WASA.”

This, he said, was un­ac­cept­able.

He said some man­agers work­ing in var­i­ous re­gions had not been in­form­ing their boss­es about prob­lems on the ground so cor­rec­tive ac­tion can be tak­en.

Gon­za­les said equal­ly shock­ing was that no dis­ci­pli­nary ac­tion had been tak­en against the man­ag­er who had de­ceived him.

Asked if he was in sup­port of work­ers be­ing sus­pend­ed or rep­ri­mand­ed for fail­ing to car­ry out their du­ties, Gon­za­les said he pre­ferred to hold peo­ple ac­count­able for their ac­tions or lack there­of.

“In any se­ri­ous or­gan­i­sa­tion or coun­try, he (man­ag­er) would have been placed on sus­pen­sion al­ready. If you can­not trust the in­for­ma­tion pro­vid­ed to you, it paints a very dark pic­ture as to what you are deal­ing with in that or­gan­i­sa­tion. The prob­lem in­side of WASA is bad man­age­ment.”

He said if these is­sues con­tin­ue at WASA “we will on­ly be spin­ning top in mud.”

Gon­za­les said the time had come “to take the bull by its horns.”

Flashback: Customers line up to enter WASA's office in San Fernando, in May.

Flashback: Customers line up to enter WASA's office in San Fernando, in May.

RISHI RAGOONATH

Man­age­ment op­er­at­ing in si­los

Gon­za­les re­vealed that WASA’s out­dat­ed or­gan­i­sa­tion­al struc­ture must be re­viewed and stream­lined.

“There are too many lev­els of man­age­ment...there are about sev­en or eight lev­els of man­age­ment which makes it al­most a night­mare to man­age. It’s dif­fi­cult to send in­for­ma­tion down from the top and vice ver­sa be­cause of the var­i­ous lev­els. They all op­er­ate in si­los. There is no in­ter­con­nec­tiv­i­ty.” WASA has 50 man­agers.

As a cit­i­zen, Gon­za­les said he was “very dis­ap­point­ed that such an im­por­tant or­gan­i­sa­tion as WASA had reached to this lev­el where it can­not pro­vide an ef­fi­cient ser­vice to the peo­ple of this coun­try.” He said he was fed up of com­plaints from com­mu­ni­ties, cus­tomers, cit­i­zens, and MPs about WASA’s poor sup­ply.

“From the Prime Min­is­ter straight down. The Prime Min­is­ter has to com­plain to his Min­is­ter of Pub­lic Util­i­ties that there are ar­eas in Care­nage and his con­stituen­cy not get­ting wa­ter. I find that is most em­bar­rass­ing.”

Asked if we can ex­pect a man­age­r­i­al shake-up at WASA soon, Gon­za­les replied,

“There must be a man­age­r­i­al shake-up. It’s im­pos­si­ble to man­age the com­pa­ny with this (cur­rent) man­age­r­i­al struc­ture. It can­not be busi­ness as usu­al.”

Go­ing for­ward, Gon­za­les said work­ers will al­so be grad­ed on their per­for­mance.

Gon­za­les said he has no in­ten­tion of play­ing pol­i­tics with WASA and Pub­lic Ser­vices’ As­so­ci­a­tion pres­i­dent Wat­son Duke, as all con­stituen­cies have been suf­fer­ing for wa­ter for too long.

“I don’t have time for that. What has to be done will be done.”

Flashback: Dow Village, Balmain and Esperanza residents protest outside the WASA pumping station demanding their communities get a supply of water. Looking on, at right, is Couva South MP Rudy Indarsingh.

Flashback: Dow Village, Balmain and Esperanza residents protest outside the WASA pumping station demanding their communities get a supply of water. Looking on, at right, is Couva South MP Rudy Indarsingh.

Shastri Boodan

WASA over­staffed, work­ers must be held ac­count­able

Gon­za­les dis­missed re­ports of WASA be­ing pri­va­tised but ad­mit­ted the or­gan­i­sa­tion is over­staffed. He said WASA’s staff to man­age­ment ra­tio was very high when com­pared to in­ter­na­tion­al wa­ter com­pa­nies and the mat­ter must be looked in­to.

“I have seen doc­u­ments and a num­ber of re­ports dur­ing this in­ves­ti­ga­tion that WASA is over­staffed. We have to look at it. All the re­ports point to the fact that WASA is over­staffed.

“But this is some­thing I am cer­tain we will have to look at. It is some­thing you would have to tread on gin­ger­ly, as you are talk­ing about peo­ple’s bread and but­ter.”

Gon­za­les said he knows that work­ers are very con­cerned whether or not they would have their jobs in 2021.

A 2012 re­port com­piled by WASA showed that in an at­tempt to get fund­ing from the In­ter-Amer­i­can De­vel­op­ment Bank, one con­di­tion­al­i­ty was that the au­thor­i­ty un­der­takes an ur­gent staff ra­tio­nal­i­sa­tion ex­er­cise. This was done by the pre­vi­ous Peo­ple’s Part­ner­ship gov­ern­ment.

Gon­za­les said WASA need­ed to get 2,500 of its 5000 em­ploy­ees out of the or­gan­i­sa­tion. He said 1,000 em­ploy­ees ac­cept­ed VSEP which “cost the peo­ple of this coun­try $400 mil­lion.”

By 2015 how­ev­er, Gon­za­les said, WASA’s work­force re­turned to its orig­i­nal fig­ure of 5,000.

“In my view, WASA has been op­er­at­ing with­out strate­gic guid­ance. If you can get man­age­ment right in WASA to hold peo­ple (work­ers) ac­count­able for their re­spec­tive re­gions, 60 to 70 per cent of the prob­lems at the or­gan­i­sa­tion can be dealt with.

“We have to change the phi­los­o­phy in which we ap­proach the man­age­ment of a crit­i­cal sec­tor like WASA. In this coun­try, if you don’t hold peo­ple ac­count­able it’s ole mas and J’Ou­vert morn­ing every sin­gle day.

“Peo­ple must be held ac­count­able and once you start to go down that road, I can as­sure the peo­ple of T&T you will see an im­prove­ment in your wa­ter sup­ply.”

Il­le­gal con­nec­tions per­va­sive in T&T

Gon­za­les’ vis­it to Paramin al­so un­earthed that sev­er­al res­i­dents had il­le­gal wa­ter con­nec­tions.

“These il­le­gal con­nec­tions have been pre­vent­ing wa­ter from go­ing to le­git­i­mate cus­tomers. Il­le­gal con­nec­tions in the coun­try are very per­va­sive.”

Gon­za­les said he man­dat­ed WASA’s new board head­ed by Dr Lennox Sealy to un­der­take an au­dit of WASA’s le­git­i­mate cus­tomers and iden­ti­fy those who have been il­le­gal­ly ob­tain­ing wa­ter so they can be­come pay­ing cus­tomers.

If they fail to com­ply, they will be dis­con­nect­ed, he added.

“The ev­i­dence is that 40 per cent of the wa­ter WASA pro­duces is not ac­count­ed for as a re­sult of leaks and il­le­gal con­nec­tions which is a loss of rev­enue and wastages tak­ing place.”

WASA pro­duces 220 mil­lion gal­lons of wa­ter dai­ly. While WASA los­es mil­lions of gal­lons of wa­ter an­nu­al­ly through age­ing in­fra­struc­ture, Gon­za­les said in­stalling new pipelines would on­ly solve part of the prob­lem.

He said for de­prived com­mu­ni­ties to get a reg­u­lar wa­ter sup­ply WASA has to pro­vide tech­no­log­i­cal and pres­sure man­age­ment sup­port.

“You can put in new lines, but if you do not have prop­er wa­ter pres­sure man­age­ment, the pipes are go­ing to rup­ture.”

He said WASA has to in­vest in tech­nol­o­gy which can in­form its work­ers when there is in­suf­fi­cient wa­ter or too much pres­sure in their sys­tem or a leak­ing pipeline.

WASA’s $90 mil­lion over­time bill

Gon­za­les said in the re­port of the Cab­i­net sub-com­mit­tee, “we have out­lined a work pro­gramme.”

He said the first thing WASA has to do is pro­vide wa­ter to com­mu­ni­ties ac­cord­ing to its sched­ule and re­build cus­tomers’ trust.

“You can come with the biggest plan to trans­form WASA if that plan does not have the re­build­ing of trust, then that plan will go nowhere.”

An­oth­er bug­bear, Gon­za­les said, was WASA’s $90 mil­lion year­ly over­time bill.

Each month, WASA pays $91 mil­lion in wages to its em­ploy­ees.

“And you are spend­ing $8 mil­lion an­nu­al­ly in all kinds of bonus­es and al­lowances. Yet still, you are com­plain­ing that you don’t have mon­ey to buy sim­ple plumb­ing tools to do the job. The is­sue is not mon­ey. The is­sue is man­age­ment. $90 mil­lion in over­time is ridicu­lous.”

He said this is­sue stemmed from the col­lec­tive bar­gain­ing agree­ment ne­go­ti­at­ed be­tween the unions and WASA.

“WASA is a 24-hour op­er­a­tion. How can you ne­go­ti­ate a col­lec­tive bar­gain­ing agree­ment on an 8 am to 4 pm work ba­sis?... That any­thing af­ter 4 pm is deemed to be over­time.”

Workers from WASA’s Pipeline Maintenance Department fix a leaking line along Independence Avenue, San Fernando, in May.

Workers from WASA’s Pipeline Maintenance Department fix a leaking line along Independence Avenue, San Fernando, in May.

KRISTIAN DE SILVA

Bonus­es not tied to per­for­mance

Gon­za­les said he dis­cov­ered that WASA paid bonus­es to work­ers who did not utilise their sick leave.

“But you don’t have the doc­u­men­tary ev­i­dence to sug­gest or to point to the fact that per­son A or B was on the job at a par­tic­u­lar point in time.

“Who pays a bonus for per­sons not tak­ing sick leave?”

He said these bonus­es were not tied to per­for­mances which makes “it a free-for-all at the or­gan­i­sa­tion.”

The ques­tion: Should an un­der­per­form­ing state en­ter­prise pay bonus­es to em­ploy­ees?

“If bonus­es are tied to per­for­mances that is a dif­fer­ent sto­ry. I am all about sup­port­ing and pay­ing bonus­es to em­ploy­ees who per­form and when there is an im­prove­ment in ser­vices,” Gon­za­les said.

He dis­closed that WASA’s em­ploy­ees re­ceive far bet­ter salaries com­pared to work­ers in the util­i­ty sec­tor.

Over the last decade, he said, the Gov­ern­ment had pumped $21 bil­lion in­to WASA.

“What have we got­ten for $21 bil­lion?” he asked.

WASA re­ceived $1 bil­lion in the 2021 fis­cal pack­age as op­posed to the $1.6 bil­lion it had re­quest­ed.

“A lot of the monies go­ing in­to WASA are not go­ing in­to items that can re­sult in an im­prove­ment of ser­vice to the peo­ple.”

Re­cent­ly, the Reg­u­lat­ed In­dus­tries Com­mis­sion (RIC) ad­vised that they be­gan a price re­view process for WASA.

The process in­volved three stages with the RIC pub­lish­ing its fi­nal de­ter­mi­na­tion af­ter re­view­ing all com­ments and con­cerns raised dur­ing pub­lic con­sul­ta­tions.

WASA’s last rate in­crease was in 1993.

Gon­za­les said the role of the RIC is not about in­creas­ing rates but hav­ing bench­marks to en­sure the ef­fi­cient de­liv­ery of the util­i­ty ser­vice.

“In look­ing for a tar­iff in­crease for wa­ter in T&T the process en­tails WASA pro­duc­ing a com­pre­hen­sive busi­ness plan to the RIC. So, it is not about get­ting up one morn­ing to raise the rate. The RIC will not ap­prove an in­crease in tar­iff if WASA does not demon­strate how it will im­prove its in­ef­fi­cien­cies. You can­not ask peo­ple of T&T to pay more for wa­ter and that mon­ey will be used to fund in­ef­fi­cien­cies.”

$4 bil­lion in debts, WASA un­able to ver­i­fy $600 mil­lion owed to con­trac­tors

He said the Gov­ern­ment would have to make tough de­ci­sions for WASA to be­come fi­nan­cial­ly sus­tain­able as its debts stood at $4 bil­lion.

“Then we have an­oth­er night­mare with­in the or­gan­i­sa­tion, near­ly $600 mil­lion of un­record­ed li­a­bil­i­ty, mean­ing that $600 mil­lion in debts owed to con­trac­tors, with WASA not hav­ing the ca­pac­i­ty to ver­i­fy those bills due to mis­man­age­ment. Some of these con­trac­tors have tak­en WASA to court and WASA has been los­ing those mat­ters be­cause the records at WASA can­not sub­stan­ti­ate the debt. It puts WASA at a dis­ad­van­ta­geous po­si­tion.”

WASA


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored