JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, February 23, 2025

Gun Talk

T&T’s firearms dilem­ma

by

231 days ago
20240707

Close to three years af­ter their re­la­tion­ship turned sour, the gun talk be­tween Prime Min­is­ter Dr Kei­th Row­ley and for­mer Com­mis­sion­er of Po­lice, and Na­tion­al Trans­for­ma­tion Al­liance (NTA) leader Gary Grif­fith con­tin­ues.

Last Wednes­day was the lat­est chap­ter in emo­tive ex­changes be­tween the two, with Dr Row­ley re­peat­ing the claim in Par­lia­ment that there were nu­mer­ous anom­alies in the is­suance of FULs dur­ing Grif­fith’s stint as head of the po­lice ser­vice—some­thing Grif­fith again de­nied.

The NTA Leader ac­cused the Prime Min­is­ter of hav­ing a ‘dan­ger­ous in­fat­u­a­tion” with le­gal firearms - one, he claims, con­tin­ues to over­shad­ow the scourge of il­le­gal firearms.

Guardian Me­dia In­ves­ti­ga­tions Desk looks at T&T’s gun dilem­ma.

Se­nior Mul­ti­me­dia Jour­nal­ist

joshua.seemu­n­gal@guardian.co.tt

Al­though for­mer Com­mis­sion­er of Po­lice Gary Grif­fith is­sued be­tween 6,000 to 7,000 firearm li­cences be­tween Au­gust 2018 and Sep­tem­ber 2021, rep­re­sent­ing ap­prox­i­mate­ly 36 per cent of all reg­is­tered own­ers, T&T has one of the low­est rates of reg­is­tered gun own­er­ship in Cari­com.

As of 2022, T&T had 19,434 reg­is­tered firearms, rank­ing eighth in Cari­com for the most reg­is­tered firearms per 100 res­i­dents, with an av­er­age of 1.27, ac­cord­ing to da­ta from the 2023 Cari­com Im­pacs’ Weapon Com­pass Caribbean Firearms Study.

T&T’s fig­ure was based on 2022 sta­tis­tics.

Suri­name (5.46), Be­lize (3.47), St Vin­cent (2.70), Ja­maica (1.85), An­tigua and Bar­bu­da (1.68) and St. Lu­cia (1.50) all had more reg­is­tered firearm own­ers per 100 res­i­dents.

In 2008, the T&T Po­lice Ser­vice (TTPS) es­ti­mat­ed that there were 10,550 firearm li­cence hold­ers in the coun­try, mean­ing that there was ap­prox­i­mate­ly an 84 per cent in­crease in firearm li­cence hold­ers be­tween 2008 and 2022.

Ac­cord­ing to the Cari­com Im­pacs study, le­gal firearm own­er­ship in the re­gion is tight­ly reg­u­lat­ed and there is a low rate of le­gal civil­ian firearm own­er­ship com­pared with the glob­al av­er­age. How­ev­er, when it comes to homi­cides, the area has three times the glob­al av­er­age for vi­o­lent deaths, with more than half of homi­cides in­volv­ing the use of firearms.

“Ja­maica, Haiti, Trinidad and To­ba­go, and the Ba­hamas are among the coun­tries with the high­est per­cent­ages of firearms-re­lat­ed homi­cides at 90, 84,78, and 75 per cent of to­tal homi­cides,” the re­port said.

The re­port stat­ed that smug­gled or lo­cal­ly-made guns (il­le­gal­ly owned) are wide­ly as­sumed to “great­ly out­num­ber legal­ly owned firearms.”

The Strate­gic Ser­vices Agency (SSA) es­ti­mat­ed in 2022 that there were at least 12,000 il­le­gal firearms in the coun­try.

Crim­i­nol­o­gist Dr Dau­rius Figueira has been on record say­ing that he be­lieves the re­al fig­ure is “three times more than that.” Oth­er crim­i­nol­o­gists have al­so stat­ed the fig­ure is like­ly high­er than the SSA’s es­ti­mate.

Il­le­gal guns have wreaked hav­oc on the streets of T&T.

More than 4,719 peo­ple were mur­dered be­tween 2014 and Sep­tem­ber 2023, with il­le­gal guns ac­count­ing for be­tween 75 and 80 per cent of killings. Il­le­gal firearms were used in 8,472 fa­tal and non-fa­tal se­ri­ous crimes be­tween 2016-2022 alone, ac­cord­ing to SSA da­ta.

“Do­mes­tic sources of il­lic­it small arms and am­mu­ni­tion gen­er­al­ly in­clude the di­ver­sion of na­tion­al stock­piles held by de­fence and se­cu­ri­ty agen­cies, the di­ver­sion of civil­ian hold­ings, il­lic­it ‘craft’ pro­duc­tion, and the re­cir­cu­la­tion of al­ready il­lic­it weapons in the un­der­ground mar­ket.

“Most Caribbean of­fi­cials in­ter­viewed—and of­fi­cial doc­u­men­ta­tion re­viewed—by the sur­vey in­di­cat­ed that the ma­jor­i­ty of il­lic­it firearms come from abroad, in­clud­ing from neigh­bour­ing states and the US main­land. In some coun­tries, the il­lic­it firearms are then loaned or sold by crim­i­nal or­gan­i­sa­tions to their mem­bers or oth­er il­lic­it end users.

“These claims were echoed by many of the in­mates in­ter­viewed in Be­lize, Suri­name, and Trinidad and To­ba­go for this project, the ma­jor­i­ty of whom in­di­cat­ed that they (or the crim­i­nal or­gan­i­sa­tions in which they were in­volved) ac­quired their firearms from for­eign sources. Their re­spons­es are not sur­pris­ing giv­en the strict con­trols on the sale and pos­ses­sion of firearms and am­mu­ni­tion in many Caribbean states, and the com­par­a­tive­ly lim­it­ed num­ber of do­mes­tic sources (di­ver­sion points) of arms and am­mu­ni­tion in these states,” the Cari­com Im­pacs’ re­port said.

How­ev­er, de­spite the threat posed by il­le­gal firearms, the num­ber of il­le­gal guns re­cov­ered by the TTPS de­clined by 33 per cent be­tween 2018 and 2023. Dur­ing that pe­ri­od, ac­cord­ing to sta­tis­tics pro­vid­ed by Na­tion­al Se­cu­ri­ty Min­is­ter Fitzger­ald Hinds in Par­lia­ment ear­li­er this year, 4,956 il­le­gal firearms and 104,737 rounds of am­mu­ni­tion were re­cov­ered. The high­est num­ber of re­cov­er­ies of il­lic­it firearms, 988, came in 2018. The low­est was in 2021, with 681 firearms. In 2023, 709 firearms were re­cov­ered.

Nyree Al­fon­so, di­rec­tor of the Firearms Train­ing In­sti­tute Lim­it­ed, said there is an un­healthy, un­ex­plained con­cen­tra­tion on le­gal firearm own­ers by the Gov­ern­ment.

“To me, it makes no sense. It is down­right strange to have this pro­lif­er­a­tion of crime in the coun­try com­mit­ted by il­le­gal firearms by the crim­i­nal el­e­ments, un­less you have co­gent and com­pelling proof it is com­ing from the le­gal deal­ers, then shut up or put up.

“I agree with Gary, come and ar­rest us if you think we are flood­ing the mar­ket with am­mu­ni­tion. Ar­rest some­body, but un­til such time, why put the blame there? Cause those are con­ve­nient scape­goats? We don’t have a han­dle on crime. Con­cen­trate on that.

“We have an unar­guable in­flux of il­le­gal firearms and il­le­gal am­mu­ni­tion and you felt the plas­ter for that is to ban the le­gal im­por­ta­tion of arms and am­mu­ni­tion? I don’t see the cor­re­la­tion. TTPS and De­fence Force bul­lets have been turn­ing up on peo­ple’s crime scenes, did you ban am­mu­ni­tion from be­ing in their hands?” she said.

Al­fon­so, an at­tor­ney, suc­cess­ful­ly rep­re­sent­ed her hus­band Towfeek Ali, a firearms deal­er, in a 2023 law­suit against the Of­fice of the Po­lice Com­mis­sion­er over a de­lay in con­sid­er­ing ap­pli­ca­tions to im­port am­mu­ni­tion. The de­lay was ruled un­law­ful by Jus­tice Kevin Ram­cha­ran, paving the way for firearms deal­ers to re­sume im­por­ta­tions. The mat­ter was ap­pealed and is await­ing a ver­dict.

How­ev­er, ac­cord­ing to Al­fon­so, while the mat­ter was be­fore the courts, the Gov­ern­ment suc­cess­ful­ly lob­bied the US gov­ern­ment to “ef­fec­tive­ly ban” the le­gal im­por­ta­tion of arms and am­mu­ni­tion. In April, the US an­nounced new re­stric­tions on firearm im­ports in an at­tempt to lim­it the use of US-made guns in for­eign crim­i­nal ac­tiv­i­ty. Sev­er­al oth­er coun­tries, in­clud­ing Ja­maica, Yemen, Pe­ru, Guyana, Ecuador and Burk­i­na Fa­so, were placed on the re­stric­tive list, which Al­fon­so said com­pris­es coun­tries un­able to man­age the im­por­ta­tion of le­gal firearms and am­mu­ni­tion with­out di­ver­sion to il­le­gal caus­es.

Al­fon­so called the re­stric­tions coun­ter­pro­duc­tive as they don’t ad­dress the source of firearms and am­mu­ni­tion used for crimes and will re­sult in a short­age of am­mu­ni­tion and ex­pired am­mu­ni­tion be­ing used.

“You make a prob­lem and put a plas­ter on it, but you are still bleed­ing to death over there. We didn’t know that two years ago to this month, the then Act­ing Com­mis­sion­er of Po­lice Mc­Don­ald Ja­cob banned the le­gal im­por­ta­tion of arms and am­mu­ni­tion in­to Trinidad.

“He did so by sim­ply re­fus­ing to grant any ap­pli­ca­tions for arms and am­mu­ni­tion. That is 2022. How did that im­pact crime in the last two years? Do you think there was a fall-off in the num­bers with re­spect to crime af­ter that? Clear­ly not, and you are still find­ing all that am­mu­ni­tion out there, right? So clear­ly there is not a short­age of am­mu­ni­tion there.

“Those peo­ple (crim­i­nals) are not buy­ing from deal­ers. They are not in­ter­est­ed in im­port­ing and pay­ing VAT and du­ties on the am­mu­ni­tion. I am sure the po­lice know bet­ter than me where the il­le­gal firearms and am­mu­ni­tion are com­ing from and be­ing stored and what’s the source.

“I am ab­solute­ly cer­tain it’s not the deal­ers...So what are you try­ing to tell me, that a crim­i­nal could bring in an AR-15, which we (le­gal deal­ers) can’t by the way —au­to­mat­ic AR-15—if you could bring in the gun, you not go­ing to be able to bring in the am­mu­ni­tion for it? You are go­ing to look for a le­gal deal­er to get you il­le­gal am­mu­ni­tion for it?” she ar­gued.

Al­fon­so dis­missed the Prime Min­is­ter’s ref­er­enc­ing of an au­dit which not­ed that in­di­vid­ual deal­ers were grant­ed mil­lions of rounds of as­sort­ed am­mu­ni­tion and tens of thou­sands of guns. She said im­port­ing that quan­ti­ty of am­mu­ni­tion makes lit­tle busi­ness sense as am­mu­ni­tion ex­pires and there isn’t a large enough de­mand to sell those prod­ucts in that amount.

Guardian Me­dia re­quest­ed in­for­ma­tion from the TTPS about the num­ber of homi­cides com­mit­ted with le­gal firearms in the last five years but the re­quest was on­ly ac­knowl­edged by the Crime and Prob­lem Analy­sis Branch which in­di­cat­ed that the Cor­po­rate Com­mu­ni­ca­tions De­part­ment has to send the re­quest. Cor­po­rate Com­mu­ni­ca­tions did not re­spond to the re­quest up to press time.

Last Wednes­day, quot­ing in­for­ma­tion from the Bar­ring­ton/Pritchard re­port in Par­lia­ment, Prime Min­is­ter Row­ley said around 100 le­gal firearms were used in mur­ders, sui­cides and rob­beries be­tween 2017 and 2021. He added that based on in­tel­li­gence re­ceived from for­eign part­ners, 30 firearms im­port­ed by li­censed firearms deal­ers were found in the pos­ses­sion of peo­ple who were not Firearm User Li­cence (FUL) hold­ers and were al­so used in crimes. This con­tra­dicts Grif­fith’s claim that no le­gal firearms were used to com­mit crimes dur­ing his tenure as CoP.

The re­port read by Dr Row­ley stat­ed that sev­er­al TTPS of­fi­cers were in­volved in the lu­cra­tive busi­ness side of the ac­qui­si­tion and train­ing of civil­ians and cer­tain mem­bers of the TTPS and some firearms deal­ers were charg­ing large sums of mon­ey for suc­cess­ful ap­pli­ca­tions for FULs.

“Ad­di­tion­al­ly, Madam Speak­er, dur­ing the pe­ri­od Au­gust 2018 and Sep­tem­ber 2021, there was an enor­mous rise in the grant of im­port per­mits to cer­tain favoured firearm deal­ers for the im­por­ta­tion of firearms, am­mu­ni­tion, and firearm com­po­nents/ac­ces­sories on a reg­u­lar ba­sis. Of all the firearm deal­ers in Trinidad and To­ba­go, on­ly 15 were heav­i­ly ac­tive and seemed to be favoured.

“In one case, Madam Speak­er, an in­di­vid­ual re­ceived a Deal­er’s Li­cence in 2020 and then pro­ceed­ed to im­port 11,810 firearms; 1,090,000 rounds of am­mu­ni­tion and 330,000 com­po­nent parts and ac­ces­sories,” Dr Row­ley read in Par­lia­ment.

Grif­fith re­ject­ed the ac­cu­sa­tions, ac­cus­ing the Prime Min­is­ter of us­ing par­lia­men­tary priv­i­lege to spread lies. Fol­low­ing Grif­fith’s con­tro­ver­sial ex­it from the TTPS, two re­ports and an in­quiry were com­mis­sioned in­to the FUL li­cense sys­tem un­der his tenure.

The first was done by Re­tired As­sis­tant CoP Arthur Bar­ring­ton and Re­tired Chief of De­fence Staff, Rear Ad­mi­ral Hay­den Pritchard. The sec­ond re­port, the Craig Re­port, was done by a team of four re­tired Se­nior po­lice of­fi­cers and four serv­ing po­lice of­fi­cers. The in­quiry was con­duct­ed by re­tired Jus­tice of Ap­peal Stan­ley John, ap­point­ed by the Po­lice Ser­vice Com­mis­sion.

In De­cem­ber 2022, Grif­fith suc­cess­ful­ly filed an in­junc­tion that pre­vent­ed Row­ley from lay­ing the John re­port in Par­lia­ment. Grif­fith said he was not al­lowed an op­por­tu­ni­ty to re­spond to the re­port’s find­ings and ex­pressed con­cern that the Prime Min­is­ter could make un­sub­stan­ti­at­ed claims us­ing par­lia­men­tary priv­i­lege.

Com­ing out of the TTPS in­ves­ti­ga­tion in­to the FUL mat­ter, more than 25 charges have been laid. In 2022, five po­lice of­fi­cers were charged: PC­sChris Tirbinaie and Lyn­don Bish­op, two counts of so­lic­it­ing and re­ceiv­ing; Cpl Ka­reem Jamaldin, so­lic­it­ing $25,000 to ex­pe­dite an FUL; Sgt Swan­son, ten counts of mis­be­hav­iour in pub­lic of­fice; ASP Be­deau, five counts of mis­be­hav­iour in pub­lic of­fice.

Two civil­ians, Dil­lon and Mukesh Go­sine, were al­so charged. In ear­ly 2023, eight po­lice of­fi­cers were charged with con­spir­a­cy to mis­con­duct them­selves in pub­lic of­fice.

The firearm de­bate has been be­fore the courts sev­er­al times over the years, with busi­ness own­ers and in­di­vid­u­als lob­by­ing to arm them­selves against what they de­scribe as a grow­ing crim­i­nal threat.

In Jan­u­ary, the High Court or­dered Com­mis­sion­er of Po­lice Er­la Hare­wood-Cristo­pher to de­cide on 33 FUL ap­pli­ca­tions by ear­ly May. The High Court al­so ruled that the CoP’s de­lay was un­rea­son­able and un­law­ful.

The CoP’s de­fence, among oth­er things, was that the in­ter­nal in­ves­ti­ga­tion in­to the FUL sys­tem ex­ac­er­bat­ed a long-ex­ist­ing back­log.

Two weeks ago, an­oth­er two busi­ness­men were per­mit­ted to chal­lenge the CoP on the de­lay of their ap­pli­ca­tions. One of them with­drew his law­suit af­ter Hare­wood-Christo­pher agreed to de­cide on his ap­pli­ca­tion with­in six months.

Sev­er­al peo­ple al­so made sim­i­lar le­gal claims against for­mer act­ing CoP Stephen Williams. In 2018, the High Court or­dered Williams to grant a gun li­cense to na­tion­al shoot­er Robert Auer­bach who sued over a six-year de­lay in con­sid­er­ing his ap­pli­ca­tion.

The de­lays are noth­ing new. There has been a sub­stan­tial back­log in the firearm ap­pli­ca­tion process for some time. In Au­gust 2021, for­mer CoP Gary Grif­fith said there was a 50,000 ap­pli­cant back­log for FULs when he en­tered of­fice in late 2018. He said it would have tak­en 25 years, at his rate of FUL ap­provals, for all re­quests to be processed. Be­fore he was ap­point­ed CoP, he said there were an av­er­age of 400 firearms li­cens­es is­sued an­nu­al­ly.

The gun de­bate, rem­i­nis­cent of the US po­lit­i­cal scene, has even made its way to pol­i­cy.

Op­po­si­tion Leader Kam­la Per­sad-Bisses­sar has made Stand Your Ground pro-le­gal firearm pol­i­cy a key com­po­nent of the par­ty’s gen­er­al elec­tion push. The for­mer Prime Min­is­ter ac­cused the Gov­ern­ment of hypocrisy, say­ing many min­is­ters can de­fend them­selves with le­gal guns but ob­ject to in­creased gun own­er­ship by the pub­lic.

The in­flux of guns in­to the re­gion has be­come a ma­jor is­sue in Cari­com’s re­la­tion­ship with the Unit­ed States. Cari­com has sought as­sis­tance from the US to crack down on gun man­u­fac­tur­ers ship­ping weapons il­le­gal­ly to the Caribbean.

An­tigua and Bar­bu­da, Be­lize, Ba­hamas, Ja­maica, St Vin­cent and the Grenadines and T&T joined a brief filed by Mex­i­co seek­ing to hold gun mak­ers re­spon­si­ble for fa­cil­i­tat­ing weapons traf­fick­ing across Latin Amer­i­ca and the Caribbean.

In late 2022, the US formed a re­gion­al Crime Gun In­tel­li­gence Unit and ap­point­ed Micheal Ben’Ary as co­or­di­na­tor for Caribbean Firearm Pros­e­cu­tion, an ini­tia­tive aimed at in­creas­ing the num­ber of pros­e­cu­tions and con­vic­tions of firearms traf­fick­ers.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored