Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar has announced a sweeping review of State property rentals, describing the nearly half a billion dollars spent in fiscal 2024 on leased buildings as “dead money” that reflects wasteful expenditure and poor oversight of public resources.
“Governmental rentals, this has caused billions of dollars to be spent without transparency. The total spent on the last fiscal year alone, fiscal 2024, was 493 million dollars. This is like dead money because it is not like you getting anything from it back.”
Speaking at yesterday’s post-Cabinet briefing, Persad-Bissessar also disclosed findings from a Ministry of Public Administration’s master list tracking State property leases.
According to the latest figures, there are currently 235 active leases but of these, 193 expired.
Even more alarming, the Prime Minister said, was the emergence of what she referred to as “ghost rentals,” leases for properties where there appeared to be little to no evidence of actual government occupation or usage.
“The rent paid by government ministries and agencies do not match the figure on a master list of properties rented by government, which is provided by the Ministry out of Public Admin. Some of the properties for which rents are paid, are being paid, are not even on the master list. I don’t know if you want to call them ghost rentals, but the government is paying almost half a billion dollars a year in rentals.”
Persad-Bissessar has expressed deep concern over an unexplained $208 million variance in government rental expenditures for the year 2024 and asserted that the discrepancy between recorded rental allocations and actual payments raised serious questions about oversight and financial management.
“There are variances in the rent paid versus rent on the master list of 21.8 million for the Judiciary, for example, 24.8 for the Ministry of Finance, 47.9 million for the Ministry of Health, 31.4 million for TTPS, 10.6 for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. This is just a few of them.”
Persad-Bissessar also took aim at landlords collecting rent without proper approvals or contracts.
“Two companies, GV Holdings and NJ Nahous Investments LTD, were paid over 15 million in rent per year in properties rented by government and regrettably, there are no current leases. And there are others, paid over 15 million in rent per year, rented by government and there is no current lease and no cabinet approval.”
According to the Prime Minister, rental properties belonging to relatives of former People’s National Movement (PNM) government minister Faris Al-Rawi allegedly cost taxpayers $1.7 million per month.
She provided a further breakdown of government-leased properties across the country.
“The majority of the leases are for the following locations: costs per month, Port-of-Spain, 66 leases, 9.5 million. San Juan, 17 leases, 1.3 million. San Fernando, 1.3 million, 22 leases. Chaguanas 0.6 million, 10 leases, Arima 0.5 million, 11 leases.”
Asked whether there were grounds for a police investigation into the discovery of rental inconsistencies, which could be tantamount to fraud, Public Administration Minister Dominic Smith indicated that the necessary processes will be followed.
“At this time, we won’t proffer too much information as we are in the assessment phase but keep in mind as the Prime Minister would have outlined, most ministers are in office about 3 weeks now and give (sic) the time to go through the proper process and procedure. We are a Government of transparency and in due time all will be brought to light.”
The Prime Minister highlighted that without lease agreements, the Government has no formal recourse to enforce obligations such as building maintenance and security.
“No one can confirm whether these properties still meet the criteria for rental or requisite approvals for fire, health and safety and other areas of concern.”
Persad-Bissessar noted that the most expensive rental per square foot was in Port-of-Spain and reiterated the need to decentralise. She said Government has to find ways of cost-cutting” and that they planned to renegotiate downwards the prices of rentals with landlords and make moves to acquire its own properties.